Attorney for Zach Smith: ‘Who is the check and balance on the press?’ in Ohio State/Urban Meyer coverage

Brad Koffel, the attorney representing former Ohio State assistant coach Zach Smith, used his weekly local radio show to blast the way the story has been covered, particularly the focus on head coach Urban Meyer.

“The past two weeks Columbus, the country, has personally witnessed reporters not report but draw inferences upon inferences and create narratives that are designed to grab eyeballs and clicks, not against corrupt public officials like the royal governor of New York that John Peter Zenger went to trial over but against football coaches. Football coaches!” Koffel said in the latest episode of his weekly show, “For the Defense,” which aired Sunday morning on 610 WTVN. 

>>RELATED: An updated timeline for the Ohio State investigation

The football coaches he referred to are Smith, who was fired July 23 after being charged with criminal trespassing and facing a domestic violence protection order, and Meyer, who has been placed on leave pending an investigation of how he handled 2015 allegations Smith abused his wife. 

(Zenger was the defendant in a historic libel case that helped establish the rights of a free press.) 

Koffel argued there is “nothing unique” about the Smiths’ divorce despite Courtney Smith accusing Zach of abusing her and Zach’s admission their marriage was “toxic” during an interview with ESPN on Friday night. 

Zach Smith said there were multiple occasions when things got physical while he was trying to extricate himself from an argument and denied ever abusing Courtney despite being “a bad husband” who “pushed her buttons.” 

>>READ MORE of what Smith said Friday night

Koffel did not touch on that, but he defended Meyer’s handling of queries into the Smith situation during his appearance at Big Ten Media Days in Chicago on July 24. 

Meyer has been heavily criticized for saying the 2015 incident was “nothing” and asking, “Who creates a report like that?” 

In Koffel’s view, “(Meyer) was asked a question predicated on, listen to me, false internet reports that were hours old, and he answered that question appropriately.” 

That was in reference to a Facebook post by Brett McMurphy, who reported he had a police report showing Zach Smith had been arrested for domestic violence and felonious assault against his then-wife in 2015. McMurphy later wrote that an updated report released by Powell, Ohio, police no longer showed Smith had been arrested. 

“What was being reported that happened in 2015 never happened. (Those reports) were false,” Koffel said, seemingly focusing on whether or not Smith was actually arrested rather than if there were an incident that was investigated by police. 

“(Meyer) didn’t lie to (the media) on Media Day,” Koffel said. "(The media) asked a poor question based upon false internet reports. Get your facts straight before you ask a question like that on the record. I have the facts. I have all the police reports. Yes. Nine. You know what they are? They’re traffic violations. Six of them. Another call about an elderly man, 65-year-old, followed the assistant coach’s wife back to her house. She got spooked. Another was a well-being check on the kids. The police showed up and everything was just fine. There are no reports. There are no arrests. OK?” 

Koffel also questioned responsibility being assigned to Meyer and OSU director of athletics Gene Smith when the matter was investigated by local law enforcement. 

“Mind you the investigating officers with jurisdiction over such matters and a state law that mandates arrests for domestic violence never arrested or charged said assistant coach, but the head coach and now the athletic director are supposed to do more than the police? Since when?” Koffel said. 

>>READ MORE: Meyer breaks silence

He went on to lament the public becoming “conditioned sheep who think heads have to roll because the media says so. This reminds me of those ancient tribes that sacrificed a virgin to please the gods. We are more sophisticated than that. To not let New York or Bristol, Connecticut, run unchecked and tell us how we should think and force institutions to bend to their will.” 

Ohio State announced Sunday night it hopes to have an investigation into Meyer’s handling of the domestic violence allegation finished within 14 days

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Sports

5 things to know about Ohio State’s blowout of Tulane
5 things to know about Ohio State’s blowout of Tulane

Ohio State rolled Tulane 49-6 on Saturday to end a rocky couple of months for the program.  So maybe it was only natural the state’s official rock song would be what brought Urban Meyer back to normal coaching the fourth-ranked Buckeyes.  “Between the third and fourth quarter, hearing the band play, ‘Hang on Sloopy.&rsquo...
Wayne grad Smith debuts for Buckeyes against Tulane
Wayne grad Smith debuts for Buckeyes against Tulane

The latest Wayne High School graduate to play for the Ohio State Buckeyes took the field for the first time Saturday at Ohio Stadium. Freshman wide receiver L’Christian “Blue” Smith made his college debut late in the fourth quarter of a 49-6 victory against Tulane. He did not catch a pass in his first game. Smith can play in...
Here’s how Ohio State fans reacted to coach Urban Meyer’s return to the Buckeyes
Here’s how Ohio State fans reacted to coach Urban Meyer’s return to the Buckeyes

Fans of the Ohio State Buckeyes welcomed coach Urban Meyer back with open arms Saturday as he returned to the sideline following a three-game suspension. At the first glimpse of Meyer before he walked to the Skull Session with the team, fans started cheering. Before he could speak to the crowd at St. John Arena, fans drowned him out with applause....
Haskins, Campbell star as Ohio State Buckeyes cruise by Tulane
Haskins, Campbell star as Ohio State Buckeyes cruise by Tulane

Back home for a final tuneup before the Big Ten schedule resumes, Ohio State had no trouble with Tulane on Saturday. The fourth-ranked Buckeyes (4-0, 1-0) scored touchdowns on their first six possession en route to a 49-6 victory over the Green Wave (1-3). A crowd of 103,336 showed up for head coach Urban Meyer’s first game back on the sideline...
Springfield, Miamisburg last two unbeaten GWOC football teams
Springfield, Miamisburg last two unbeaten GWOC football teams

Springfield and Miamisburg are the only two remaining unbeaten high school football teams in the 20-member Greater Western Ohio Conference. Both are 5-0 after Week 5 wins on Friday. The teams are not scheduled to play in the regular season, but could be paired in the playoffs. Springfield improved to No. 2 in the Division I, Region 3 computer rankings...
More Stories