Housing, credit crisis hurt home remodeling

The number of permits issued for residential remodeling, alteration or addition projects declined last year in a variety of cities and counties across the region, according to data and building records obtained by the Springfield News-Sun. Some home-improvement businesses have also seen their earnings fall.

Industry experts said the declines are likely attributable to persistently high unemployment, tight family budgets, stricter underwriting requirements for bank loans, shrinking home equity and the weak housing market.

“Housing values have dropped pretty dramatically, so you have to question the value of putting a fair amount of money into your home if it’s not going to be reflected in a higher value or a higher sale price,” said Vincent Squillace, executive vice president of the Ohio Home Builders Association. “The economics just don’t work in favor of remodeling like it once did.”

Residential building permits or permits issued for remodeling, alteration and addition projects fell last year in Butler, Champaign, Miami, Montgomery and Warren counties. They also fell in Springfield, Beavercreek, Moraine, Riverside and Vandalia.

Tina Koumoutsos, executive director of Neighborhood Housing Partnership of Greater Springfield, said the drop in permits indicate many area residents are in “limbo” due to the poor economy.

“People are just hesitant to take on additional debt. We do see signs of a slight recovery, but there are still a lot of unknowns,” Koumoutsos said.

In all seven counties in the region, home-improvement permits are down compared to before the housing market crashed. But in some counties, the numbers have rebounded compared to the height of the housing slump.

Dayton and Huber Heights, however, reported that residential improvement permits are up, and the number of permits issued by cities have bounced around in the last seven years.

Clark County saw permits for residential alterations increase from 246 in 2010 to 270 in 2011 — or 9.7 percent.

Koumoutsos said the downturn in housing values can work both ways: some homeowners have decided not to invest in their homes, while others cannot sell their homes and have opted to remodel.

“Some people are choosing to stay where they are and make some improvements rather than getting into a much higher mortgage. Some can’t sell their homes because they’re underwater,” Koumoutsos said.

But when analyzing the slight decline in residential alterations numbers in Springfield, a local building official said residents have benefited from job growth in the area.

“Springfield has been fortunate that our numbers have not dropped as dramatically as other communities. It’s hard to say why one community does one thing and another does something else, but Springfield’s economy, to me, seems to a little better and people are more willing to get things done to their homes,” Dick Eichelberger, certified building official for the city of Springfield.

Greene County saw permits for residential alterations more than double last year to 286 from 141 in 2010, but had declined steeply, from 256 in 2009 and 340 in 2008.

Declining home values mean consumers are having more difficulty acquiring home equity loans because they often owe more on their properties than they are worth, Squillace said.

Family budgets, he said, are stretched thin, meaning that many home-improvement projects today are performed out of necessity instead of lifestyle changes, such as wanting a den or a new master bedroom.

“The remodelers have seen the slowdown just as the builders have,” he said.

Widespread foreclosure activity, bankruptcies and credit card debt means consumers have lower credit ratings and banks have adopted higher underwriting requirements, said Peter Price, president of the Miami Valley Chapter of the National Association of the Remodeling Industry.

This makes it difficult to secure financing for major improvement projects.

Consumers are also deferring major financial decisions, such as sinking money into their homes, until there is less economic uncertainty, Price said.

He said “big-ticket” remodeling projects today are typically along the lines of furnace replacements. Like Squillace, he said much fewer people are adding rooms and making major changes to their living spaces.

Some consumers are buying new electronics and appliances to improve their living conditions. Others are performing more basic work that does not require permits, but the economy has also impacted sales at home-improvement retailers.

Lowe’s watched earnings fall 44 percent in the third quarter, and the company announced plans to close a number of under-performing stores. Home Depot, however, saw profits rise 12 percent in the third quarter of 2011. Analysts noted the company benefitted from Hurricane Irene preparation and cleanup.

Spending on remodeling is expected to dip in the next two quarters of 2012, according to projections reported by the National Association of the Remodeling Industry. The association cited estimates by the Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University’s Leading Indicator of Remodeling Activity.

“Absent a more sustained upturn in the broader housing market, particularly in the sales of existing homes, there’s not much to propel growth in home improvement spending,” Kermit Baker, director of the Remodeling Futures Program at the Joint Center, said in a release on the association’s website. “Homeowners are continuing to undertake smaller jobs but are still nervous about larger discretionary projects

Consumers no longer view remodeling or adding onto their homes as great investments, like they did when property values were appreciating,” Price said.

He said some consumers are not spending money on their homes because they have no intention to put them on the market and try to upgrade to better ones.

Still, Price said the real value of home improvement projects is the benefit it adds to the owners’ quality of life. Additionally, low interest rates make it a good time to borrow money for improvements if consumers can afford the loans.

Ceir Coral, 43, of Beavercreek, said he decided to spend about $20,000 to convert his patio into an outdoor living space and remodel his basement because putting his home up for sale was not an option.

When the housing market sank, Coral said he was upside-down on his mortgage by about $50,000. He said he decided it does not make sense to sell his home for a loss, so he is staying put and improving it.

“If moving is not in the cards, then you have just got to put some money into your home and make it your own and improve your quality of life,” he said.

Staff Writer Tiffany Y. Latta contributed to this report.

Thank you for reading the Springfield News-Sun and for supporting local journalism. Subscribers: log in for access to your daily ePaper and premium newsletters.

Thank you for supporting in-depth local journalism with your subscription to the Springfield News-Sun. Get more news when you want it with email newsletters just for subscribers. Sign up here.