Carlos Hyde vs. Jeremy Hill: Final answer

Remember when the Cincinnati Bengals passed on Ohio State star Carlos Hyde to draft Jeremy Hill out of LSU instead? 

It happened four years ago, and it is worth revisiting with news of Hyde planning to sign with the Cleveland Browns this week

Was it the right move or not? 

Let’s review how their careers have gone so far: 

Hill made a big splash early in Cincinnati. 

He ran for 1,124 yards and nine touchdowns as a rookie in 2014 despite starting only half of the games that season. He averaged 5.1 yards per carry. 

Since then, though, things have not gone so well. Over the last three seasons, Hill has 1,749 yards, and he has failed to average even four yards per carry in any of those campaigns. 

He did the Ickey Shuffle, which was cool, but he also lost a crucial fumble that set off a series of events that led to a devastating loss in the playoffs to Pittsburgh. 

Meanwhile, Hyde’s career has followed nearly the opposite arc. 

The Cincinnati native ran for only 333 yards as a rookie and 470 in his second season in the NFL while struggling to stay healthy. 

The past two seasons, Hyde has looked more like a valuable pro running back, totaling 1,926 yards in 29 games. 

So while one of them looked like a big-time NFL back early in his career, the other has been better lately. 

What about the picture in full? 

Through four years Hyde has put up better numbers despite playing for a much worse team. 

Hyde: 54.6 yards per game, 4.2 yards per carry, 21 touchdowns, 109 catches, 634 yards, 3 touchdowns, 3,363 yards from scrimmage. 

Hill: 53.2 yards per game, 4.1 yards per carry, 29 rushing touchdowns, 67 catches, 484 yards, 1 touchdown, 3,357 yards from scrimmage. 

Hill finished last season in Injured Reserve and is still looking for work while Hyde is set to sign a new contract on the first day of free agency. 

So it looks like, yes, the Bengals should have gone with the higher-rated prospect who also happened to have played 90 minutes up the road instead of dipping into the SEC talent pool again, and not just because it might have appealed to a few free agent fans in the center of the state. 

But now they figure to get a closer look at him twice a year for the next three seasons anyway. 

On the bright side, Cincinnati already seems to have found its running back of the future in Joe Mixon. 

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Sports

Division IV: All-Ohio boys basketball
Division IV: All-Ohio boys basketball

The Division IV boys basketball All-Ohio team was announced Monday by a statewide media panel. The teams were selected by members of the Ohio Prep Sportswriters Association. »RELATED: Ahrens, Barhorst earn top D-IV boys honors »RELATED: Trotwood-Madison head back to final four FIRST TEAM: Lukas Isaly, Hannibal River, 5-11, sr., 24.4; Mark...
Two positions likely available for Reds’ Opening-Day roster
Two positions likely available for Reds’ Opening-Day roster

Ready or not, the 2018 major-league baseball season starts in 10 days. Bryan Price knows who his 10 starting position players are. Yes, there are only eight for any given game, but Price considers four outfielders - Adam Duvall, Billy Hamilton, Scott Schebler and Jesse Winker - starters. Catchers Tucker Barnhart and Devin Mesoraco will not be in a...
Opposing coach on Trotwood: ‘They’re crazy athletic’
Opposing coach on Trotwood: ‘They’re crazy athletic’

The Trotwood-Madison boys basketball team will be a heavy favorite to win an elusive state championship this weekend. The first challenge will be to overcome newcomer Byesville Meadowbrook in Friday’s final four semifinals. Trotwood (25-3) will play Meadowbrook (22-6) at 10:45 a.m. Friday at Ohio State University’s Schottenstein Center...
End of an era for OSU’s Kelsey Mitchell

Kelsey Mitchell’s last shot in an Ohio State women’s basketball uniform was one she made at least a couple hundred times before: A pull-up jumper from a few feet behind the 3-point line that hit nothing but net. Unfortunately for the third-seeded Buckeyes, this one came well after the outcome of their second-round NCAA tournament game against...
Ahrens, Barhorst earn top D-III All-Ohio honors
Ahrens, Barhorst earn top D-III All-Ohio honors

Versailles High School senior Justin Ahrens has been named the boys high school basketball Division III player of the year and Anna’s Nate Barhorst the D-III coach of the year. Their selections, along with other D-III and D-IV All-Ohio boys basketball teams, were announced on Monday by the Ohio Prep Sportswriters Association. An outstanding offensive...
More Stories