Crashes cause lawmakers to consider raising driving age

Report says stronger limits would reduce fatal crashes by 39 percent.

Parents from one end of Ohio to the other dread that one phone call about a crash involving another teen at the wheel.

It came in November 2012 for the parents of three Bellbrook High School girls killed after a 17-year-old boy lost control of an extended cab Dodge pickup truck loaded with six teenagers.

It came last October when a Greenon High School junior died after the car he was riding in crashed into a utility pole.

Or last May when a Bishop Fenwick High School student died after being ejected in a rollover crash involving a teen driver.

It comes — everyone can agree — all too often, and as Ohio lawmakers ponder significant changes in the state’s driver’s license laws, young people like Northmont High School junior Emily Frantz can be numbered among the proponents.

“I’m an older sister, so I thought about how it would keep myself, my friends and my sisters safe,” Frantz told lawmakers about the proposed rules. “I would have felt more confident driving if I had been given a year’s worth of practice and instruction.”

Related: ODOT: Several area counties among top 25 for teen crashes

A bill approved by the Ohio House Transportation Committee in an 11-3 vote last week would attempt to do just that. House Bill 293 would extend the temporary instruction permit phase for new drivers to 12 months, up from six months, meaning new drivers would spend time on the road in each of the four seasons.

The bill would also delay issuance of the first license to 16 1/2 years of age and set the curfew for unsupervised teen drivers at 10 p.m., two hours earlier than the current law that requires parental supervision between midnight and 6 a.m.

Advocates for the changes insist that it’s for the safety of the teens — and the rest of the motorists on the roads. Between 2014 and 2016, teen drivers were at-fault in 95,259 crashes statewide, including 286 fatalities and 41,411 injuries, according to the Ohio Highway Patrol. The biggest mistakes: following too closely, failure to yield, unsafe speed and failure to control.

“Not only are those teens and their families impacted but the rest of us on the road are too,” said Anne Goodman, injury prevention coordinator at OhioHealth, a Columbus-based hospital system. “We need to work harder at protecting young teen drivers and all of us who are on the roads with them.”

Related: Where do teen drivers have the highest crash rate in Ohio?

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety says strong graduated driver licensing programs are an easy win for states.

The institute’s online calculator shows how states could reduce crashes and fatalities if they adopted combinations of stringent rules for teens: limiting unsupervised night- time driving hours, boosting the permit and license ages, increasing practice driving hours and limiting the number of passengers teens are allowed to carry.

Rolling back the state’s night driving restrictions for teens from midnight to 10 p.m., as is the case with this bill, could result in a 5 percent reduction in fatal crashes, the calculator estimates. Moving the license age up to 16 1/2 could result in another 7 percent reduction in fatal crashes.

“A lot of these kids, at six months, hardly have any driving experience in,” said Mendy Ruecking, co-owner of Bee Driving School in Hamilton. “I think it’s going to maybe — hopefully — enhance the skills of the young driver more than what they’re required now.”

The institute reports that Ohio could see a 39 percent drop off in fatal crashes for teens if it embraced the strongest limits, according to the online calculator.

The greatest reduction in fatal crashes — 16 percent in Ohio, the institute estimates — would come from prohibiting teens from driving other teens. Some 15 states and the District of Columbia have enacted such a restriction, according to the institute.

Related: Community remembers three students killed in crash

In 2016, there were 305,964 traffic crashes resulting in more than 112,000 injuries and 1,133 fatalities, according to Ohio State Highway Patrol statistics. Data show drivers under age 26 were involved in 27.3 percent of the accidents and are more likely to be at fault than older drivers.

In 2017, drivers aged 15, 16 and 17 were involved in 20,501 accidents, including 55 fatalities and 5,434 injuries across the state. They were at fault in 68.4 percent of those crashes, the data show.

Of Ohio’s 7.8 million licensed drivers, 96,757 have temporary instruction permits, 63,804 are age 16 and 86,526 are age 17, according to the Bureau of Motor Vehicles.

House Bill 293 is backed by the Ohio Conference of AAA Clubs, Ohio Association of Chiefs of Police, Ohio Fraternal Order of Police, Nationwide Children’s Hospital, Ohio PTA and others.

While Frantz favors a more stringent law, she knows it could some time for her Northmont High School peers and others to adjust.

“I think for the kids who are in the process of getting it now, it would be a big deal for them,” she said. “But eventually it would become the new normal. I think for the first couple of years there would be some grumbling among kids.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Politics

States take lead in passing gun laws
States take lead in passing gun laws

Despite the pleas from students across the country for Washington to do something about gun violence, the states seem to be ones listening. In the aftermath of a school shooting in Parkland, Fla., that took the lives of 17 students, at least two states have moved to pass more stringent gun regulations. A handful of Republican governors — including...
Russia investigation: Special counsel Mueller subpoenas Trump Organization
Russia investigation: Special counsel Mueller subpoenas Trump Organization

  Special counsel Robert Mueller has subpoenaed the Trump Organization for documents as part of his investigation into Russian meddling in the 2016 presidential election and its possible ties to President Donald Trump and his associates, according to multiple reports. The subpoena is the first directly connected to one of Trump’s businesses...
Pa. election outcome has some thinking Ohio districts are in play
Pa. election outcome has some thinking Ohio districts are in play

Democrat Conor Lamb’s stunning victory Tuesday in a suburban Pittsburgh congressional district easily won in 2016 by President Donald Trump has convinced Democrats and some independent analysts the party has a chance to compete for at least two GOP seats in Ohio. Although Lamb apparently prevailed over Republican Rick Saccone by less than a thousand...
READ IT NOW: Ex-Springfield firefighter shared post with racial slur
READ IT NOW: Ex-Springfield firefighter shared post with racial slur

A Facebook post shared by a Springfield firefighter that the city says led to his firing contained a racial slur, and mocked school dropouts and McDonald’s employees. Bradley Baugh was fired on March 9 after only a few weeks with the Springfield Fire/Rescue Division, according to city records obtained by the Springfield News-Sun through a public...
Ohio lawmaker wants military to assist Puerto Rico cleanup
Ohio lawmaker wants military to assist Puerto Rico cleanup

In the aftermath of a whirlwind two-day trip to Puerto Rico, Rep. Brad Wenstrup will push for but the active duty and reservists to help assist in the rebuilding of Puerto Rico. Wenstrup, a Cincinnati Republican who serves on the House Veterans Affairs Committee and who is an Army Reservist, flew into Puerto Rico last Sunday for a field hearing on...
More Stories