The board’s decision was issued after a five-day termination hearing where a referee appointed by the Ohio Department of Education recommended the school board wait for the criminal case to conclude before firing him.
TRENDING STORY: Clark County teacher deadly hit-and-run: Family wants justice
Indian Lake issued a statement on its website and a district spokeswoman declined to further comment.
"Board members reject the analysis and conclusions contained in the referee's report and recommendation, including but not limited to his recommendation that the board not proceed with termination of O'Donnell's employment contract at this time," the Indian Lake statement says.
The O’Donnells declined to comment at this time.
READ MORE: Trial dates set for Logan County superintendents in child rape case
State referee Robert Harrelson said in his written recommendation the district should wait to see if he is convicted before firing him, even though the charges against O’Donnell are serious.
“Quite possibly, the board has acted prematurely in pursuing the termination of Mr. O’Donnell for the sole reason he was arrested and charged with this crime,” the recommendation says. “Instead, the board had the option to place Mr. O’Donnell on paid or unpaid administrative leave pending the resolution of the criminal matter.”
MORE COVERAGE: Logan County superintendent suspended after ‘horrible’ charges
Ohio law allows the school board to reject the findings of the referee, the district’s statement says.
“Based on the board’s findings of facts, the board resolves that O’Donnell’s contract of employment with Indian Lake Schools is terminated, effective immediately,” the statement says.