West Liberty suspect asked victim to shoot him, report says

The alleged West Liberty-Salem High School shooter apologized to his victim and asked the fellow student to shoot him, according to a sheriff’s report obtained by the Springfield News-Sun that provides new details about the incident.

Student Ely Serna, 17, allegedly shot 16-year-old Logan Cole twice on Friday, then shot at a teacher before shooting classroom door windows, according to a report from the Champaign County Sheriff’s Office released Wednesday.

RELATED: West Liberty shooting victim has shotgun pellet in his heart

He then reportedly returned to Cole, turned the shotgun on himself, pressed his forehead to the muzzle and asked Cole to pull the trigger, the report says.

“According to Ely Ray Serna, Logan Cole refused to pull the trigger,” an affidavit by Champaign County Sheriff’s Detective Glenn Kemp says.

The affidavit, obtained by a public records request, says the suspect drove himself and sister to school, then waited in the car after she went into the building.

He snuck the weapon and shells into the school in his backpack, the affidavit says, along with a camouflage jacket and a homemade mask that had an “anarchy symbol” on it. Serna allegedly disassembled the shotgun and hid the parts in his backpack before reassembling it in a school bathroom stall. He then said the Lord’s Prayer, the report says.


School and law enforcement leaders have said over the past week that the shooting Friday occurred in a hallway at the school, but the affidavit says Cole was shot at random when he entered the restroom. Champaign County Sheriff Matthew Melvin said four shots were fired in the hallway, but Cole was shot in the bathroom.

Upon seeing Logan Cole enter the restroom, Serna allegedly fired two shotgun rounds at him, striking him in his side and the chest, the report says.

Serna allegedly told investigators that a teacher identified in the report as Mr. Thomas then walked in, according to the affidavit, and the suspect began to shoot at him. The suspect then left the restroom and allegedly began shooting at door windows before returning to Cole.

“He noticed that Logan Cole was not deceased due to seeing Logan Cole’s eyes blink,” Kemp says in the report. “Ely Ray Serna stated that he exclaimed, ‘You’re not dead?’ Ely Ray Serna stated that he apologized to Logan Cole.”

He then allegedly handed the weapon to Cole, the report says, and asked him to pull the trigger.

MORE: Sister of alleged West Liberty shooter speaks

After Cole refused to shoot Serna, the affidavit says Serna heard the voices of Middle/High School Principal Gregg Johnson and Assistant Principal Andy McGill.

“Ely Ray Serna advised that he then entered the same toilet stall as previously used, he indicated that he discarded the camouflage M60 field jacket vest and the (shotgun) onto the floor,” the affidavit states. “He indicated that he kicked the (shotgun) across the floor.”

He was found by McGill, who tackled him to the ground, the affidavit states.

A total of six shell casings were recovered at the scene, Kemp wrote. The affidavit states Serna received the shotgun for Christmas from his grandparents two years ago and that he also had a knife in the Jeep he drove to school.

The affidavit also identifies the second student who was injured in the shooting as Adam Schultz. He was hit by one pellet, according to authorities, and didn’t require treatment.

A motive behind the shooting wasn’t described in the report.

Next Up in Crime

Clark County Municipal Court cases
Clark County Municipal Court cases

CASES CALLED TUESDAY INCLUDED: Zackerey Q. Howald, 29, of 2802 Hemlock Dr., OVI amended to physical control, guilty, 60 days jail with 60 days suspended, 12 months probation, administrative license suspension remains, fined $525. Danyale A. Blair, 26, of New Carlisle, possession of drug abuse instrument, guilty, 30 days jail, credit for time served...
Hyperloop in Ohio? Two firms to study feasibility
Hyperloop in Ohio? Two firms to study feasibility

Two companies will begin studying the feasibility and environmental impact of a potential hyperloop connecting Columbus, Chicago and Pittsburgh. Hyperloop One is a worldwide challenge to create a transportation system that moves both people and products quickly. The hyperloop is expected to transport pods of people and goods through a tube —...
Trump: US-Mexico border 'a big mess'
Trump: US-Mexico border 'a big mess'

President Donald Trump called the U.S.-Mexico border “a big mess” on Thursday morning as the House prepared to vote on a pair of immigration bills. “I believe (the Department of Homeland Security) is working on that,” Ryan said Thursday at a news briefing. “We obviously want to have families reunited.” He said...
50 best restaurants in the world: Where are they, how many in the US?
50 best restaurants in the world: Where are they, how many in the US?

If you want a seat at the world’s best restaurant, you had better make reservations.  It has only 12 tables.Osteria Francescana, a restaurant in Modena, Italy, took the top ranking as the world's best restaurant for the second time in three years in a survey from The World’s 50 Best. The ranking includes restaurants in 23 countries...
Clark County Common Pleas Court cases
Clark County Common Pleas Court cases

COMMON PLEAS COURT CURRENT BUSINESS State of Ohio v. Saraha McNeil, termination of probation, case closed. State of Ohio v. Robert Childers, termination of community control, case dismissed. State of Ohio v. Robert Sparks, termination of community control, case dismissed. State of Ohio v. Jacquiline Strole, termination of community control, case dismissed...
More Stories