Best of Hal: Top 25 Cincinnati Reds All-Stars

In 2015, Hal McCoy was in his 40th year of being the team’s beat writer. To mark the return of the Major League All-Star game to Cincinnati that season, Hal listed his top 25 Reds All-Stars up until that season. With pitchers  and catchers reporting soon, here’s Hal’s list. 

Read Hal’s Reds Blog: The Real McCoy


Position: Catcher 

All-Star selections: 14 (1968, 69, 1970, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79, 1980, 83) 

Hal’s take: Did he invent the catching position? It seems that way because he is the best I’ve ever seen and probably ever will see.


Position: 2B, OF, 3B 
All-Star selections: 17 (1965, 67, 68, 69, 1970, 71, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79, 80, 81, 82, 85) 
Hal’s take: He played every game as if it was an All-Star Game, and nobody ever played the game harder and got the most out of his ability


Position: 3B, 1B 
All-Star selections: 7 (1967, 68, 69, 1970, 74, 75, 76) 
Hal’s take: The best clutch hitter I ever saw, and as former manager Dave Bristol said, “If there is a way to win a baseball game, Tony Perez will find it.”


Position: 2B 
All-Star selections: 10 (1966, 1970, 1972, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79) 
Hal’s take: Little Joe was Big Joe on the baseball field and there was nothing in the game he couldn’t do and do it better than most.


Position: SP 
All-Star selections: 3 (1982, 83, 84) 
Hal’s take: Maybe the best Reds pitcher I ever covered and got people out with only two pitches, a fastball and a changeup, and batters had difficulty hitting either pitch.


Position: OF All-Star selections: 2 (1987, 89) 
Hal’s take: A five-tool playerwho would be in the Hall of Fame right now had he not played so hard that injuries slowed him down.


Position: OF 
All-Star selections: 5 (1976, 77, 78, 79, 1981) 
Hal’s take: The most underrated member of the Big Red Machine and one of the strongest players I ever covered.


Position: SS 
All-Star selections: 12 (1988, 89, 1990, 91, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 99, 2000, 04) 
Hal’s take: Helped redefine shortstop from just a defensive position to an offensive and defensive position.


Position: OF 
All-Star selections: 13 (1990, 91, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 98, 99, 2000, 04, 07) 
Hal’s take: Most of his stardom came as a member of the Seattle Mariners, but The Kid was a great player for the Reds when injuries didn’t curtail his play.


Position: SP 
All-Star selections: 1 (1994) 
Hal’s take: Not only a great pitcher but also one of the most popular players ever with both the fans and the media.


Position: SS 

All-Star selections: 9 (1973, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79, 1980, 81, 82,) 
Hal’s take: Should be in the Hall of Fame because he was the best shortstop of his era and learned how to hit in the clutch in the later stages of his career.


Position: OF 
All-Star selections: 3 (1976, 77, 1980) 
Hal’s take: Wasn’t as good as his illustrious son, but he was an excellent hitter with exceptional speed and a solid hitter for average, though not as powerful as his more famous son.


Position: 3B 
All-Star selections: 3(1988,1990,91) 
Hal’s take: Spuds McKenzie and his goggles was a fan favorite and marched not only to the beat of a different drummer, but he was the drummer and a solid third baseman with good pop in his bat for a little guy.


Position: 1B
All-Star selections: 3(1999,2001,04)
Hal’s take: The Mayor may have been the most popular player to the fans of any guy to wear a Reds uniform and was an accomplished singles and doubles hitter who was a human rain delay with all the antics he went through between pitches at the plate.


Position: RP
All-Star selections: 2 (2000, 04)
Hal’s take: The Baby Assassin was a standout closer who got by more on guts than stuff, although his stuff was unhittable when he was on, which was most of the time.6


Position: RP
All-Star selections: 4 (1986, 87, 89, 1990)
Hal’s take: Made more of a name for himself as a New York Met after he was with the Reds but was baseball’s best closer at both venues with a circle change-up that mesmerized hitters.


Position: 1B
All-Star selections: 4 (2010, 11, 12, 13)
Hal’s take: No man can get on base as often as he does via the walk and a near .300 batting average every year. He made himself into a solid defensive first baseman after signing as a catcher.


Position: RP
All-Star selections: 2 (1990, 91)
Hal’s take: The most famous of The Nasty Boys (Norm Charlton, Randy Myers, Dibble) because of his 100 mph fastball and his volatile temperament.


Position: RP
All-Star selections: 1 (1992)
Hal’s take: The Professor, a three-major student at Rice University, did it all for the Reds — start, middle relief, set-up and closing — and did them all at a high level.


Position: 2B
All-Star selections: 3 (2010, 11,13)
Hal’s take: The best defensive second baseman I’ve seen, a master at incredibly flashy plays and a guy who can bat effectively anywhere in the order.


Position: SP
All-Starselections: 12 (1967,68,69, 1970,71,72,73,75,76,77,78,81)
Hal’s take: Known most notably as a New York Met but made the All-Star team three of the four years he was with the Reds and was nearly as good with the Reds in his later years as he was with the Mets in his early years.


Position: 3B
All-Star selections: 7 (2002, 03, 04, 05, 06, 2010, 11)
Hal’s take: The best defensive third basemen I ever saw. Although he didn’t hit as well as he had with the Cardinals and Phillies, his glove never abandoned him and he made the All-Star team twice during his short tenure with the Reds.


Position: RP
All-Starselections: 3 (2012, 13, 14)
Hal’s take: His career is short but his legacy is implanted via his 100- to 105-mph fastball. He’s on pace to becoming baseball’s best closer, if he isn’t already.


Position: RP
All-Star selections: 2 (1971, 72)
Hal’s take: The Hawk was an early-day closer, just when closers became in vogue and was reliable in pitching more than one inning to get his saves.


Position: OF
All-Star selections: 2 (2011, 12)
Hal’s take: A two-time All-Star who plays both side of the ball with his powerful arm and defensive dexterity, plus displays power and streaks when he carries the Reds.

Contact Hal at

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Sports

Antetokounmpo on Mavericks roster as season gets underway
Antetokounmpo on Mavericks roster as season gets underway

Former Dayton Flyers forward Kostas Antetokounmpo, the last player taken in the NBA Draft in June, starts the NBA season on the roster of the Dallas Mavericks, though he’s expected to soon report to the franchise’s G League affiliate, the Texas Legends. The Mavericks play at the Phoenix Suns at 10:30 p.m. Wednesday. The Legends begin...
Wright State men’s basketball picked to win Horizon League
Wright State men’s basketball picked to win Horizon League

The Wright State University Raiders are the team to beat in the Horizon League. The Raiders were picked to finish first in the league’s preseason poll released today. Defending regular-season champion Northern Kentucky was selected No. 2, followed by UIC, Oakland, Green Bay, IUPUI, Cleveland State, Milwaukee, Youngstown State and Detroit Mercy...
For Ohio State Buckeyes, it’s ‘next man up’ after loss of Nick Bosa
For Ohio State Buckeyes, it’s ‘next man up’ after loss of Nick Bosa

Joey Bosa’s college career ended three quarters earlier than expected when he was ejected for targeting in the first quarter of the Fiesta Bowl in 2016. His brother Nick’s college career came to a sudden end, too, when Ohio State announced Tuesday he would withdraw from the university to focus on rehabbing a core muscle injury...
Ohio State football: New week, similar questions surround Buckeyes
Ohio State football: New week, similar questions surround Buckeyes

Urban Meyer was a good sport. Meyer took questions about his undefeated football team, more negative than positive, for the usual 15 minutes or so Monday. He pushed back at times, but lightly at most. The Ohio State coach did not look like someone under attack. Just maybe feeling deja vu. The questions he was hearing from reporters had already been...
High School Football: With two weeks remaining, conference title races heating up
High School Football: With two weeks remaining, conference title races heating up

With two weeks remaining in the regular season, several conference title races across the area are still very much up in the air. Here’s a look at how the conference races are shaping up across Clark and Champaign counties heading into Week 9: GWOC National East: Springfield’s two most important games of the season will come with both the...
More Stories