Dayton woman ate at Pine Club with her Aunt Barbara and Uncle George

“She said ‘George wants a steak,’” niece of former president recalls. 

When Sharon Rafferty Patterson’s Uncle George wanted a Pine Club steak, Sharon Rafferty Patterson’s Uncle George got a Pine Club steak. 

Makes sense. 

Rafferty Patterson’s Uncle George was then Vice President George H.W. Bush and in the running for the nation’s top post. 

Bush, the 41st president of the United States, died Friday at the age of 94. 

>> President George H.W. Bush, Barbara Bush had deep family ties to Ohio

His wife Barbara Bush, the younger sister of Rafferty Patterson’s mother Martha 

Pierce Rafferty, died April 17 at age 92. 


George and Barbara Bush headed to Dayton just days after he accepted the Republican presidential nomination. 

Rafferty Patterson received a phone call shortly after a rally Aug. 20, 1988 in West Carrollton.

>> George H.W. Bush in Dayton region, southwest Ohio: Highlights from his visits

“Barbara called me up and said, ‘Do you want to go to the Pine Club?’” recalled Rafferty Patterson, a former resident of Oakwood and Dayton’s Oregon District neighborhood. 

Rafferty Patterson said she tried to persuade her aunt to go somewhere a little more private, but no dice. 

“She said ‘George wants a steak’,” she recalled Barbara saying. 

She assumes her Uncle George had heard about The Pine Club, 1926 Brown St., and its acclaimed steaks. 

>> Cooking Channel pushes back The Pine Club’s ‘Best Thing I Ever Ate’ shout-out 

“You want a steak in Dayton, Ohio, you go to The Pine Club,” Rafferty Patterson said.

She and her husband Tim Patterson, a great nephew of famed Dayton luminary John Patterson, met George and Barbara Bush for dinner at the restaurant located at 1926 Brown St. after the Secret Service secured a table. 

The Pine Club famously does not take reservations. 

Dave (Hulme) does not make exceptions, but when we got there, there was a table because the Secret Service got a table,” she recalled. “He was brought in and seated.” 

>> Daytonian of the Week: David Hulme, owner of the Pine Club

The presidential couple did not go unnoticed. 

“There were people standing around us. Some of them I know,” she said. “Some of them went home and changed their clothes and were kind of loitering.”


Rafferty said there were two points during dinner that caused her concern.

The first came when her uncle asked for dessert, which the Pine Club does not offer (not even the ice cream her uncle asked for). 

The second came when her husband missed the chance to grab the check. 

>> Guess where Robert Redford and Tom Waits ate when they were in town?

Rafferty Patterson said she feared her uncle would try to pay with a credit card, which the Pine Club famously does not accept. 

She was relieved when her uncle instead pulled out cash, reporting paying $93 plus a “generous 15 percent tip.”


A Connecticut native, Rafferty Patterson met the boy who would be her husband during summer breaks in the New York resort town where they now reside. 

Her family has its own Dayton ties. 

Rafferty Patterson’s grandparents (Barbara and Martha’s parents) , Marvin Pierce and Pauline Robinson, met at Miami University in Oxford. 

Barbara made trips to Dayton when her father worked for McCall Corporation and the family lived in New York years later.

Marvin Pierce went on to be the president of McCall’s, the publisher of Redbook and McCall’s.

>> Did you know Barbara Bush’s grandfather was a founder of the Dayton Rotary Club?

Rafferty Patterson said her Great Aunt Charlotte Pierce — her grandfather’s sister — was a teacher in Oakwood. 

Although they left Dayton in 2004, Rafferty Patterson and her husband visit Dayton often to see their grandchildren and children, Meaghan Carter of Huber Heights and Rockwell Patterson, a resident of Dayton’s South Park neighborhood. 

The couple is in Dayton this week volunteering for the Oregon Historic District Society’s Candlelight Holiday Tour.

>> PHOTOS: The Legendary Lights of Clifton Mill will take your breath away

Rafferty Patterson and her husband will greet tour takers in the John H. Balsley home on East Sixth Street, one of their former Dayton- area residences.


Rafferty Patterson said their life in politics made it hard to be close to her aunt and uncle, but she was always fond of them even though she did not always agree with her uncle’s politics. 

“George Bush, outside of being pretty attractive, was very smart and very funny,” she said. “Barbara was lovely. She had little bit of an edge to her as did my mother... It would come in her head and come out of her mouth. She would tell it like it was, but was very lovely.”

>> 6 things you didn’t know about NCR’s John Patterson

At age 21, Rafferty Patterson lived in Houston with George and Barbara Bush when he ran for Senate in 1964. 

She worked in her uncle’s campaign office with her then 18-year-old cousin George W. Bush, mostly stuffing envelopes. 
“Barbara gave us the car and a dollar each day for lunch,” she said.  

“All I could really remember is when it was time to go home,  he (George W. Bush) was nowhere around.”

Rafferty Patterson said she last saw George W. Bush, the 43rd President of the United States, at her Aunt Barbara’s funeral. 

Although she had been close with her aunt for a while, she hadn’t seen her uncle for about 20 years until the funeral and understands why. 

“Politics drew a great big line with us spending time with them,” she said. “They were not hanging out with the likes of us. It’s too bad. It certainly took them out of our family. We didn’t see them and we did not know the cousins.”

>> RELATED: Moving photo of George H.W. Bush’s service dog lying near casket 

During George H.W. Bush’s time in the White House, Barbara Bush attended Rafferty Patterson’s father’s funeral in Connecticut. 

The president did not attend. 

 “She was a commotion,” Rafferty Patterson said. “He tripled it.” 

Still, there are fond memories. 

Rafferty Patterson remembers riding in a golf course with her aunt while her uncle was here for a charity golf event and the time her daughter Meaghan, then a student at Chaminade Julienne Catholic High School, talked herself through Secret Service to see Barbara during one of the couple’s visits to Dayton. 

Being the niece of a president and a first lady was an unique experience, Rafferty said. 

“It’s a little strange. First they are your relatives, and then they are all over the place,” she said. “It means you don’t see them that much, and when you do it is in a big crowd and where everyone wants to see them.” 

>> Texans honor former President George H.W. Bush with moment of silence



Reader Comments

Next Up in Springfield Entertainment

Christmas gift fail? A toy that’s powered by yelling and chases kids is freaking people out
Christmas gift fail? A toy that’s powered by yelling and chases kids is freaking people out

“The louder you yell, the faster they go.” The advertising slogan for a new spider-like Hasbro toy line, Yellies, caters to the boisterous kid that gets a thrill out of voice-activated toys, but some critics are calling the toy a parent’s worst nightmare. >> Read more trending news  Hasbro introduced the controversial new...
Pete Davidson appears on 'SNL' after concerning Instagram post, deleting account
Pete Davidson appears on 'SNL' after concerning Instagram post, deleting account

Pete Davidson made an appearance on this week's "Saturday Night Live," putting worried fans at ease hours after the comedian told his Instagram followers that he didn't "want to be on this Earth anymore" before deleting his account. "I'm doing my best to stay here for you but I actually don't know how much longer I can last...
Offset crashes Cardi B show, takes stage to beg for forgiveness
Offset crashes Cardi B show, takes stage to beg for forgiveness

Awkward. Less than two weeks after Cardi B announced her split from her husband, Offset, the Migos rapper made a surprising attempt to win back his ex Saturday night as she performed at the Rolling Loud Festival in Los Angeles. According to Variety, Cardi, whose real name is Belcalis Almanzar, and her fans looked stunned as Offset took the stage. Standing...
’Blurred Lines’ lawsuit: Robin Thicke, Pharrell Williams must pay Marvin Gaye’s family $5M
’Blurred Lines’ lawsuit: Robin Thicke, Pharrell Williams must pay Marvin Gaye’s family $5M

The legal dust-up between Robin Thicke, Pharrell Williams and the family of the late singer Marvin Gaye is finally over. A judge has ruled Thicke and Williams must pay Gaye’s family nearly $5 million over a copyright infringement lawsuit that claimed the songwriters used Gaye’s 1977 song “Got to Give It Up” in their 2013...
Chris Pratt makes Katherine Schwarzenegger relationship social media official
Chris Pratt makes Katherine Schwarzenegger relationship social media official

It was one of the worst kept Hollywood relationship secrets, but now actor Chris Pratt has made it Instagram-official. He is dating Katherine Schwarzenegger, daughter of actor and former governor, Arnold Schwarzenegger and his ex-wife, Maria Shriver. Pratt, 39, posted photos and a birthday message for Katherine Schwarzenegger. While the couple has...
More Stories