5-week-old puppy stolen from New Carlisle pet rescue

German shepherd found in Circleville, returned safe after missing for a few days.


A 5-week-old puppy is now back with his mother after a volunteer allegedly stole him from a New Carlisle pet shelter.

Pawsitive Warriors Rescue of New Carlisle Founder and Executive Director Molly Murray was by herself at the shelter on Nov. 2 and knee deep in work when a woman came in to volunteer.

READ MORE: Champaign County man’s dream of $3M animal sanctuary ready to open

“I was here by myself taking care of the dogs,” Murray said. “So when she walked in, I was so excited to have help. I didn’t even think to have her fill out the paperwork.”

The volunteer jumped right in and was there for nearly 10 hours, Murray said, seemed to be a great worker, including cleaning out cages.

During that time, a man fell in the parking lot. That’s when Murray, her husband and another volunteer ran out to help the man.

“Which gave her a few minutes alone,” Murray said.

TRENDING STORY: Springfield manufacturer Topre opens plant, may grow to 400 jobs

That’s when she believes the woman allegedly stashed a full-blooded German shepherd puppy named Lendy in a cage and took the cage outside. The puppy is worth about $1,000 to $1,500.

Murray and others didn’t notice the missing dog until the next day. She contacted the Clark County Sheriff’s Office and posted about it on Facebook. She was worried about his health because Lendy was still nursing and too young to be away from his mother.

“I put the post out there and the community, they were all over it,” Murray said. “It was just amazing the information people were able to obtain and send to me.”

DETAILS: Clark County opens new shelter to house lost, stray dogs

Several social media tips lead to the puppy being found Saturday in Circleville, south of Columbus.

“He was in a cardboard box,” Murray said. “They slid him inside of a door of a GameStop.”

A store employee found Lendy and took him to her mother, who operates a Mastiff rescue. They took care of him until they learned he was stolen. He was returned Sunday when Murray met the good Samaritans in Xenia.

The puppy is in good health and back with his mother and litter mates.

“I can tell he lost a little bit of weight but he’s eating like a pig and he’s just fine,” Murray said.

The Clark County Sheriff’s Office is investigating the abduction. They have a suspect identified but no charges have been filed at this time.

Lendy’s abduction has made her more aware, Murray said, and she will now make sure all volunteers fill out the appropriate paperwork with a photo identification.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Crime

Food Bank’s dessert auction to aid local families
Food Bank’s dessert auction to aid local families

Desserts can help put food on the tables of needy local families this holiday season. Second Harvest Food Bank of Clark, Champaign and Logan Counties’ Ninth Annual Thanks for Giving Dessert Auction is a way to enjoy sweet treats while raising funds for the Food Bank’s Holiday Giving Campaign. The bidding will be 5-7 p.m. Tuesday, Nov. 20...
OSP: Man trapped inside truck for several hours, taken to Springfield Regional
OSP: Man trapped inside truck for several hours, taken to Springfield Regional

UPDATE @ 9:55 a.m.: A man was transported to Springfield Regional Medical Center this morning for unknown injuries after flipping over a bridge in a pick-up truck off W. County Line Rd.  According to the Ohio State Highway Patrol, the man was traveling westbound on W. County Line Rd., veered to the left, then flipped over the bridge around...
Columbus woman arrested on Live PD as porn blares in background
Columbus woman arrested on Live PD as porn blares in background

A Columbus woman was arrested on live television Friday by the Franklin County Sheriff's Office, according to WBNS. The sheriff's office was featured on A&E's 'Live PD', a show that features law enforcement agencies across the country during their shifts.  During the show, deputies served a warrant for 23-year-old Storm Wisener. She was wanted...
Parents of Triad student want schools to do more in wake of suicide
Parents of Triad student want schools to do more in wake of suicide

Parents of a girl who committed suicide after alleged bullying filed a federal lawsuit against Triad Local Schools and say that it’s time for schools to handle bullying differently. Nationwide, about 30 percent of sixth through 12th-grade students reported being bullied, according to StopBullying.gov. In Clark County, more than one in five high...
Pike County investigation: 8 deaths and multiple arrests were tied to one key factor — child custody
Pike County investigation: 8 deaths and multiple arrests were tied to one key factor — child custody

Sophia Wagner is spending her fifth birthday today in the custody of Children Services. Her mother, Hanna Rhoden, and her mother’s immediate family were all murdered in their homes in 2016. Her father, Edward “Jake” Wagner, and his immediate family are in jail and charged with killing them. Investigators have revealed little about...
More Stories