Online sales keep soaring while in-store numbers stay flat

Brick-and-mortar sales for Thanksgiving weekend and Black Friday about equal to last year.

While shoppers still spent billions in brick-and-mortar stores this weekend, Cyber Monday is stealing major spending away from Thanksgiving and Black Friday.

Brick-and-mortar sales stayed steady this year compared to Thanksgiving and Black Friday 2016, but Cyber Monday sales are expected to increase by more than 18 percent, according to Adobe Analytics.

Shoppers are expected to spend $6.6 billion on Cyber Monday. Approximately 78 million people in the U.S. were expected to shop on Cyber Monday, according to the National Retail Federation, due in part to changing consumer power of generations.

“As Gen Z and millennials get older, their purchasing power increases, and the rise in disposable income is sure to be seen by retailers,” said Matthew Shay, NRF president and CEO.

» RELATED: Holiday spending expected to increase in Ohio, region

Retailers pushed more sales online on Cyber Monday, but also morphed toward offering deals all week. Toys”R”Us, which filed for bankruptcy earlier this year, offered 15 percent items site-wide and another 25 percent off all Hasbro games online. Carter’s brand clothes was 60 percent off online. Elder-Beerman offered online shoppers access to an exclusive promo code for $50 off a $100 or more online purchase, and free shipping on any purchase of $25 or more

The online deals come as economists expect online sales to surpass brick-and-mortar sales this holiday season for the first time in history. About 59 percent of consumers plan to shop online this year, according to the NRF. The trade group projects that holiday retail sales in November and December this year will be up between 3.6 percent and 4 percent for a total between $678.8 billion and $682 billion. Consumers say they will spend an average $967.13 this year, according to the annual survey conducted.

Brick-and-mortar stores still saw strong sales — but they did not increase compared to last year, according to preliminary data. Shopper visits on Thanksgiving and Black Friday declined a combined 1.6 percent when compared to the same days in 2016. Black Friday 2017 shopper visits decreased less than one percent when compared to Black Friday 2016, according to preliminary data from ShopperTrak, a Tyco Retail Solutions’ brand. The National Retail Federation will also release its spending data this week.

» RELATED: Travel tips: 10 worst airports to fly through for Thanksgiving travel

“There has been a significant amount of debate surrounding the shifting importance of brick-and-mortar retail, and the fact that shopper visits remained intact on Black Friday illustrates that physical retail is still highly relevant and, when done right, profitable,” said Brian Field, senior director of advisory services for ShopperTrak.

Local residents showed up in hoards on Thanksgiving evening — thousands lining up outside of JCPenney, Elder-Beerman, the Dayton Mall and the Mall at Fairfield Commons. On Black Friday, at least 600 people waited outside of Cabela’s in Centerville to land free gift cards and other prizes.

Satpal Kour of Fairborn was the first in line at JCPenney near the Dayton Mall on Thanksgiving. She waited out in the cold for more than two hours to be the first in the store to get deals on items such as outerwear and shoes.

“It’s our first time doing Black Friday, just looking for good deals,” she said.

Small Business Saturday also lured in local consumers as the day grows in popularity. Approximately 61 percent of U.S. consumers were aware of Small Business Saturday going into the day, and of those, 82 percent said they planned to shop at a small, independently-owned retailer or dine at a small, independently-owned restaurant on the day.

» RELATED: UberEATS launches food delivery services in Dayton

In Ohio, the majority of consumers spent money at restaurants, bars, pubs or supermarkets on Small Business Saturday this year, according to the Morning Consult Intelligence. About 41 percent of consumers went to a restaurant, bar or pub, and 24 percent went to a food store or supermarket. About 23 percent went to a clothing or accessories store.

“Supporting small businesses is critical to the health and livelihood of our national economy and local communities,” said NFIB CEO and President Juanita Duggan.

Looking ahead, eight of the 10 anticipated busiest shopping days still remain, including Super Saturday, which will fall on Dec. 23, according to ShopperTrak. As a potential boon to retailers, there are four Saturdays in December prior to Christmas Day, which will draw major crowds for weekend shopping.


$5 billion was spent by consumers on Black Friday in 2016

$6.6 billion in sales expected on Cyber Monday

18 percent increase in sales recorded on Thanksgiving Day

Source: Adobe Analytics


After Black Friday, small businesses try to cash in on shopping frenzy

Overheard while Thanksgiving shopping: ‘Your dad is going to kill me’

5 ways to stay out of debt this holiday shopping season

Champagne gummy bears? Dorothy Lane selling new candy brand

17 retail horror stories that show working Black Friday is the worst

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Business

Toddler toys, decorative pillows, and water bottles among the latest product recalls 
Toddler toys, decorative pillows, and water bottles among the latest product recalls 

Children’s xylophones, water bottles sold at Costco, and 21 styles of decorative pillows are among the latest recalls announced by the Consumer Product Safety Commission.  The Petit Collage musical jumbo wooden xylophones made by Wild & Wolf are under recall because the ball on the end of the stick can detach and pose a choking hazard. ...
Can I still use my gift card at Elder-Beerman? 5 questions answered for customers
Can I still use my gift card at Elder-Beerman? 5 questions answered for customers

Elder-Beerman’s parent company announced the going-out-of-business sale begins today for its 212 stores and e-commerce website. Bon-Ton Stores Inc. is closing all stores after only liquidators submitted bids for the retailer at a bankruptcy auction earlier this week. Bon-Ton’s liquidation sales are expected to run for about 10 to 12 weeks...
Manufacturing helps boost Ohio jobs again
Manufacturing helps boost Ohio jobs again

Ohio’s unemployment rate fell slightly last month, to 4.4 percent from 4.5 percent in February — and once again, manufacturing helped provide the boost. The state’s non-agricultural wage and salary employment increased 10,800 in March, from a revised 5,568,400 in February to 5,579,200, the state said in a monthly jobs report. ...
Pier 1 Imports to close up to 25 stores
Pier 1 Imports to close up to 25 stores

Pier 1 Imports Inc. will close up to 25 stores in the next two years, the company announced during its quarterly earnings call. Net sales decreased 1.4 percent to $469.2 million, according to a company statement. Alasdair James, president and CEO, said the company’s financial performance was impacted by the hurricanes in Texas and Florida. E-commerce...
Elder-Beerman store closings: Everything we know now about local impact
Elder-Beerman store closings: Everything we know now about local impact

After several last ditch attempts to save one of America’s oldest retailers, Bon-Ton Stores Inc. joined the ranks of companies that have succumbed to the retail apocalypse. Bon-Ton Stores Inc. officials announced on Wednesday morning that a joint bidder, including a group of the bankrupt retail chain’s bondholders, won the auction...
More Stories