Sports Today: Can the Browns go wrong with the NFL draft’s first pick?

The obvious answer is yes, but hear me out…. 

I already posted my seven takeaways from NFL draft analyst Mike Mayock’s annual pre-combine conference call yesterday, so check those out if you would.

Here’s something else I found interesting: His top two quarterbacks both have pretty sizable red flags, at least if you are talking about using a high first-round pick on them. 

That of course could present quite a conundrum for the Cleveland Browns, who have the No. 1 and 4 picks in the draft. 

(Maybe they should make it easy on themselves and take Penn State running back Saquon Barkely with the first pick then be happy with whoever falls to them at four, but I doubt that is going to happen.) 

Mayock has USC’s Sam Darnold on top of his quarterbacks board with Wyoming’s Josh Allen second. 

Different physical attributes are the reason. In the case of Darnold, it is his ability to extend plays and find the open man. 

For Allen, that magical right arm has everyone drooling. 

The problem is Darnold turns the ball over too much and Allen has accuracy issues. 

These, of course, are the two worst things a quarterback can do on the field, so it’s hard to dismiss either of them no matter how much you like the other things you see. 

Adding much intrigue to this is Lamar Jackson. The Louisville quarterback could end up being the draft’s ultimate wild card even though the big question about him is probably more solvable than those about Darnold and Allen. That would be, “Can you run an offense in which Jackson can thrive?” 

The answer to this should be yes, but likely few NFL teams are willing to make that bet on themselves even as they would be willing to risk turning their franchise over to a guy who might never protect the ball adequately (Darnold) or another who perhaps can’t make it go where he wants consistently (Allen). 

Weird, huh? 

I’m not sure how the Browns will play this. 

They could end up liking UCLA’s Josh Rosen or Oklahoma’s Baker Mayfield better than any of those other three. 

(I’ve already laid out the case for the Bengals taking Jackson, by the way, and if Mayock’s prediction he goes somewhere in the second half is correct, there could still be an opportunity to trade back up and snag him after addressing the offensive line at No. 12.) 

Monday was a pretty good day for Ohio State basketball. 

Chris Holtmann was named Big Ten Coach of the Year in men’s basketball while the player of the year honors went to a man and a woman from the Scarlet and Gray. 

(He was wise to snap that up this year since the Buckeyes will likely be too good for him to be considered in future seasons because voters are a bit too committed to that line of thinking.)

Keita Bates-Diop and Kelsey Mitchell earned those honors, marking the third time OSU had the top player in both genders since 2006. 

In 2006, it was Jessica Davenport and Terence Dials while Evan Turner and Jantel Lavender were so honored in 2010.

Mitchell (who shared POY honors with Megan Gustafson of Iowa) is Ohio State’s third three-time Big Ten Player of the Year on the women’s side since 2007, joining Davenport and Lavender (who actually won the award all four years she was a Buckeye). 

Ohio State center Stephanie Mavunga also made the All-Big Ten first team. 

A late-season injury may have cost Middletown’s Vincent Edwards a spot on the all-conference first team, but the Purdue senior still landed on the second team… 

Sticking with Ohio State, Mayock covered five Buckeyes in his pre-combine conference call yesterday: 

“I think they're tied with Alabama for 33 players invited to the combine in the last three years. Kind of crazy,” Mayock said.

“(Cornerback) Denzel Ward to me is a top 10 pick in this draft. Billy Price, the center/guard, is a late 1 to mid 2, a solid plug-and-play guy. The defensive end, (Sam) Hubbard, is not flashy, but he's going to come in and start immediately for somebody. Probably second round, worst case, third round.

"I already mentioned (Jerome) Baker, the linebacker, who I think is going to light up this combine. He's got some good days and not so good days, but I think his physical specifications match up with today's NFL. The left tackle, Jamarco Jones, probably a third or fourth round type of guy. Very solid player.

“The free safety [presumably Damon Webb] I think is more of a third-day guy.”

Earlier in the call, he predicted Baker will impress scouts with a 4.5-second 40-yard dash at 225 pounds, and later he said Hubbard “checks off all the boxes” scouts want to see and could become more of a sure-thing first-rounder if he runs something like a 4.5 in the 40. 

He also said he worries if Ward is too “light and lean,” which seems a bit odd. 

Perhaps most noteworthy were his thoughts on the Ohio State quarterback in this draft class. 

“J.T. Barrett is a hard one for me because I love the kid,” Mayock said. “I got to meet him a little bit at the East-West game. You can see the leadership attributes. Everything you want in the quarterback he has, except for the high-level talent.

“So from my perspective, he's probably going to be a later third day guy, and somebody's going to buy into him because they love the kid and what he brings to the table in the meeting room and try to give him a chance to develop over time. He's an ideal back-up or third quarterback, and I think he'll play in the league for a lot of years.” 

Sounds a lot better than the chances he’s been given up to this point, but then almost all draft speculation prior to January is pretty much worthless. 

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Sports

Wright State falls short in bid to reach NCAA tourney
Wright State falls short in bid to reach NCAA tourney

The Wright State men’s soccer team had hoped it did enough to make the field of 48 in the NCAA tournament for the first time. The Raiders have an RPI rating of 35 and were ranked all season in the national polls until falling to UIC in the Horizon League championship. But despite a banner year under first-year coach Jake Slemker, they weren&rsquo...
Meyer says Buckeyes won’t have trouble focusing on Maryland this week
Meyer says Buckeyes won’t have trouble focusing on Maryland this week

Ohio State began its 11th game week of the season Monday, and that can only mean one thing. Urban Meyer needed to talk to his team about not thinking about the ninth-ranked Buckeyes’ 12th game week of the season yet. The latter, of course, will lead up to a game against Michigan. With the Buckeyes and Wolverines (No. 4) both in the top 10 this...
Urban Meyer endorses play of Ohio State offensive line
Urban Meyer endorses play of Ohio State offensive line

The play of Ohio State’s offensive line has been a bit of a lightning rod among the fan base this season.  The head coach provided an endorsement of the group Monday — but he wants to see more. “I think we could play a little bit better,” Meyer said two days after the Buckeyes beat Michigan State 26-6. “That was a...
Bengals Report Card: Grading Sunday’s 51-14 loss to the Saints
Bengals Report Card: Grading Sunday’s 51-14 loss to the Saints

The Cincinnati Bengals were missing their best player on offense Sunday, and the defense just didn’t show up at all. The result was one of the worst losses in franchise history, as the Bengals fell 51-14 to the New Orleans Saints. »RELATED: Bengals reportedly fire defensive coordinator »RELATED: 5 takeaways from Bengals’ blowout...
Cincinnati Bengals: Head coach Marvin Lewis to take over team’s struggling defense
Cincinnati Bengals: Head coach Marvin Lewis to take over team’s struggling defense

One day after an embarrassing defensive performance in a season full of them, the Bengals fired defensive coordinator Teryl Austin. Bengals head coach Marvin Lewis, a former defensive coordinator for the Baltimore Ravens, will take over the defense moving forward. “I appreciate the hard work that Coach Austin has put into our football team, but...
More Stories