COMMENTARY: Cincinnati Bengals bringing back Marvin Lewis boggles the mind

The Cincinnati Bengals announced late Tuesday afternoon they don’t care about winning or selling tickets. 

The second part is a lot more surprising than the first (to be honest). 

RELATED: Marvin Lewis signs 2-year contract extension

OK, these things weren’t spelled out specifically in the press release confirming Marvin Lewis will be back as the team’s coach next fall, but they didn’t have to be. 

While Lewis did a lot of good things in his first 15 years coaching the Bengals, he hasn’t made it to the second weekend of the playoffs, let alone a championship game of any sort. 

Fans already started voting with their feet as the team finished 31st in home attendance this season, outdrawing only the essentially homeless Chargers, who played their home games in a soccer stadium less than half the size of Paul Brown Stadium. 


Don’t get me wrong. I don’t think fans should be calling the shots. That would be a disaster because fans are emotional and make rash decisions. 

And I’m not going to tell anyone how to spend their money, but it’s beyond me why anyone would do so for a team that doesn’t seem interested in getting better. 

(And of course that doesn’t mean giving up one’s fandom. It’s very easy to follow the team without spending money on it.) 

But the plethora of empty seats likely to be found at Paul Brown Stadium next season will be totally justified because fans have good reason to be fed up with what they’ve seen. 

For years I was one of those, “Be careful what you wish for…” people when it came to firing Lewis. 

His accomplishments are important, and they should be appreciated. 

They indicate he is (or at least was) a good coach. 

He knows talent. 

He’s done a good job constructing a staff multiple times. 

But the inability to get over the hump when it comes to big games really has to be a dealbreaker at some point, right? 

Especially when the team regresses two years in a row? 

(They won half a game more than last season but faced a weaker schedule and dropped from 13th to 24th in Football Outsiders total DVOA.) 

There will be time to pick this decision apart all winter, but my first reaction is that this is all mind-boggling. 

SPORTS TODAY: Marvin Lewis still wants to coach football edition

Does Lewis’ return mean Mike Brown has concluded none of the things that have gone wrong the last two years are the coach’s fault? 

If not him, then whom? 

Why play the games if it doesn’t matter if you win or lose or how you look doing so? 

This is all just bizarre. 

Moving on from Lewis certainly brings some risk, but as when Dusty Baker was fired by the Reds, doesn’t it feel like going forward with him no longer includes any positives? 

Is Brown simply that averse to change he can’t stand the thought of seeing if the locker room would react better to a new voice? 

There are a lot of good players — many of them fairly young — on this roster, but this team had no juice all year. 

Even though the Bengals botched the draft and free agency, there was reason to be excited when the season began because it was a clean slate from last year and the schedule seemed to present some opportunities. 

Then they laid a complete egg on opening day at home against the Ravens. A dreadful performance from start to finish headlined by the play of the alleged franchise quarterback. 

Then they lost to a banged-up Texans team with a rookie quarterback starting his first game

Houston won without even playing well. 

The rest of the season was pretty much a root canal thanks to that start. 

The offensive coordinator was fired, which was reason to cheer given how un-reactive the Bengals typically are, but alas the move to Bill Lazor only half fixed the offense. 

As in, the team was generally only good for about 30 minutes a week before completely collapsing. 

The defense was pretty good all year — even as injuries piled up late — but now come reports coordinator Paul Guenther is leaving, so what will become of that unit? 

That’s also interesting when considering staff turnover was one of the excuses cited for the team’s disappointing 2016. 

It has been suggested Lewis staying could mean less say for Brown and more say for Lewis, which could be a net positive. 

But we’ve heard that line before, and while the results of the 2011 reboot were promising for a while, the ceiling wasn’t really any higher than the first eight years. 

Is there any reason to believe it will be different now? 

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Sports

What Ravens coach Jim Harbaugh says about Sunday’s matchup vs. Bengals
What Ravens coach Jim Harbaugh says about Sunday’s matchup vs. Bengals

While the Cincinnati Bengals didn’t seem to solve any issues over the bye two weeks ago, history says John Harbaugh will have his Baltimore Ravens ready to go after their bye. Harbaugh is 8-2 in games after the bye during his 10 years with Baltimore, but he’s not certain that is a reason to be confident as the Ravens prepare to host the...
Dayton rallies from 8-point deficit in second half to beat Purdue Fort Wayne
Dayton rallies from 8-point deficit in second half to beat Purdue Fort Wayne

The Dayton Flyers pulled away in the last 10 minutes to beat Purdue Fort Wayne 91-80 on Friday at UD Arena, improving to 3-0 with third straight home victory to start the season. Dayton is now 17-17 in the last two seasons under coach Anthony Grant. The Flyers trailed by as many as eight points early in the second half. They went on a 9-0 run starting...
Dayton basketball fans will see complete lineup for the first time Friday
Dayton basketball fans will see complete lineup for the first time Friday

Dayton Flyers redshirt senior forward Josh Cunningham will make his season debut at 7 p.m. Friday against Purdue Fort Wayne at UD Arena. Cunningham missed the first two games against North Florida and Coppin State after suffering a hand injury Nov. 6 in practice. Obi Toppin, a redshirt freshman forward, started for Cunningham in those two games and...
Mechanicsburg senior player of year in Southwest District
Mechanicsburg senior player of year in Southwest District

Mechanicsburg senior running back Joey Mascadri was named an offensive player of the year and three Springfield players were named first team on the All-Southwest District high school football teams. A media panel of Southwest District reps, one of nine throughout the state, announced the teams on Thursday. Players are nominated by coaches and voted...
Cincinnati Reds talking trade with New York Yankees?
Cincinnati Reds talking trade with New York Yankees?

The Cincinnati Reds have talked to the New York Yankees about a potential trade for starting pitcher Sonny Gray, according to Jon Morosi of Gray, 29, was 11-9 with a 4.90 ERA last season in 23 starts. In 30 appearances, the right-hander struck out 123 and walked 57 in 130 1/3 innings. Gray spent his first five plus seasons with the Oakland...
More Stories