Wittenberg drove to the Washington & Jefferson 38 on its next drive, but quarterback Blake King, making his first career start, fumbled after being sacked. Nick Getz recovered the ball at the 48 and returned it 52 yards for a touchdown, giving the Presidents a 16-8 lead.
» FINCHAM TRADITION: The story of the Coffee Pot Letter
Wittenberg got the ball three more times but did not threaten to score.
Wittenberg trailed 7-0 early but got on the board with a safety at the 5:09 mark in the first quarter and took an 8-7 lead on a 35-yard touchdown pass from King to Thaddeus Snodgrass with 7:54 left in the first half.
Washington & Jefferson won despite throwing four interceptions in the first half. Each team recorded 10 first downs. The Tigers gained more than twice as many yards (256-120) but were 1 of 16 on third down.
King completed 11 of 20 passes for 122 yards. He was sacked five times. The Tigers lost three fumbles.
Jake Saus led Wittenberg receivers with three catches for 55 yards. Jaheem Washington rushed eight times for 55 yards.
led the defense with six tackles. Trevor Good had three sacks.