Springfield teen accused of killing brother ruled competent for trial


A Springfield 16-year-old accused of killing his younger bother last year was found to be competent and ordered to stand trial.

Clark County Common Pleas Court Judge Douglas Rastatter found Nicholas Starling competent after an evaluation concluded he’s able to understand court procedure and aid his defense attorney.

RELATED: Prosecutors: 14-year-old Springfield boy beaten with bat, stabbed

“(The evaluation) opined, within a reasonable degree of psychological certainty, that the defendant is capable of understanding the nature and objective of the proceedings against him and assisting in his defense and that he is, therefore, competent to stand trial,” according to the judge’s ruling.

The court document says both the prosecution and the defense accepted the findings.

Starling is accused of killing his 14-year-old brother, Harley Starling in October 2016. Harley was found dead in his bed at his Superior Avenue home on the morning of Oct. 31. He had been beaten with a baseball bat and stabbed several times in the neck, according to the Montgomery County Coroner’s Office.

MORE: Springfield teen charged in brother’s death to be tried as adult

Nicholas Starling allegedly confessed to killing his brother by beating him with a baseball bat and then stabbing him, police said.

Springfield Police Division Detective Ron Jordan testified in an earlier court hearing that Nicholas Starling admitted he and his brother had been in a previous argument over Halloween candy, according to court records.

READ: Springfield boy beaten, stabbed; brother charged

Nicholas Starling allegedly told detectives he later went into his brother’s room while he was sleeping, and struck him in the head with a baseball bat 14 to 15 times. The teen then stabbed his brother with a knife in the neck, according to court records, to stop the “noise” the younger brother was making after the beating.

The court set a trial date of Nov. 28 at 9 a.m.



Reader Comments


Next Up in Crime

Mom mourns 4 children, ages 2 to 8, killed in South Carolina crash: 'They were my everything'
Mom mourns 4 children, ages 2 to 8, killed in South Carolina crash: 'They were my everything'

A South Carolina mother is devastated after her four young children were killed in a weekend crash. According to the Greenville News and The Associated Press, Amez Yaron Jamison Jr., 4; Robbiana Evans, 6; and Jamire Halley, 8, died early Friday after the van they were riding in crashed on state Highway 253 in Taylors, authorities said. Their brother...
Freezing fog could cause slick spots, low visibility for morning commute
Freezing fog could cause slick spots, low visibility for morning commute

Areas of fog/freezing fog Slowly warming up this week Showers return towards end of week TODAY: Areas of fog started to redevelop last night. Temperatures are down in the upper teens again, so freezing fog will be possible, according to Storm Center 7 Meteorologist Kirstie Zontini. It’ll be a little breezy this morning, which will help prevent...
Homicides up in Xenia, chief says city is safe
Homicides up in Xenia, chief says city is safe

In a city that typically has one or two homicides a year, four people have been killed so far in 2018 in Xenia, where the police chief seeks to reassure residents. Three of the homicides came in two stabbing incidents, including one last week that resulted in the death of an 84-year-old woman and her 57-year-old daughter, whose brother is now being...
Centerville man wants teen crash victim’s medical records
Centerville man wants teen crash victim’s medical records

Lawyers for a Centerville man facing an aggravated vehicular homicide charge in connection with a Thanksgiving 2017 fatal crash with a teen walking along a road outside Springboro are pressing for more information. Robert C. Pietrantonio’s lawyers want to obtain medical and mental health records of the person killed, Skyler P. Ludington, 18,...
Hit-skip crash causes parked car to strike Springfield house
Hit-skip crash causes parked car to strike Springfield house

A vehicle involved in a hit-skip crash fled the scene after causing a parked car to strike a house on Montgomery Avenue Tuesday morning.  Police say the suspect vehicle hit a car that was parked, which caused the parked car to crash into a home in the 400 block around 1:15 a.m. The driver did not stay at the crash site and was last seen in the...
More Stories