WEATHER ALERT

Challenging evening commute ahead as rain, snow showers redevelop

Prosecutor frustrated by ‘frivolous’ motion to overturn local death sentence


Warren County Prosecutor David Fornshell called the latest motion filed to overturn a Clayton man’s death sentence frivolous and frustrating.

In the motion filed Tuesday in the Ohio Supreme Court, lawyer Elizabeth Orrick claims, among other things, that lawyers previously handling the appeal of Austin Myers, now 24, provided “ineffective counsel” in the appeal filed on Oct. 27, 2014.

Orrick also claimed Myers’ trial lawyers erred in his defense, and alleged misconduct by prosecutors and errors by Judge Donald Oda II should warrant reopening of the appeal.

RELATED: Former public defender wants to continue Clayton man’s death penalty appeal

“While we understand this is just another step in the process, frivolous motions like these are why it takes 15-20 years from the time someone receives the death sentence until it is actually carried out. It’s very frustrating not only for prosecutors, but more importantly, for the families of the victims,” Fornshell, who personally argued the case before the Ohio Supreme Court, said in a text-message response Wednesday.

Myers was convicted in 2014 of murdering a childhood friend, Justin Back, 18, of Wayne Twp., and sentenced to death. Back was about to join the U.S. Navy.

Myers was the youngest person on Ohio’s Death Row at the time.

Timothy Mosley, the other Clayton man charged in the case, entered a plea to life in prison without parole and cooperated with prosecutors.

RELATED: Local teen youngest on Ohio’s Death Row

“As can be seen from the meritorious issues that were not presented in this case, appellate counsel were prejudicially ineffective,” Orrick said in the motion.

Orrick urged the court to reopen the case because direct-appeal counsel failed to include a complete transcript “of all the proceedings against him.”

In addition, Orrick claims “direct appeal counsel’s failure to reconstruct the trial court’s repeated discussions with counsel that took place off the record.”

RELATED: Co-defendant pleads guilty in Warren County death penalty case

Orrick claims Myers’ trial lawyers should have moved for suppression of evidence against Myers on his cellphone, eliminated two jurors “who had been exposed to pretrial publicity” and renewed their request for a change of venue and continuance.

In addition, Orrick claims Myers’ trial lawyers should have called more witnesses about his mental health, helped him prepare his statement and “properly” challenged “Mosley’s purported notebook.”

RELATED: Notebook surfaces in Warren County death penalty case

RELATED: Clayton man step closer to execution

Myers’ trial lawyers, Greg Howard and John Kaspar, did contest the use of the notebook, found eight months after the alleged murder.

Lawyer Timothy McKenna argued for Myers’ life before the Ohio Supreme Court.

Myers is being held in the Chillicothe Correctional Institution.




Next Up in Crime

Judge delays ruling in CNN lawsuit against Trump over Jim Acosta White House ban
Judge delays ruling in CNN lawsuit against Trump over Jim Acosta White House ban

A judge is set to rule Friday in the lawsuit filed earlier this week by CNN against President Donald Trump and his top aides. Attorneys for the news network are arguing that Trump and his aides violated both the network’s and reporter Jim Acosta's constitutional rights when he was banned from the White House last week. Update 1:05 p.m. EST Nov...
Mark Wahlberg donates $20K to Ohio foster care organization
Mark Wahlberg donates $20K to Ohio foster care organization

Actor Mark Wahlberg, who is promoting his new movie “Instant Family,” donated $20,000 to an Ohio foster care organization. Walhberg, and business partner Jay Feldman, made the donation to Buckeye Ranch, an organization that operates foster homes in 23 counties in Central and Southern Western Ohio. The organization serves children and...
Country musician Roy Clark, of 'Hee Haw' fame, dead at 85
Country musician Roy Clark, of 'Hee Haw' fame, dead at 85

Grammy-winning country musician Roy Clark, best known for co-hosting “Hee Haw,” has died at age 85. His publicist said in a news release that he died from complications from pneumonia in his Tulsa, Oklahoma, home. >> Read more trending news  In addition to work on “Hee Haw,” Clark was a Country Music Hall of Fame...
Pregnant Carrie Underwood reveals she's having another boy
Pregnant Carrie Underwood reveals she's having another boy

Carrie Underwood used some of her time hosting the CMA Awards Wednesday to announce she is having a second son. Billboard reported that, at the start of the show, Underwood shared her usual banter with longtime co-host Brad Paisley. >> Read more trending news  “Seriously Carrie, give me a little baby hint," Paisley said. &ldquo...
JCPenney earnings reports don’t show improvement
JCPenney earnings reports don’t show improvement

While JCPenney isn’t closing stores now, it’s not out of the question. The department store once again disappointed Wall Street with same-store sales dropping 5.4 percent last quarter and net sales decreasing 5.8 percent, according to a company statement. The company also lost more than $150 million, sending its stock price down 12 percent...
More Stories