Middletown cat beating, hanging case goes to grand jury


A Butler County grand jury will now consider the case of a Middletown man accused of hanging and beating a cat to death.

Andrew Tyler Chilton, 19, appeared Tuesday before Judge James Sherron in Middletown Municipal Court, where he waived his right to a preliminary hearing on the fifth-degree felony.

He remains in the Middletown City Jail in lieu of a $25,000 bond. Now that the case has been sent to grand jury, he will be transported to the Butler County Jail.

FIRST REPORT: Butler County man charged for beating, hanging death of kitten

The incident allegedly occurred about three weeks ago when Chilton hung a kitten in the basement of a relative’s house on Oberon Drive and beat it to death with rocks and bricks, according to Butler County Dog Warden Supervisor Kurt Merbs.

The kitten, a calico named Tinker, belonged to Chilton’s girlfriend, according to investigators. Merbs said Chilton uploaded pictures of the beating online where his girlfriend could find them. She contacted the dog warden’s office.

“This is one of the most heinous acts of cruelty I have seen in this county,” Butler County Sheriff Richard Jones said. “I’m proud of the deputy dog wardens for their diligent work and getting this guy locked up. Obviously he has some serious issues if he feels he has to harm an innocent animal.”

The charge of cruelty to a companion animal had been a first-degree misdemeanor for years, with a maximum sentence of 180 days. Now classified as a felony, the charge carries a sentence of up to 12 months in prison in some cases. The law changed in September 2016.




Next Up in Crime

Aberdeen shooting: Woman, 26, kills self, 3 others in 'horrific' Rite Aid center incident
Aberdeen shooting: Woman, 26, kills self, 3 others in 'horrific' Rite Aid center incident

Four people died Thursday after a temporary employee opened fire at a Rite Aid distribution center in Maryland, according to Harford County sheriff’s deputies. The suspected shooter was among the deceased, Sheriff Jeffrey Gahler said. Deputies in Harford County said they responded just after 9 a.m. to reports of a shooting with “multiple...
88-year-old victim of carjacking: ‘I’d kill the SOB’
88-year-old victim of carjacking: ‘I’d kill the SOB’

An elderly Michigan woman left battered and bruised when a man stole her car and purse outside a Walmart store Tuesday did not mince words when asked what she would like to do if she saw the man again. “I’d kill the son of a (expletive),” Gloria Kevelighan told Fox 2 in Detroit. “The way he pushed me, he didn’t care...
James Brown's daughter, Venisha Brown, dead at 53
James Brown's daughter, Venisha Brown, dead at 53

Venisha Brown, one of the daughters of the late Godfather of Soul James Brown and the late Yvonne Fair, formerly of the Chantels, died Wednesday. She was 53. >> Read more trending news  Venisha Brown died at Augusta University Health Medical Center in Augusta due to complications from pneumonia, according to a release from the ...
Orlando Melbourne International Airport reopens after security breach; man arrested
Orlando Melbourne International Airport reopens after security breach; man arrested

Florida’s Orlando Melbourne International Airport has reopened after an early morning security breach Thursday morning, and a 22-year-old college student is now in police custody, authorities said. Update 1:25 p.m. EDT Sept. 20: Airport officials said the suspect was a 22-year-old part-time college student from Trinidad and Tobago who...
Ex-boyfriend stabs woman’s new boyfriend after hiding in closet
Ex-boyfriend stabs woman’s new boyfriend after hiding in closet

A 24-year-old Texas man is in critical condition Thursday after he was stabbed by his girlfriend’s ex-boyfriend, who was hiding in a closet at her apartment, WOAI reported. >> Read more trending news  Anthony Escobedo, 24, was taken to a San Antonio hospital with a collapsed lung, the television station reported. The incident...
More Stories