Supreme Court rejects Navistar’s appeal in $27M tax case


The Ohio Supreme Court sided with the state in a legal fight with Navistar over how tax credits are applied to manufacturers throughout Ohio.

The truck maker had appealed a previous decision by the state tax commissioner and the Board of Tax Appeals that Navistar was ineligible to receive about $27 million in commercial activity tax credits.

The justices ruled 5 to 2, affirming a decision by the Board of Tax Appeals.

The ruling was relatively narrow based on Navistar’s specific situation, said Matt Chafin, chief legal counsel for the Ohio Department of Taxation.

DETAILS: Navistar reports $37M profit after stronger truck sales

Still, he said it helps clarify the rules if a similar case arises in the future.

“Any time we get any direction from the courts it’s always helpful in doing our job in the future,” Chafin said.

MORE: Volkswagen execs indicate possible takeover of Navistar

Navistar officials said they believe the company was entitled to the credit, but the case had no impact on day-to-day operations.

“It’s a one-time deal” said Lyndi McMillan, a spokeswoman for Navistar. “It was something we went after but we acted as though that money was not there.”

READ MORE: Navistar, local leaders push others to buy trucks made in Springfield

The dispute focused on whether the Springfield manufacturer should be allowed to use tax credits created when the state implemented the Commercial Activity Tax in 2005.

Navistar sought to spread about $27 million in net operating losses over future tax years through a credit allowed when the CAT Tax was implemented. But the company later revised financial statements from 2004 after seeking the credit, and the state tax commissioner used that updated information to reject the credit.

MORE BUSINESS NEWS: Could driverless tech mean thousands of Ohio trucking jobs lost?

Attorneys for Navistar had argued the tax commissioner exceeded his authority in denying the credit, in part because he based his decision on financial statements that did not exist at that deadline.

This was the second time the Ohio Supreme Court considered Navistar’s objection to being denied the credits. In 2015, the court ruled that the Board of Tax Appeals did not fully consider expert testimony provided by Navistar’s witnesses, and the court sent the case back to the board for further review.

However, Navistar appealed again when the board ruledNavistar wasn’t entitled to the credits for a second time.

MORE AUTOMOTIVE NEWS: Ohio to play key role in driverless cars, transportation research

This time, the court decided the tax board did explain why Navistar didn’t qualify for the tax credit, and the justices affirmed the tax board’s original decision.

Navistar is one of Clark County’s largest employers with roughly 1,800 people employed at its Springfield plant. The company manufactures commercial trucks, buses military vehicles and other products at facilities in Springfield, Tulsa, Okla. and Escobedo, Mexico.

The truck maker reported a net loss of $73 million for the first quarter this year, including $46 million in charges as a result of debt refinancing in November last year. Navistar reported a net loss of $62 million for the same quarter last year.

However, the company raised its revenue projections for this year, in part due to strong results in the company’s truck segment.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Community News

Ex-Disney World dancer claims she was fired over pregnancy in lawsuit
Ex-Disney World dancer claims she was fired over pregnancy in lawsuit

A former aerial dancer at Walt Disney World has sued the resort alleging gender discrimination, saying she was fired after she became pregnant with twins and went on an 11-month leave. Krista Crowder filed the lawsuit in state court in Orlando, Florida, last week. It doesn't specify how much money she seeks. In the lawsuit, Crowder said she...
Air Quality Alert for some today; storms and humidity to end week
Air Quality Alert for some today; storms and humidity to end week

Butler and Warren counties are under a Air Quality Alert from 6 a.m. until 9 p.m. today.  Nice again today with highs in mid-80s Clouds roll in and humidity rises tonight Thunderstorms over weekend, possibly severe Friday Today: Mostly sunny skies are expected with some increase in clouds late in the day and evening...
Husband, wife accused of raping children, committing sex crimes over 10-year span
Husband, wife accused of raping children, committing sex crimes over 10-year span

A west Tennessee husband and wife are accused of committing sex crimes against children over a 10-year span. John and Dava Henley are charged with two counts of rape and four counts of aggravated sexual battery.  John Henley is also charged with aggravated rape of a child and rape of a child, according to the indictments. Investigators...
Fort Hunter Liggett tent collapse: 22 injured at California military base, officials say
Fort Hunter Liggett tent collapse: 22 injured at California military base, officials say

More than 20 people were injured late Wednesday when a tent collapsed at Fort Hunter Liggett in California, officials said. Update 2:26 a.m. EDT July 19: According to the military base’s official Twitter account, 22 soldiers were hurt when “a U.S. Army UH-60 Blackhawk helicopter landing’s rotor wash blew over a tent structure&rdquo...
1 hospitalized after mobile home fire in Clark County
1 hospitalized after mobile home fire in Clark County

UPDATE @ 3:15 a.m: One person was transported to an area hospital after a fire occurred at a mobile home in South Vienna early Thursday morning. Fire crews responded to the 10000 block of Buena Vista Road just after 2 a.m. on a fully involved trailer fire, according to initial reports. Damage estimates were not immediately available, however,...
More Stories