Juvenile conviction can prevent someone from owning a gun as an adult, Ohio Supreme Court rules


In a 6-1 ruling issued Wednesday, the Ohio Supreme Court said that a juvenile conviction can be used to keep an adult from legally owning or possessing a firearm.

In 1994, at age 16 Anthony Carnes was convicted in juvenile court of felonious assault for punching another teen in the mouth, knocking out four teeth.

RELATED: 3-D gun debate: Ohio AG DeWine says ‘it is legal to make a gun’

Twenty years later, police in Hamilton County investigating a report of shots fired near Carnes’ home found DNA evidence on a gun linked to Carnes. He was charged with aggravated menacing and having a weapon under a disability — the basis for the disability charge was his juvenile conviction.

Carnes argued at trial that the disability charge should be dismissed, given he was not represented by an attorney in juvenile court in 1994. The trial court denied his request and he was convicted and sentenced to 30 months in prison. Carnes lost his subsequent appeal and again at the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court opinion noted that the weapons-under-disability law specifically states that people convicted or adjudicated as a juvenile of felony offenses or certain other offenses can be barred from carrying a firearm.

Supreme Court Chief Justice Maureen O’Connor dissented from the majority, saying that if an offense is serious enough, a juvenile can be tried in adult court. O’Connor said it’s “profoundly unfair” to have a juvenile act follow someone into adulthood without any time limit.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in News

Student of the Week Graham High School
Student of the Week Graham High School

Name: Chase Adams School: Graham High School Grade: 12 Age: 17 Extra-curricular: Basketball, Baseball, Student Senate, Freshman Focus Claim to fame/honors: 2nd team CBC, Falcon Pride Student of the Month, Honor Roll, perfect attendance for all of high school Words you live by: “The true test of a man’s character is how he handles adversity...
Athlete of the Week Graham High School
Athlete of the Week Graham High School

Name: Brady Oder School: Graham High School Grade: 12 Age: 17 Sports: Soccer, Bowling Claim to fame/honors: 1st Team CBC; 1st Team District Words you live by: “Live, Laugh, Love.” Toughest opponent: Life Biggest influence: My parents Game-day rituals: Just think about the game What’s on your bedroom walls: Paint and medals When I&rsquo...
Sheriff asks residents to stop bothering a vacationing Post Malone
Sheriff asks residents to stop bothering a vacationing Post Malone

The Morgan County Sheriff asked residents, mostly children, Friday to stop bothering entertainer Post Malone, who is in the area on vacation, officials said. >> Read more trending news  “If you see him out on the town feel free to say hello, he has been very kind and respectful to all who have talked to him,” officials said in...
Some flea-tick products increase seizure risk in pets, FDA says
Some flea-tick products increase seizure risk in pets, FDA says

Some flea and tick drugs could cause seizures and other neurological issues in pets, and owners should consult with their veterinarians to decide on an appropriate treatment, the Food and Drug Administration said.  >> Read more trending news  Some cats and dogs on Bravecto, Nexgard, Credelio and Simparica, which use isoxazoline...
Strip club closed after food stamps used to buy lap dances, drugs, investigators say
Strip club closed after food stamps used to buy lap dances, drugs, investigators say

The Ohio Liquor Control Commission revoked the liquor permit of Sharkey’s bar, an adult entertainment establishment, effective at the close of business Thursday, after investigators used food stamps to buy lap dances. >> Read more trending news  Agent-in-Charge Michelle Thourot said agents began investigating the Twenty Two Fifty Inc...
More Stories