breaking news

Navistar CEO tells investors truck maker’s rebound is complete

‘The courthouse is the next step…’: Mining dispute between Clark Co. and Enon company continues


Clark County commissioners rejected a proposed settlement with a local mining company Wednesday after close to 100 Mad River Twp. residents packed into a county hearing room to oppose the deal.

Enon Sand and Gravel filed a federal lawsuit against the county last year, seeking to bypass the Clark County Board of Zoning Appeals and protect its right to surface mining on the property, according to court records. It also sought damages in excess of $25,000.

DETAILS: Enon Sand sues Clark County after state issues mining permit

The county had reached a tentative agreement with the company after a mediation process, Clark County Commissioner Richard Lohnes said. But the commissioners voted two to one against the agreement, in part because of the resident turnout to oppose the settlement. The Mad River Twp. residents have long raised concerns about how work proposed by the company would impact neighboring property values, water wells, traffic and more. Opponents said Wednesday there are about 200 homes adjacent to the property and more that are close to the mining operation.

MORE: Clark County: Permit needed to approve proposed gravel pit

“We have not had one email or phone call in support of doing this,” Lohnes said of why he voted against the settlement.

The commissioners said turning down the deal meant risking a court fight in which the county may not prevail. Lohnes said it’s also possible the company would be willing to renegotiate or take a second look at the settlement once residents had more time to review the proposal.

But Dennis Garrison, president of Enon Sand and Gravel, said a court date in January is now likely.

RELATED: Enon limestone mining proposal opponents worried about water

“The courthouse is the next step because they voted against the agreement today,” Garrison said.

The mining company applied to the Ohio Department of Natural Resources in November 2016 to mine limestone and merge two existing permits into one. The business wants to mine about 60 feet deeper on parts of its nearly 400-acre property near Hustead and South Tecumseh roads and Rebert Pike.

After discussions with their attorneys, the commissioners said they have no authority to prevent the firm from mining on several parcels of property on which the company has conducting mining operations in the past. The settlement agreement would have required Enon Sand and Gravel to seek approval from the county’s Board of Zoning Appeals before it could proceed with any operations on additional parcels to the north and south where mining had not occurred in the past.

MORE BUSINESS NEWS: Proposed changes to mining permit concerns Clark County residents

Rejecting the settlement means there’s no guarantee residents will have a say in whether the company conducts operations on the additional parcels to the north and south, said Melanie Flax Wilt, the lone commissioner who voted in favor of the agreement.

“We’re trying to do what’s best for the community to protect you and get the best resolution that we can,” said Commissioner Lowell McGlothin, who also voted against the settlement.

Kyle Peterson, a Mad River Twp. resident who’s long been opposed to the quarry, said he remains confident the company would consider renegotiating its proposed settlement with the county and said both sides are taking a risk by taking the case to the courts early next year.

He said residents who have opposed the company’s project for more than a year only learned about the proposed settlement about a day ago. Peterson said he’s glad the commissioners put the brakes on the deal for now.

“They put on a poker face, but they don’t want to go to court as much as we don’t want to go to court,” Peterson said of Enon Sand and Gravel.

He said residents living near the mining operation are concerned the proposed work will harm an aquifer they rely on for well water, and could force many residents to pay thousands for new wells. There are also concerns the water could become contaminated and the project will be a nuisance by creating additional noise.

“The loss of well water is the biggest concern,” Peterson said.

Garrison said Wednesday he’s aware of the concerns neighbors have raised, but said there are safeguards in place to mediate those concerns. He also argued state officials have addressed concerns from neighboring properties through the permitting process. He said the company was prepared to move forward with the settlement Wednesday.

“We as a company went through the mediation process and we thought we had a deal with the county,” Garrison said.

Joe Catanzaro, a Mad River Twp. trustee, said residents clearly made a case they weren’t interested in agreeing to the proposal Wednesday. He said he’s glad the commissioners took residents seriously.

“I think a better outcome will come from this situation,” Catanzaro said.



Reader Comments


Next Up in Community News

'Bear, go away:' Video doorbell shows bear on Florida doorstep
'Bear, go away:' Video doorbell shows bear on Florida doorstep

A bear was seen on camera knocking over Christmas decorations on a family’s doorstep. WTSP reported that a video doorbell captured the bear’s visit in Naples, Florida. The video was shared to the Ring Neighbors App by the homeowner. Video began recording automatically when the bear stepped onto the property, according to WFOR. >...
Children’s Place recalls infant girls snowsuits
Children’s Place recalls infant girls snowsuits

The Children’s Place and the Consumer Product Safety Commission have announced a recall of infant snowsuits due to a choking hazard. According to the recall alert, the metal snaps on the snowsuit can come off and can pose a choking hazard to young children.  About 14,900 snowsuits are covered by the recall in the United States. Another...
2 women arrested on prostitution-related charges at Miami Twp. massage parlor
2 women arrested on prostitution-related charges at Miami Twp. massage parlor

Two women were arrested on prostitution-related charges at a Miami Twp. massage parlor, according to jail records.  Deputies arrested Jinhuang Ging Liu, 45, and Li Wang Corona, 43, at Healthy Massage, at 2179 Miamisburg Centerville Road, online records show.  It was not immediately known if the charges Liu and Corona were arrested for were...
These 16 people were indicted in Clark County, Ohio
These 16 people were indicted in Clark County, Ohio

These cases were indicted in Clark County Common Pleas Court in December. Haley Thomas, 23, of Springfield: aggravated possession of drugs Cassandra Robidoux, 31: two counts of receiving stolen property and forgery Jaylin Cameron, 20: carrying concealed weapon and improper handling of firearms Christopher Fenner, 45: domestic violence and abduction...
President Trump signs order giving federal employees Christmas Eve off
President Trump signs order giving federal employees Christmas Eve off

Despite a looming potential government shutdown, President Donald Trump has signed an order giving all federal employees Christmas Eve off.  Trump issued the order Tuesday that stated “all executive departments and agencies of the federal government shall be closed” on Monday. The order continued the trend of giving federal employees...
More Stories