Bengals Report Card: Grading Sunday’s 51-14 loss to the Saints

The Cincinnati Bengals were missing their best player on offense Sunday, and the defense just didn’t show up at all.

The result was one of the worst losses in franchise history, as the Bengals fell 51-14 to the New Orleans Saints.

»RELATED: Bengals reportedly fire defensive coordinator

»RELATED: 5 takeaways from Bengals’ blowout loss

»ARCHDEACON: Bengals are a team going in reverse

Seven-time Pro Bowl wide receiver A.J. Green was sidelined with a toe injury, and the offense wasn’t the same without its go-to playmaker, and the defense continued its catastrophic struggles. Cincinnati gave up 509 yards — the first time a team has allowed 500 yards in three straight games — as the Saints scored on every drive except the final one when they kneeled out the clock.

Below is how we graded the performance in our Week 10 Report Card:


The Good: Joe Mixon carried the ball four times for 35 yards on the Bengals’ first drive, and they never got to a third down, as they moved 75 yards on eight plays to tie the game at 7-7. Giovani Bernard returned from a knee injury that sidelined him four games. Jeff Driskel ran for a 27-yard touchdown on fourth-and-1 in the fourth quarter.

The Bad: Mixon only had seven more carries after the first drive and finished with 61 yards. Bernard added just six yards on two carries.

Key Play: The Bengals were about to run on fourth-and-1 from the Saints’ 40-yard line when tight end Matt Lengel was called for a false start. Cincinnati ended up punting and New Orleans drove down for a third score to make it 21-7.

Grade: D


The Good: Dalton was 3-for-3 for 32 yards on the first drive, including a nice 23-yard catch by Tyler Boyd and 2-yard touchdown to John Ross. Boyd averaged 21.7 yards per catch.

The Bad: Dalton was sacked four times, threw two interceptions and completed 12 of just 20 pass attempts for 153 yards. The Bengals converted no third downs.

Key Play: Dalton’s pass intended for John Ross as halftime approached was intercepted at the 17-yard line, and Marcus Williams ran it back 78 yards to set up a last-second score to make it 35-7 at halftime.

Grade: F


The Good: The Bengals put the Saints in third-and-long situations twice in the fourth quarter and ended up limiting them to field goals both times.

The Bad: The Saints rushed 47 times for 244 yards and three touchdowns, including 104 yards from Mark Ingram and 56 yards and two touchdowns by Alvin Kamara.

Key Play: After Kevin Huber pinned the Saints inside their own 10-yard line in the second quarter, Kamara immediately got New Orleans going with a 14-yard run on first down, and the Saints drove down the field to make it 21-7.

Grade: F


The Good: Cincinnati limited the Saints to field goals on three drives in the second half, as New Orleans converted just 1 of 6 third downs after going 6-for-6 in those situations the first half.

The Bad: The Bengals didn’t have any sacks or interceptions, and Drew Brees completed 22 of 25 passes for 265 yards and three touchdowns. Michael Thomas caught all eight of the passes thrown his way and finished with 70 yards and two touchdowns.

Key Play: Ingram took a short pass 28 yards for a touchdown early in the second quarter, utilizing a big block on Jordan Evans and then spinning around two defensive backs, as Shawn Williams and Jessie Bates both whiffed, to get into the end zone. That made it 14-7 and encapsulated how the defense has played much of this season.

Grade: F


The Good: Cincinnati never began a drive inside the 23-yard line, so field position wasn’t an issue. Kevin Huber had one punt to the 10. Alex Erickson had a long return of 32 yards. There were no penalties on teams.

The Bad: New Orleans never punted. The Bengals didn’t have any huge plays on teams to help spark the offense or defense.

Key Play: After the Bengals were penalized for a false start one fourth-and-1, Huber’s punt set New Orleans at the 10-yard line but the Saints got a big run on first down and ended up driving down for a touchdown.

Grade: C


The Good: Bill Lazor seemed to have a good plan in place the first drive to overcome not having Green, using a good mix of runs and passes, but the Bengals appeared to get away from that as the game went along.

The Bad: Lewis wasted a challenge on the opening drive and lost a timeout. The defense has never been so bad and there doesn’t seem to be a solution beyond the reported firing of coordinator Teryl Austin . Mixon was completely underutilized, and Lewis could only attribute that to the game dynamics changing but he had just one carry in the second and third quarters combined.

Key Play: No one play stands out, but it’s especially disappointing that the Bengals had an extra week to prepare and didn’t seem ready at all. Perhaps they should have gone for it on fourth-and-6 from the Saints’ 45-yard line instead of punting. Cincinnati completely fell out of it after that.

Grade: F

Reader Comments

Next Up in Sports

Oklahoma quarterback Kyler Murray wins Heisman Trophy
Oklahoma quarterback Kyler Murray wins Heisman Trophy

Kyler Murray has won the Heisman Trophy, becoming the University of Oklahoma's seventh Heisman winner, beating fellow finalists Tua Tagovailoa of Alabama and Dwayne Haskins of Ohio State on Saturday. Murray gives the Sooners back-to-back years with Heisman Trophy-winning quarterbacks (Baker Mayfield, 2017), something no school has done before...
Atlanta United wins MLS Cup, beats Portland 2-0
Atlanta United wins MLS Cup, beats Portland 2-0

The Kings of the South are the Kings of MLS. Behind goals from Josef Martinez and Franco Escobar, Atlanta United defeated Portland 2-0 to win the MLS Cup in front of record announced attendance of more than 73,000 on Saturday at Mercedes-Benz Stadium in Atlanta. No one, from owner Arthur Blank to the players, were shy in the...
HS Scores 12/8: Conley, Thomas go over 50-point mark in wins

Two area basketball players had record-setting nights on Saturday. Ethan Conley sounded off with 54 points for Franklin Monroe in a 92-80 victory versus Houston in boys basketball and Corinne Thomas exploded for 51 points in Tecumseh’s 104-42 win versus London in girls basketball. Both Conley and Thomas set the single-game scoring record for...
Turnovers doom Dayton in 10-point loss at Auburn
Turnovers doom Dayton in 10-point loss at Auburn

The Dayton Flyers made a run at the No. 8 Auburn Tigers in the second half, cutting a 19-point deficit to six but lost 82-72 on Saturday at Auburn Arena. The Flyers (5-4) lost their fourth game to a team ranked in the top 50 of the Ken Pomeroy rankings. In each of the games against Virginia, Oklahoma, Mississippi State and Oklahoma, they  had...
Wright State lets second-half lead slip away in loss to Kent State
Wright State lets second-half lead slip away in loss to Kent State

Wright State put itself in position to end its losing skid with a strong second-half surge, but Kent State scored on its final 10 possessions to pull out an 83-76 home win Saturday. The Raiders took a 71-66 lead on two free throws by Mark Hughes with 4:24 to go, but the Golden Flashes, led by All-Mid-American Conference guard Jaylin Walker (25 points)...
More Stories