Ex-superintendent convicted in child sex case still suing school district


A former Indian Lake superintendent continues to argue in a lawsuit the district didn’t have the right to fire him, despite the fact he eventually was convicted in a criminal child sex abuse case.

Patrick O’Donnell was placed on paid administrative leave by the Indian Lake Board of Education shortly after being arrested and accused of sexually assaulting a child. The child was known to him but wasn’t a student at Indian Lake schools, police said.

MORE: Ex-Logan County superintendent takes plea deal in child sex case

O’Donnell pleaded guilty to a count of gross sexual imposition and was sentenced to 54 months in jail. He is not expected to be released from prison until September 2022.

The amount of money O’Donnell is seeking hasn’t been disclosed, but his annual salary was about $110,000, according to district records. His wife, Heather O’Donnell, who was charged with two counts of child endangering in connection to Patrick O’Donnell’s case, got about $35,000 from the Midwest Regional Educational Service Center after she resigned from her position.

As Patrick O’Donnell’s criminal case made its way through the courts, the board decided to initiate termination proceedings against him— even though he had not yet been convicted. Patrick O’Donnell’s attorneys say in court filings that is not right and that Patrick O’Donnell is owed back pay. The board of education says they had the right to terminate Patrick O’Donnell because he was unable to fulfill his duties to the district after the allegations surfaced.

Patrick O’Donnell’s attorney Dennis Pergram and Indian Lake Board of Education attorney Doug Holthus didn’t respond to messages seeking comment. A spokeswoman for the board of education didn’t either.

The school board began termination procedures against Patrick O’Donnell in June and he appealed those in July 2017 which prompted the school to hold a termination hearing with a referee appointed by the Ohio Department of Education in August.

The referee issued a recommendation on Nov. 7, 2017, that the board shouldn’t fire Patrick O’Donnell. The referee noted in his recommendation that even though the allegations are “extremely serious”, Patrick O’Donnell should have remained on unpaid leave until after the criminal case is resolved.

The school district went ahead and fired Patrick O’Donnell anyway, an action the board said it has the right to do.

In a defendant’s brief, Indian Lake schools said Patrick O’Donnell deserved to be fired.

MORE: Ex-Logan County superintendent takes plea deal in child sex case

“Indeed, it is difficult to imagine a case where an educator deserves to have been terminated more than O’Donnell - he has been convicted of committing a sex crime against a child,” the brief says. “A board of education should not be required to wait for a criminal conviction to terminate an educator. The standard for terminating an educator is ‘good and just cause’ and not a criminal act proven beyond a reasonable doubt.”

The Board of Education shouldn’t have to pay an employee until a criminal case is completed, the brief says.

“Moreover, an educator who is subject to a mandatory suspension pending a criminal proceeding should not be permitted to be entitled to payment through the completion of the criminal process. If that were the case, the person who is arrested and charged with a crime could try to delay his criminal case in an effort to extract more payment from a public employer,” the brief says.

READ: Victim in ex-Indian Lake superintendent sex case: Speak up

In response to the brief, Pergram said Patrick O’Donnell is not looking to get his job back but shouldn’t have been fired before a conviction.

“It is the board that chose to initiate a termination proceeding against superintendent O’Donnell when it did and it is the board that chose to rely on ‘an arrest’ rather than setting forth any charges or evidence that Superintendent O’Donnell engaged in misconduct that would constitute good and just cause,” the reply says. “Based on the facts introduced at the termination hearing and the law, the order of termination must be reversed along with an order that the board pay Mr. O’Donnell his back pay loss…”



Reader Comments


Next Up in Crime

OSP: 700 arrests made in multi-state impaired driving campaign
OSP: 700 arrests made in multi-state impaired driving campaign

The Ohio State Highway Patrol says a recent enforcement and awareness effort on impaired driving as part of a multi-state law enforcement partnership resulted in a total of 700 arrests for driving under the influence.  From Dec. 7 through 9, 280 of the arrests were made in Ohio.  The 6-State Trooper Project is a multi-state law enforcement...
KFC announces yule log that smells like fried chicken 
KFC announces yule log that smells like fried chicken 

Kentucky Fried Chicken is trying out a new tradition, just in time for the holidays. >> Read more trending news  The chain is offering a new way to enjoy the aroma of the Colonel's secret recipe in your own home: A KFC yule log. It's called the KFC 11 Herbs & Spices Firelog and it smells like chicken. KFC partnered with Enviro-Log to create...
School safety expert: Entrances can be made less vulnerable
School safety expert: Entrances can be made less vulnerable

A Miami Valley school security expert said glass doors on school entrances can be modified to make them much less vulnerable to the kind of attack in Richmond, Indiana, that allowed a teenage shooter to gain access.  Craig Hoschouer, president of PLE Group, Kettering, said on Thursday that a protective film can be applied to glass doors and...
Georgia police officer and suspect dead after shooting during traffic stop
Georgia police officer and suspect dead after shooting during traffic stop

Update 9:15 p.m. EST Dec. 13: The Georgia police officer who was shot by a suspect Thursday afternoon near in metro Atlanta’s DeKalb County has died at Grady Memorial Hospital, DeKalb County police Chief James Conroy said at a news conference.  The suspect also died at Grady, Conroy said. Conroy said the officer had been with the department...
Richmond school shooting: Police seize computers, gun boxes from home
Richmond school shooting: Police seize computers, gun boxes from home

Authorities seized computers and two gun boxes this afternoon from the home in the aftermath of a shooting at Dennis Intermediate School. Neighbors said Indiana State Police, the FBI and ATF were outside the home all day in the 100 block of Southwest 16th Street in Richmond. “When I got up this morning, the police were across the street with...
More Stories