Fatal accident closes lanes of I-70 EB near South Vienna

Springfield teen sentenced in brother’s brutal death: 3 things to know

The Springfield teenager who was only 16 when prosecutors said he beat and stabbed his brother to death in 2016 has pleaded guilty to murder and been sentenced to 15 year to life in prison, according to court documents.

Here’s three things you should know about the case.

» READ MORE: Springfield teen guilty of killing brother

1. Crime scene called a “horror movie”

Nicholas Starling was accused of beating his brother, Harley Starling, with a baseball bat and then stabbing him in the throat in October 2016. According to court documents, Starling went into his brother’s room while he slept, then allegedly hit him in the head with the bat 14 to 15 times before stabbing him in the throat to stop the “noise” his brother was making after the beating.

» RELATED: 9-1-1 call released in Springfield beating, stabbing death

Springfield Police Division Detective Ron Jordan testified in an earlier court hearing that Nicholas Starling admitted he and his brother had been in an argument over Halloween candy.

Clark County Prosecutor Andy Wilson said the slaying resembled something of a horror movie and is the worst child-on-child crime he has ever prosecuted.

2. Killing could have been caused by several factors

The older brother’s tough upbringing might have played a role, Wilson said. He said the teen’s father was murdered two years before and his mother was in and out of the boys’ lives.

» TRENDING: Family: Attempted robbery lead to fatal shooting in Springfield

Another possible reason was the teen’s interest, Wilson said.

“He seemed to be researching the occult, the Insane Clown Posse,” he said. “He was very into some satanic worship and that kind of stuff. We were never able to prove a direct link between why he did what he did and his interests, but it piles on for how disturbed this kid is.”

3. Ruled competent to stand trial

Starling underwent a mental evaluation and was found competent to stand trial in October 2017.

» MORE COVERAGE: Springfield teen accused of killing brother competent to stand trial

Wilson said despite Starling’s background, it doesn’t excuse him from the consequences of the murder and he wasn’t criminally insane at the time it was committed. He said Starling took steps to cover up what he did, including hiding the bat and knife and trying to make it look like a suicide.

“Anyone who could do something like this is ill,” he said. “You have to be a sick person to do what he did but that doesn’t mean you are criminally insane. It is very clear from the evidence that when he murdered his brother he was certainly able to appreciate the wrongness of his actions.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Crime

Clark County leaders developing plans for trip to Japan
Clark County leaders developing plans for trip to Japan

Board members with the Community Improvement Corp. of Clark County on Thursday discussed an upcoming trip to meet with business leaders in Japan and progress on two studies being conducted with assistance from the University of Cincinnati. Three workforce development officials are traveling to Japan in November for about 10 days to develop closer ties...
Amber Alert: Boy, 6, taken from father's West Virginia home
Amber Alert: Boy, 6, taken from father's West Virginia home

An Amber Alert was issued in West Virginia after a 6-year-old boy was taken from his father’s home, officials said. >> Read more trending news  Akexton Steele was taken from the home in Ohio County about 9 p.m. after family members of his father’s estranged ex-wife used an ax to break in, officials said. There was then a confrontation...
6 people, including 3 infants, stabbed at New York City day care
6 people, including 3 infants, stabbed at New York City day care

At least six people, including three infants, were stabbed at a New York City day care center Friday morning, WNBC reported. >> Read more trending news  Police were called to the day care center in Queens around 3:40 a.m., WPIX reported. A 52-year-old woman with apparent self-inflicted knife wounds was taken into custody, the television...
Fatal pedestrian strike reported in Clark County
Fatal pedestrian strike reported in Clark County

We are responding to a report of  a fatal pedestrian on eastbound I-70, just west of Ohio 54. The left and middle lanes have been closed, according to dispatch. Drivers can take U.S. 40 as an alternate route, per the Ohio State Highway Patrol, Springfield Post.  We have a reporter on scene, and we will bring you the latest information as...
Sister: Springfield Twp. stabbing victim ‘devoted her life to her family’
Sister: Springfield Twp. stabbing victim ‘devoted her life to her family’

A Clark County woman is facing a long recovery after her husband allegedly cut her throat Thursday morning in the couple’s home. She “devoted her life to her family. She was a young mother. She put her life on hold to raise her daughter and give her the best life possible,” the victim’s sister said in a statement Thursday. The...
More Stories