Hartman: Ohio State probably passed itself out of playoff contention

I ended up in a little bit of a college football stats rabbit hole Thursday night and came away with one of those realizations I wish I’d had at least a month ago. 

It was something I suspected but never did enough research to confirm until now. 

Alabama is probably playing for the national title because the Crimson Tide trusted its running game more than Ohio State did.

I mean, yeah, this is admittedly a fun assumption for any old-school football lover like myself to make. 

It felt much of the season like Ohio State over-relied on J.T. Barrett’s arm, but sometimes feelings are wrong, right?

RELATED: Ohio State football and the disappearing tailback runs

Well, some numbers back up these potential ramblings of a crazy person better than I might have expected.

Barrett and Alabama quarterback Jalen Hurts posted very strong passer ratings and similar completion percentages. (Barrett finished ninth in the nation in pass efficiency while Hurts was 11th.) 

I don’t know how many of Hurts’ completion were screens of various type, but I doubt it was much (if any) more than Barrett, who averaged slightly more yards per attempt while leading an attack that was frequently assailed for not pushing the ball down the field enough. 

Here’s the thing, though: Barrett threw 125 more passes (in one more game so far).

He also ran more times than Hurts despite averaging fewer yards per carry (not to mention being hurt in the last two games). 

RELATED: Ranking the top Ohio State quarterbacks of all time

And here’s the kicker: Ohio State’s running game, though less utilized, was better statistically than Alabama’s, too, according to Football Outsiders

Weird, huh? 

That’s especially interesting when considering the narrative that became dominant in the latter part of the season and throughout December: Ohio State’s defense was to be respected, but the offense just wasn’t championship-worthy. 

I’ve seen plenty of Ohio State fans wave off being left out of the playoff with this justification*. 

Well, guess whose offense scored a significantly higher S&P+ at Football Outsiders? Yep, it was the Buckeyes

And the obvious conclusion to be drawn from that? 

Urban Meyer, Kevin Wilson, et al, may have mismanaged this offense even more than anyone realized -- until it was too late. 

*This is not an argument about who should have made the playoff but rather an example of how Ohio State might have really screwed up offensively by continually treating him like a combination of Drew Brees and Braxton Miller rather than Alex Smith. 

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Sports

HS Roundup 8/15: Carlisle boys card 176 in win

A.J. Keeton’s 39 helped lead Carlisle to a 176-248 win versus Northridge in boys golf action on Wednesday. Keeton picked up medalist honors and Dalton Smith tacked on a 44 for Carlisle. Justin Triplett shot a season-low 54 for Northridge. Boys Golf Ben Logan 166, Kenton Ridge 180: Ethan Ricketts totaled a 39, Garrett Allen a 40 and Trey Allen...
HS Scores 8/15: Triad edges Southeastern in girls golf

Girls Golf Wednesday’s Results New Bremen 207, Versailles 213 St. Henry 198, Marion Local 257 Triad 206, Southeastern 208 Tuesday’s Results Ben Logan 174, Riverside 199, North Union 229 Greenville 217, Troy 219 Greeneview 211, Madison Plains 225 Mechanicsburg 237, Triad 238 Diana Schwab Mixed Invitational At Beavercreek Team Results: Lebanon...
High schools: GCL Coed, Roger Bacon fighting competitive balance, get temporary restraining order against OHSAA
High schools: GCL Coed, Roger Bacon fighting competitive balance, get temporary restraining order against OHSAA

The Ohio High School Athletic Association’s competitive balance plan has become a legal issue. The OHSAA said Wednesday it was informed that the Hamilton County Court of Common Pleas has issued a temporary restraining order (TRO) that prohibits the OHSAA from continuing to utilize a component of the competitive balance process that OHSAA member...
McCoy: Freefallin’ Reds put ‘interim’ manager Riggleman in tough spot
McCoy: Freefallin’ Reds put ‘interim’ manager Riggleman in tough spot

What can a manager do? What can he say to his team when it is so deep in last place it can’t see the next-to-last team without the Hubble Telescope - and then it is a faint view? That’s the situation Cincinnati Reds manager Jim Riggleman finds himself in as he tries to make enough of an impression so the front office removes the interim...
Northeastern looking to compete in loaded OHC North Division
Northeastern looking to compete in loaded OHC North Division

Northeastern High School football coach Jake Buchholtz has one goal for the Jets program – rebuild the winning culture. The first-year coach has seen great competition early in the preseason. “It starts with competing with one another,” he said. “That’s been a big push for us. If we can’t compete with one another...
More Stories