What should the NCAA do about its transfer rules?

NCAA transfer rules are going to change. 

Exactly how and how much is still being determined. 

That was announced this week by the Division I Transfer Working Group, which met Monday and Tuesday in Indianapolis and now is seeking feedback on the types of changes that could be implemented. 

RELATED: Assessing Ohio State’s Big Ten title chances as Reds head to spring training

Two things are certain: The graduate-transfer rule is not going away, and some restrictions will remain in place. 

The group also identified two potential changes (via press release): 

— Allow students who meet specific, high-achieving academic benchmarks to play immediately after the first time they transfer during their college experience.

— Allow prospective student-athletes who have signed a National Letter of Intent to transfer and play immediately if a head coach leaves the school of the student’s choice, as well as under other exceptions already in the rulebook.

With the popularity of college sports in southwest Ohio, this obviously has the potential to be a hot-button issue. 

Dayton and Wright State men’s basketball both have “traditional” transfers playing important roles this season — Josh Cunningham for the Flyers and Cole Gentry for the Raiders.

So do both women’s teams. Fairmont grad Chelsea Welch leads the Raiders in scoring for the second straight season after transferring from Pitt, and Alex Harris is a starter for UD after starting her career at Penn State. 

All had to sit out a season after arriving on campus.

Archdeacon: Wright State’s Cole Gentry — ‘I decided to bet on myself’

WSU also lost a graduate transfer last summer when Mark Alstork opted to play his final season of eligibility at Illinois. 

Another Dayton native, Jaaron Simmons of Alter High School, is at Michigan this season after graduating from Ohio University, where he was a star for two years. 

(Both of them also transferred earlier in their careers, for what it’s worth.) 

Ohio State’s resurgence? A key reserve for the Buckeyes is Andrew Dakich, a graduate transfer from Michigan. 

Transfers are also of course a big deal in college football, where the frequency of players transferring out has increased at Ohio State as Urban Meyer has elevated the recruiting from top 10 to top two over the past six years. 

I happen to think some constraint on transfers should remain in place. 

The NCAA says transfers tend to have worse academic outcomes (obviously this is not the case for those who have already graduated before moving to a new school)), and too much player movement could hurt fan interest. 

Players should be allowed to do what is necessary to improve their situations. However, some incentive to encourage them to work it out where they are probably isn’t a bad thing. 

Obviously player welfare is the No. 1 priority, but fan interest is important because that’s the main source of all that expanding revenue that makes college athletics possible. 

Additionally, I’ve heard countless stories of players who were unhappy and wanted to transfer early in their careers before ultimately becoming success stories at their original school. That’s only natural given the stakes and the emotional time in students’ lives. Often cooler heads prevail, though not always of course. 

RELATED: Welch earns another Horizon League honor

Allowing immediate eligibility for players who want to transfer after their coach leaves or is fired (whether they are recruits or in school) is a no-brainer. 

Perhaps that could also bring some sanity to the coaching market, encouraging colleges to be more patient with coaches who aren’t immediate hits. More coaching stability would also be good for student-athletes who are happy where they are until the administrator screws it up by firing the coach. 

I’m not so sure about one-time Academic Transfer Get Out of Jail Free Card. 

Maintaining good grades is sort of an understood part of being eligible, right? And the graduate transfer exception already rewards players who take care of business in the classroom before their eligibility is up, so I’m not sure the situation is really screaming out for this change. 

It might just be a public relations bone to throw to those who prefer more radical changes than are apparently going to be considered. 

At any rate, it will be interesting to see what changes actually come about, especially since there are already concerns graduate transfers are hurting leagues like the Atlantic 10, Horizon and MAC by stripping them of some players who were recruited and developed at their schools only to strengthen the big boys. 

Making it easier for players to move up the ladder probably wouldn’t help, and that could be bad for the overall health of college athletics. 

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Sports

Hartsock Podcast: Interview with Reds’ Marty Brennaman
Hartsock Podcast: Interview with Reds’ Marty Brennaman

WHIO-TV Sports Director Mike Hartsock spoke at length with Hall of Fame Cincinnati Reds announcer Marty Brennaman for the latest episode of his “Stay Right There” podcast. Get the latest on the Reds from one of broadcasting’s greats. Catch the latest episodes of Mike Hartsock’s “Stay Right There&rdquo...
Here’s how the NFL will define a catch next year (hopefully)
Here’s how the NFL will define a catch next year (hopefully)

Remember how the catch rules in the NFL have been a disaster the last few years?  Apparently that might not be the case anymore.  I hesitate to be too quick to rubberstamp the announcement made by NFL director of officiating Al Riveron, but I would say it’s OK to be optimistic things will be better next season.  If the NFL competition...
Changes are coming to the NFL draft broadcasts
Changes are coming to the NFL draft broadcasts

The NFL has announced new ways fans can watch the draft in April, including one that could be intriguing to college football fans in particular.  NFL Network and ESPN will continue broadcasting the annual talent distribution festival, and Fox is jumping in as well via a partnership with the league’s channel.  For the first time ever...
Pro day is just that for Georgia linebackers as Bill Belichick does some coaching
Pro day is just that for Georgia linebackers as Bill Belichick does some coaching

New England Patriots coach Bill Belichick was one of many interested observers at Georgia’s pro day on Wednesday. But the coaching legend did more than watch; he participated. Belichick coached up the Bulldogs linebackers, who appreciated the help from the legendary coach. The post Pro day is just that for...
Report: Tua Tagovailoa’s injury a ‘sprain,’ to be back at practice soon
Report: Tua Tagovailoa’s injury a ‘sprain,’ to be back at practice soon

The news regarding Alabama quarterback Tua Tagovailoa’s injury is good, as the sophomore quarterback who is competing with Jalen Hurts for the starting job is expected to be back at practice sooner than thought, per Matt Zenitz. The injury which occurred on Tuesday on the opening day of the Crimson Tide’s practice...
More Stories