Suspect arrested after mayo dispute at Atlanta Subway leaves worker dead

A worker was shot to death in an Atlanta sub shop following a dispute with a customer about how much mayonnaise was on a Subway sandwich. AJC

Combined ShapeCaption
A worker was shot to death in an Atlanta sub shop following a dispute with a customer about how much mayonnaise was on a Subway sandwich. AJC

First an argument, then gunfire, and two young women lay wounded Sunday evening inside a downtown Atlanta sub shop.

One of those women, a 26-year-old, was later pronounced dead. They were coworkers at a Subway connected to a Circle K on Northside Drive, two blocks south of Mercedes-Benz Stadium. A customer became enraged over the amount of mayonnaise on a sandwich and pulled out a gun, according to Atlanta police, our news partners at AJC.com reported.

The other woman, a 24-year-old, was shot in front of her 5-year-old child and is in critical condition at a hospital. The shooting, which was reported shortly after 6:30 p.m., brought a host of Atlanta police officials to the scene Sunday night, including interim police Chief Darin Schierbaum.

“What you are seeing behind me is the result of a tragedy,” Schierbaum told reporters from outside the Subway. “A senseless tragedy that we’ve seen numerous times throughout the year where an argument leads to gunfire, and now we have someone dead.”

Within a few hours, a crucial tip helped investigators identify a 36-year-old Atlanta man as a suspect, and he was arrested late Sunday not far from the restaurant, according to police. Deputy police Chief Charles Hampton declined to release his name Monday, citing the ongoing investigation.

The names of the two victims were also being withheld. Willie Glenn, who co-owns the Subway location, told Channel 2 Action News both women started working there earlier this month and were considered “model employees.”

“It breaks my heart to know that someone has the audacity to point a weapon and shoot someone for as little as too much mayonnaise on a sandwich,” Glenn said.

A frustrated Schierbaum said Sunday that arguments are the leading cause of the homicides his department has investigated in 2022. Atlanta has seen 82 homicides in 2022; the number at this time last year was 70. Authorities investigated 160 homicides in 2021, up from 157 in 2020. The agency previously had reported it worked 158 cases last year and updated the total after a review of department data. Last year’s homicide total was the highest since 1996.

Just this year, arguments at Atlanta restaurants and bars have led to deadly gunfire at least a half-dozen times, and most of those victims have been young adults. Those scenes have included strip clubs, sports bars, fast-food restaurants and a southwest Atlanta bowling alley, where police believe 31-year-old mother LaKevia Jackson was killed in the parking lot after arguing with a stranger in the next lane over a bowling ball.

“We need individuals to talk out their disputes, walk away and do not pick up guns,” Schierbaum said Sunday. “We can take down drug operations that breed violent crime, we can dismantle gang organizations that breed violent crime, we can stop robbery crews that breed violent crime. We cannot stop someone who is mad because there is too much mayonnaise on their sandwich.”