Ohio Supreme Court rules traffic stop purse search unconstitutional


The Ohio Supreme Court ruled in a 4-3 decision Tuesday that a state trooper’s search of a woman’s purse during a traffic stop violated constitutional protections against unreasonable search and seizure.

Writing the lead opinion, Justice Bill O’Neill said in the course of events leading to the arrest, the trooper provided no justification for searching the vehicle without a search warrant.

Related: Ohio Supreme Court: backpack searches fair game on school property

The ruling stems from 2014 traffic stop in Warren County by the Ohio Highway Patrol.

Jamie Banks-Harvey, who was pulled over for speeding, provided identification but did not have a driver’s license. She was patted down and placed in the back of the cruiser while her purse remained in the car.

The trooper found Banks-Harvey had an outstanding arrest warrant in Montgomery County for heroin possession and her passenger, Shannon Holcomb, had an arrest warrant in Warren County for drug paraphernalia possession.

Related: Drug crisis in Ohio: What solutions are making a difference?

The trooper asked the second passenger, Charles Hall, who owned the car, if he could search the vehicle. Hall said no. The trooper reached into the vehicle to grab Banks-Harvey’s purse and then searched it, discovering pills, capsules and needles.

A local officer on the scene said he might have seen a capsule in Hall’s car so the trooper then searched the car and found a needle and empty capsule.

Banks-Harvey pleaded no contest to drug charges that were based on the items found in her purse and she was sentenced to three years of community control and mandated inpatient drug treatment. The trial court denied her motion to suppress the evidence found.

“Neither the purse, nor the vehicle that contained the purse, came into police custody as a result of her arrest. On these facts, the state has failed to show that this search fits under the inventory-search exception to the Fourth Amendment’s warrant requirement,” the Ohio Supreme Court majority opinion said.

Related: Man stopped for wearing hoodie, baggy pants is jailed for nine days



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in News

Marine’s murder in Belize remains unsolved one year later
Marine’s murder in Belize remains unsolved one year later

Brandon Barfield has kept his best friend’s room just the way he left it. Drew DeVoursney’s black suit still hangs in the closet of the West Palm Beach home they shared. And his guitar — the one he used to perform Lynyrd Skynyrd and Allman Brothers songs while they were both deployed in Iraq — rests beside the bed he slept in...
Delta warns of flight cancellations due to subtropical storm Alberto
Delta warns of flight cancellations due to subtropical storm Alberto

Delta Air Lines is warning that it expects it will have to cancel flights due to subtropical storm Alberto. The storm is expected to make landfall just west of Panama City on Monday afternoon with heavy rain and strong wind affecting areas in Alberto’s path, according to Delta. Atlanta-based Delta said it expects delays and cancellations...
15-year-old girl missing since Tuesday in Mississippi, parents want answers
15-year-old girl missing since Tuesday in Mississippi, parents want answers

A Mississippi family is desperate for answers after one of their own, 15-year-old Eileen Betlinski-Brown, went missing Tuesday in Horn Lake, Mississippi. “It’s just way, way, way too real. I guess you call it stressful to say the least. Scary. Not knowing what’s happening,” said Eileen’s grandfather, James Betlinski. Betlinski...
Man, 79, pleads no contest to raping girl, 5, sentenced to 90 days house arrest
Man, 79, pleads no contest to raping girl, 5, sentenced to 90 days house arrest

A California businessman pleaded no contest to statutory rape of a 5-year-old girl Wednesday, and, as part of a negotiated deal with the San Joaquin County Superior Court, was sentenced to 90 days house arrest and will not have to register as a sex offender. Lyle Burgess, 79, of Stockton, sexually assaulted the girl, who is now 7, after her family...
Germany’s largest amusement park reopens after massive fire 
Germany’s largest amusement park reopens after massive fire 

There were no injuries among the thousands of people who evacuated from Germany’s largest amusement park after a fire ignited Saturday, destroying the Pirates of Batavia ride.  About 250 firefighters battled the blaze at Europa-Park into Sunday morning after the fire started in a warehouse, according to Sky News. Some firefighters...
More Stories