Those who lost in Springboro man’s $66M Ponzi scheme want money from winners

The investors who lost the most in the William Apostelos Ponzi scheme have filed a lawsuit against those who they call “net winners” to recover some of their losses in the scam that cost hundreds of people millions of dollars.

The 19 named plaintiffs are suing 56 individual and company defendants and a potential class of 100 John or Jane Does to get back money from those who may have benefited from their investments with the Springboro man serving a 15-year federal sentence for fraud.

Apostelos’ wife, Connie, and others also were sentenced to prison.

RELATED: ‘Bernie Madoff of Dayton’ ordered to serve 15 years, pay back $32M

A U.S. Bankruptcy Court case against Apostelos may be in jeopardy because the case administrator says they cannot get information they need from federal prosecutors to move forward, according to court documents.

Toby Henderson, the attorney bringing the lawsuit in Montgomery County Common Pleas Court, said the lawsuit is designed to get the “claw-back” money that the bankruptcy case was to seek.

RELATED: William Apostelos pleads guilty in Ponzi scheme

The Ponzi scheme using several shell companies raised at least $66.7 million from 350 investors, “including business persons, professionals, retired police officers and retired factory workers,” according to the lawsuit.

“Apostelos portrayed himself as a sophisticated investor and businessman, and he exploited his network of clients, business associates, and friends to attract new investors. Many investors invested their retirement savings and lost their entire investments to the scheme.”

RELATED: Seizures in Ponzi case include race horses, cash, jewelry and artwork

Henderson said the tough thing about the litigation is that early investors who told friends and family about Apostelos may now have to pay back money to later investors who lost life savings.

“Not all investors lost money,” the lawsuit said. “In furtherance of the scheme, Apostelos distributed millions of the proceeds to a select group of investors.

MORE: Read other stories from Mark Gokavi

“That is, numerous investors in the Apostelos Ponzi-Scheme were ‘Net-Winners’ (those investors who received more money from Apostelos than they invested in principal), identified herein as the ‘Net Winner Defendants.’

“This class of investors benefited from the scheme directly out of the monies paid to Apostelos by Plaintiffs. The Net Winner Defendants reaped enormous profits.”

SOCIAL MEDIA: Follow Mark Gokavi on Twitter or Facebook

A handful of defendants have started to receive service of the lawsuit, according to court records.

No attorneys are named for defendants, and no court dates have been set.


Next Up in Crime

Gorilla walks on two legs to keep hands clean
Gorilla walks on two legs to keep hands clean

When it gets too muddy, or his hands are full, Louis, a silverback gorilla at the Philadelphia Zoo walks on two legs so he does not get his hands dirty. A volunteer at the zoo recently shared footage of Louis scampering across his pen on two legs. “People are often surprised to hear that despite his appearance of a tough male gorilla, (Louis)...
Blink-182 announces 16-show Las Vegas residency
Blink-182 announces 16-show Las Vegas residency

Blink-182 has announced a Las Vegas residency, joining the likes of pop stars Britney Spears, Cher, Bruno Mars, Jennifer Lopez and Lady Gaga. But unlike many other musicians, the rock band won’t be in Vegas for years on end. >> Read more trending news  People reported Monday that the band is starting a 16-date residency starting Memorial...
Why was Andrew McCabe fired? What we know now
Why was Andrew McCabe fired? What we know now

Attorney General Jeff Sessions fired Andrew McCabe late Friday, hours before the former assistant director of the FBI was to retire. Sessions said in a statement that McCabe was let go for “lacking candor under oath” in misleading investigators about the fact that he authorized a conversation between FBI employees and The Wall Street...
NYC man faces charges after baby found alone on subway platform 
NYC man faces charges after baby found alone on subway platform 

A New York City man is facing charges that include child abandonment after a 6-month-old girl was found alone on a subway platform early Sunday, WNYW reported. According to police, Joshua Perez, 26, was with the child and her mother, Vanessa Almodovar, 27. According to police, the couple got into an argument inside the 110th Street train station...
Clark County Common Pleas Court cases
Clark County Common Pleas Court cases

COMMON PLEAS COURT NEW SUITS 18-DP-0171 - Rebecca A. Padgitt, 3032 Willow Run Cir., v. Jonathan Padgitt, Urbana, petition for domestic violence civil protection order. PROBATE COURT Marriage Licenses Tyler Michael Sindle, 23, Springfield, business owner/firefighter, and Samantha Jo Barnette, 22, Springfield. Asyah Nicole Payne, 22, 602 Isabella St...
More Stories