5 key findings by the independent working group that investigated Urban Meyer and Ohio State

nearly 12-hour day ended a nearly one-month saga at Ohio State. 

When it was over Wednesday night, the independent working group hired to look into how Urban Meyer handled allegations former assistant coach Zach Smith abused his wife released a summary of its findings that included these key items: 

1. Meyer was aware law enforcement in Powell, Ohio, investigated Smith for allegedly abusing Courtney Smith in 2015. 

The coach was informed by director of athletics Gene Smith that fall after law enforcement notified the OSU department of athletics. 

Both Meyer and Gene Smith regularly monitored progress of investigation for a period of months, and ultimately no criminal charges were pressed. 

The working group concluded Meyer and Smith acted in good faith at that time but did not report the investigation to compliance, as group believes they should have. 

Even though there were no criminal charges, compliance could have determined if there should have been an internal investigation. 

2. Lead investigator Mary Jo White said the group concluded relying on law enforcement to take action was not sufficient, but the investigation found Meyer and Gene Smith were not alone in misunderstanding what was required of them. 

“A number of the other witnesses who were interviewed had the same understanding as that of Coach Meyer and Athletic Director Smith as to the events required to trigger University reporting obligations. 

“The University therefore will undertake steps to make its requirements clearer and implement additional training to reinforce them” according to a summary of the report published Wednesday night. 

3. Despite Meyer being aware of the 2015 allegation, the investigators did not find Meyer deliberately lied when asked about the incident during Big Ten Media Days in Chicago in late July. 

That is because — as had been widely speculated over the past few weeks — Meyer was focused on a media report Smith was arrested rather than only investigated

However, White said his answer “swept more broadly than the falsely reported arrest and Coach Meyer falsely stated that he lacked knowledge of all relevant events regarding alleged domestic violence by Zach Smith in 2015. While those denials were plainly not accurate, Coach Meyer in our view did not deliberately lie.”

4. The committee found Meyer has a sincere belief in his stated program “core value” to respect women, and he is committed to instilling it in his players. 

White also reported the group found Gene Smith shares that belief. 

5. Finally, there was the matter of other misconduct of Zach Smith. 

According to White, her group found “a number of instances of misconduct and other problematic conduct by Zach Smith while he was employed at OSU, some of which was known by Coach Meyer and AD Smith and some of which was not.” 

The failure to deal with those incidents loomed large in the ultimate conclusion Meyer failed in his management of Zach Smith, and that led to a three-game suspension without pay. 

Meyer admitted ignoring “red flags” surrounding Zach Smith and acknowledged his relationship with Smith’s grandfather, the late Earle Bruce, played a role in giving him the benefit of the doubt too often. 

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Sports

HS Roundup 9/19: Miami East girls golf team has record day

Two school records were set for the Miami East girls golf team in a 183-237 win versus Tri-Village on Wednesday. Paige Lawson posted a 38 to lead the way, setting a new individual low for East. Kearsten Kirby added a 44, Maci Krites a 48 and Marissa Kearns a 53. The 183 team score also marked a school record. Boys Soccer Bellefontaine 7, Indian Lake...
HS Results 9/19: Bellefontaine, Ben Logan, Northwestern win by shutout

Boys Soccer Wednesday’s Results Bellefontaine 7, Indian Lake 0 Benjamin Logan 1, Shawnee 0 Northwestern 1, Tecumseh 0 Urbana 2, Jonathan Alder 1 Tuesday’s Results Alter 0, Fenwick 0 Beavercreek 4, Northmont 0 Bellbrook 1, Eaton 1 Butler 8, Greenville 1 Centerville 2, Springboro 0 Colerain 1, Oak Hills 1 Dayton Christian 5, Bethel 1 Fairfield...
Cincinnati Bengals off to strong start, but injuries piling up
Cincinnati Bengals off to strong start, but injuries piling up

The Cincinnati Bengals are off to about as good of a start as they could hope for in terms of the results, but the same cannot be said for the health of the team. Cincinnati (2-0) travels to face the Carolina Panthers (1-1) on Sunday and will be using some backups at key positions in an offense that has been rolling through the first two games. »...
Week 4 area high school football passing leaders
Week 4 area high school football passing leaders

The following are area high school football passing leaders through Week 4. Southwest Ohio Conference: Connor Kinnett, jr., Harrison, 57 of 100 passing (57.0 percent), 1,040 yards, 10 TDs, 1 INT. Midwest Athletic Conference: Jake Hemmelgarn, jr., Coldwater, 77 of 102 passing (75.5 percent), 990 yards, 14 TDs, 4 INTs. Central Buckeye Conference: Chris...
Ryan Day to receive hefty one-time payment for serving as interim Ohio State football coach
Ryan Day to receive hefty one-time payment for serving as interim Ohio State football coach

How much is navigating a top five team through preseason and to a 3-0 start worth?  Nearly half a million dollars.  According to a letter released by the university Wednesday, Ohio State offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coach Ryan Day will be paid $487,000 for serving as interim head coach in Urban Meyer’s absence.  »...
More Stories