What ever happened to Arthur Treacher’s Fish and Chips?

There was only one place to get fish and chips in the 1970’s.

Seafood is a tricky cuisine to get right. If you don't live near one of the coasts, it's not fresh. It can also be expensive, so not many national fast food chains are willing to put it on the menu.  

In the 1970s, however, there was one place you could rely on for good, inexpensive seafood. 

 >>RELATED: Sheryl Crow eats at THIS Dayton restaurant for its fish and chips 

You didn't have to look too far to find it either. At its peak, Arthur Treacher's Fish & Chips had about 800 locations across the country.  

Fast forward to today, and the restaurant chain conjures up images of a bygone era.  

So what happened to one of the country's largest fast food chains? Just like many fads of the 1970s, it went out of style. But there were also outside factors involved.

 >>RELATED: Long John Silver’s shuts down one of its local restaurants

Not many people remember that the restaurant chain was named after the English actor of the same name. Arthur Treacher is best remembered today as Jeeves the butler in several Shirley Temple films. 

Despite the English name and branding, the chain was founded in 1969 in Columbus, Ohio.  

>>RELATED: The best places to get sushi in Dayton

Unlike chains that started off slow, Arthur Treachers aggressively expanded right off the bat. By the early 1970s, hundreds of locations were in operation across the county.  

It was the perfect storm for the fast food chain focused on seafood. Anyone could get a burger from Burger Chef or McDonalds, but only at Arthur Treacher's could you get their famous cod fish and chips. The restaurant's specialty became especially important for many families during Lent, when Catholics are prohibited from consuming meat on Fridays.

But the perfect storm quickly turned into a devastating hurricane. The expansion of chains like McDonalds and Burger King in the 1970s forced many younger and regional chains out of business.  

On top of that, the price of cod skyrocketed in the 1970s due to the "Cod Wars." Iceland imposed a 200-mile fishing limit around the country, meaning British fishing companies lost access to waters rich with cod. In fact, the two countries almost went to war over the issue.

>>RELATED: 40 things we love about Jay's Seafood

In 1979, Arthur Treacher's parent company, Orange Co., sold the brand to Mrs. Paul's Seafood. The new owners quickly replaced the cod with less expensive pollock, but the change alienated consumers. 

Throughout the 1980s, Arthur Treacher's went through several owners and quickly began to lose ground to its competitors. Before long, hundreds of locations shuttered, and the chain was a shell of its former self.

>>RELATED: Cheap Eats at Sea Jax in Kettering

The chain isn't completely gone, however. There are seven remaining locations around the country - three in New York and four in Ohio.

"People drive by, look up and notice the lantern and then stop in," says restaurant owner Ben Vittoria of Garfield Heights, Ohio. "They're shocked to see that we're still open."

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Dining

Public Enemy performs at Dayton woman’s wedding 
Public Enemy performs at Dayton woman’s wedding 

A band that has been fighting the power for more than three decades performed for the first time in four years at a Dayton woman’s wedding.  It makes sense. The groom was a member of Public Enemy.  Robin Dugger and Norman “DJ Terminator X” Rogers were married Saturday, Nov. 17 at Residence Park Church...
Yes, you can make turkey stuffing out of White Castle burgers. Here’s how.
Yes, you can make turkey stuffing out of White Castle burgers. Here’s how.

Yes, you read that right. Sounds crazy, doesn’t it? Well, according to food writer Mark Fisher’s tips and tricks for surviving Thanksgiving, it’s a pretty legit offbeat stuffing recipe. Oh, and it’s simple, too. Here’s how it’s done, according to White Castle: - 10 White Castle sliders, (no pickles) from either...
Long-closed Dayton club re-emerging for a night this weekend
Long-closed Dayton club re-emerging for a night this weekend

The DJ boat booth, heavy duty shark cage used for dancing and nude mannequins were moved out long ago. The building it once inhabited now provides shelter for homeless teenagers, but the spirit of that Asylum Nightclub lives on, Matt Freeman says. Freeman, a longtime DJ at the alternative music dance club, will host the 2018 installment...
Inn serves traditional holiday dinner on Thanksgiving
Inn serves traditional holiday dinner on Thanksgiving

If you’re looking for someone else to do the cooking on Thanksgiving, the traditional buffet with turkey, ham and more at the Quality Inn and Conference Center may be the perfect place to celebrate the holiday. Location: 383 East Leffel Lane, Springfield Contact: www.canus.gm@gmail.com, (937) 323-8631 Quality Inn and Conference Center by Choice...
All the Black Friday deals to catch in 2018
All the Black Friday deals to catch in 2018

Get ready, get set and start planning so that you're ready in time for this year's Black Friday sales events. From now until Thanksgiving Day, all the top stores will start revealing their biggest Black Friday deals in preparation for the huge holiday rush. Good news, Atlanta! Some of the best Black Friday ads have already leaked, allowing you...
More Stories