Champaign County wind farm challenges residents’ right to fight project

Developers of a proposed wind farm in Champaign County have challenged the ability of a group of local residents to intervene in its legal case, arguing they live outside the project’s footprint and wouldn’t be affected by the wind turbines.

The wind farm, which initially included plans to build about 100 turbines across six townships, has been tangled in legal disputes that have lasted about a decade.

RELATED: Developer of Champaign County wind farm likely for sale

Everpower Wind Holdings, the project’s developer, finally reached an agreement last year with members of Union Neighbors United, a group of residents who opposed the project. That deal slashed the total number of turbines proposed to about 50, with only one turbine to be built in Union Twp. In return, members of UNU agreed not to object to the smaller, revised project.

Now, a new group of residents opposes the revised project. Everpower says in a memo filed with the Ohio Power Siting Board that some of those residents should be excluded because they don’t own property in the project area, rather they live between 1.5 to 2.9 miles away.

DETAILS: Wind farms stall, solar grows as energy debate continues in Ohio

“It is not enough for a person seeking to intervene in a proceeding such as this to merely state that he or she resides in a county wherein the project under consideration is proposed to be sited,” Everpower’s filing states.

John Stock, an attorney representing the residents, filed a response this week countering that the residents established homes in the area long before the project was proposed. And even if they’re not directly within the project’s footprint, the filing says they will still be affected by the turbines.

READ MORE: Court sides with Champaign County wind developers in permit fight

“While they may not reside as close to EverPower’s wind turbines as members of the admitted group, nonetheless they will be subjected to continual, disruptive noise from the turbines — noise to which they previously have not been subjected,” the response says. “Furthermore, their beautiful rural viewscapes and property values will be diminished.”

The opponents also raised several other concerns about the project, including arguing state law passed since the project was first approved requires that each turbine be set back at least 1,125 feet from property lines not included in the project. Instead, they argue the project uses setback requirements of 541 feet from adjacent property lines, which was the requirement when the state first approved the project.

They argue that by amending the initial two phases of the project, the wind farm is subject to the tougher setbacks.

MORE: Everpower signs deal with Amazon for Ohio wind farm

Everpower, however, said their arguments should be limited to a single issue of which model of turbine is used for the project. The developer argued the setback issues have been decided and are outside the scope of the most recent applications.

“… a desire to re-litigate legal issues that the (Ohio Power Siting Board) has already decided in favor of other applicants in the past is not a sufficient interest that allows for intervention on those issues in this proceeding,” attorneys for Everpower say in their filing.

But Stock argued it’s clear the tougher setback requirements should apply to the project.

“UNU asserted in its Ohio Supreme Court case against Everpower that the setback requirements … apply to the project as a result of amendments made to Everpower’s certificates after the effective date of those statutory requirements,” Stock says in his reply to the siting board. “And Everpower apparently settled that case by amending the project to remove all but one turbine from Union Township in Champaign County — removing more than 50 turbines from the project.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Community News

Mike DeWine ice cream social brings out nearly all of GOP slate
Mike DeWine ice cream social brings out nearly all of GOP slate

Hundreds of Republican supporters spent an afternoon Sunday listening to optimistic speeches at the annual Ice Cream Social that Ohio Attorney General Mike Dewine and his wife Fran hosted at their home near Cedarville. DeWine’s event brought nearly all the Ohio GOP statewide candidates; Senate candidate U.S. Rep. Jim Renacci, R-Wadsworth, did...
Suspect accused in mentally disabled woman's assault was once police chief
Suspect accused in mentally disabled woman's assault was once police chief

Roughly 20 years before Robert Lanier New became embroiled in assault allegations tied to a mentally disabled woman and her niece, he served as the police chief in Emerson.  City officials confirmed to WSB-TV that New had two stints with Emerson police. New first served with the department from September 1998 to February 1999, when he left...
Dwyane Wade says he wants to bring Sonics back to Seattle
Dwyane Wade says he wants to bring Sonics back to Seattle

Future basketball hall of famer Dwyane Wade may still have a couple seasons left in his tank, but he’s also already thinking about what will come next for him when his playing career ends.  "Seattle. I want Seattle's team, the Sonics, to come back," Wade told Joel Weber, of Bloomberg, regarding his hope to one day be part...
Air Show ends with crowds, perfect weather
Air Show ends with crowds, perfect weather

The featured performances at the Vectren Dayton Air Show may draw the crowds, but the static aircraft displays this year were a huge part of the experience. Sunday’s air show had more than 50 aircraft in one of the largest static displays in several years. About 30 of those were military aircraft, estimated Roger Doctor, public safety director...
Vehicle accident on I-70 east at U.S. 68 cleared; Traffic moving slow
Vehicle accident on I-70 east at U.S. 68 cleared; Traffic moving slow

According to the Ohio Department of Transportation cameras, I-70 at St. Rt. 4 showed traffic to be backed up and I-70 at U.S. 68 showed police cruisers and ambulances on scene.  When our crew arrived on scene, it seemed to be a vehicle accident with possibly only minor damage. All lanes are open, but traffic is moving slowly.  We are working...
More Stories