Springfield man sues police officers claiming civil rights violations


A Springfield man has sued three Springfield Police Division officers, alleging they violated his civil rights, assaulted him and failed to provide adequate medical care.

City Law Director Jerry Strozdas said his initial review of the case doesn’t indicate any misconduct on the part of the officers.

DETAILS: 2 arrested in armed robbery at Springfield Verizon store

On July 20, 2017, Devan Smith accidentally locked himself out of his home, according to the lawsuit. A neighbor saw him trying to get into the home and called police. Officers Justin Massie, Michael Fredendall and Kevin Hoying arrived on scene and Smith was placed in custody as they checked records to see if he lived at the residence. Once it was confirmed that he lived there, the officers allegedly didn’t leave.

They allegedly began questioning the plaintiff about if he had illegal drugs and searched his room, the suit claims. The officers found Smith’s prescription medication and questioned him, according to the lawsuit.

MORE COVERAGE: Lawsuit against Clark County for jail death moves to federal court

The interaction between the four allegedly became hostile and triggered a seizure in Smith, who has epilepsy, the suit claims.

The officers were aware of the plaintiff’s condition, the suit says, but claimed they thought he had illegal drugs. They handcuffed Smith, the suit claims, and tried to pry his mouth open. Afterward they left Smith handcuffed and face down on the floor, according to the lawsuit.

READ MORE: Hunting photos lead to wildlife charges for New Carlisle man

He regained consciousness later at the hospital and was still in handcuffs, the suit alleges. Smith was never charged after the series of events.

The lawsuit was filed Jan. 11. The city just learned about it late Thursday, Strozdas said.

“I have done a preliminary review of the case and it is apparent to me there is no misconduct on part of the officers,” Strozdas said.

It’s the city’s intention to defend the officers, he said, and no decisions have been made about approaches or strategies.

The Springfield News-Sun contacted Smith’s lawyer listed in the lawsuit, Kurtis G. Black, but didn’t receive a call back.

The suit seeks compensatory and punitive damages in an amount to be determined at trial.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Crime

Bright moon might outshine Orionid meteor shower

The Orionid meteor shower is produced by the debris from Halley’s Comet.  Meteor showers are named based on their radiant point (place where meteors look to appear from). Orion is the constellation for this shower. Unfortunately, bright moonlight could block out some of the dimmer meteors even though we will have clear skies Oct. 21 and...
Tremont City Barrel Fill cleanup still stalled as negotiations continue
Tremont City Barrel Fill cleanup still stalled as negotiations continue

Any work to remove hazardous materials from the Tremont City Barrel Fill site in Clark County won’t take place for months, federal officials told residents at a meeting in downtown Springfield this week. Jim Saric, a remedial project manager from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency based in Chicago, said it’s difficult to say when...
Clark County has one of highest breast cancer rates in Ohio
Clark County has one of highest breast cancer rates in Ohio

Clark County women develop breast cancer at a higher rate than most other Ohioans, a factor that’s driving awareness and prevention efforts in the Springfield area. At a rate of 135 breast cancer cases per 100,000 women, Clark County had the sixth highest incidence from 2010 to 2014, according to a new report from the Ohio Department of Health...
'Love & Hip Hop' star Tommie Lee arrested at daughter's middle school
'Love & Hip Hop' star Tommie Lee arrested at daughter's middle school

Atlanta's WSB-TV has learned a reality television star was arrested Tuesday at her child's middle school in Cobb County, Georgia. WSB-TV’s Matt Johnson obtained the arrest warrant for Atasha Chizaah Jefferson, known as Tommie Lee on “Love & Hip Hop: Atlanta.” Jefferson is accused of shoving her child’s head into a locker...
Freeze Warning in effect through 10 a.m. for the Miami Valley 
Freeze Warning in effect through 10 a.m. for the Miami Valley 

Freeze Warning through 10 a.m.  Showers return Friday Cool all weekend  TODAY: Another frigid morning with possible frost. A Freeze Warning is in effect until 10 a.m. for all of the Miami Valley. Some of the northern Miami Valley will drop to around 30 degrees with clear skies. Some high, thin clouds linger in the southern Miami Valley...
More Stories