Seattle moves to replace totem poles with authentic indigenous art

Totem poles have become a symbol of Seattle, but it turns out they have nothing to do with the Coast Salish people of the Northwest. Now there is a growing movement to right the cultural wrongs done by well-meaning white settlers.

>> Read more trending news 

Totem poles from Alaska's tribes, Chief Seattle dressed in the headdress of a Great Plains tribe - these are just some of the things Native Americans say Seattle hasn't gotten right.

Now they want to change that.

Colleen Echohawk stood beside a totem pole inside the Chief Seattle Club, where she is executive director. Totem poles, like the one that rises high above the ground in Pioneer Square, represent native tribes from Alaska, not the Pacific Northwest.

"Well, they stole them, yeah," said Echohawk.

She was asked how that happened.

"There were people who went to Alaska in the gold rush," Echohawk said. "And they got excited. And they saw these beautiful totem poles, which are appropriate to Alaska native culture, and they thought they were cool. And they were brought back to Seattle. Sadly, sometimes they brought them back and they hadn't asked permission."

A case in point is the Pioneer Square totem pole.

"This was two years after the Yukon gold rush," said author Robert Spalding via Skype

Spalding has written a new book, "Monumental Seattle: The Story Behind the City's Statues, Memorials, and Markers." Spalding says some prominent businessmen decided they needed a totem pole to connect Seattle to the Last Frontier, so they stole one from the Tlingit tribe, which is native to Alaska.

"They went ashore and they cut down this totem pole," Spalding said, "Floated it back out to the ship and brought it to Seattle."

Seattle City Council member Debora Juarez says it is more than the theft.

"Imagine a whole group of people where this is indigenous land that is not represented," said Juarez.

She spoke out recently on the Seattle Channel program, “City Inside/Out: Council Edition.” 

"It comes down to a value system in who we are as Seattle, Chief Seattle," she said. "And you know we have the emblem of the chief, which by the way is a 'Plains Indian,' not a 'coastal Indian.' We have the poles down at Steinbrueck Park, which are not traditional Coastal Salish poles."

Indeed, she and others say this park, initially known as Native Park, was largely the creation of one man, Victor Steinbrueck. The totem poles were designed by Marvin Oliver, a well-known native artist, but "He's pretty clear that those are Victor's poles," says Colleen Echohawk. "He says that over and over again."

At some point, Echohawk called their actions "compassionate racism." 

"Yeah, that is a phrase I kind of have coined a little bit on this," said Echohawk. "I feel like there was so much good intention, like so (many) compassionate people who were creating this park."

Still, she says those good intentions have not made life better for native peoples here. 

"These kinds of of appropriation of our arts and culture and misrepresentative of who we are, as native people, it has a reaction," Echohawk said. "And the reaction is in human suffering."

She and others are pushing for changes at Victor Steinbrueck Park that better reflect the native people it was designed to honor. Any changes would come before the Seattle City Council committee Debora Juarez chairs. Juarez is an enrolled member of the Blackfeet Nation.

A new chapter is being written.

Reader Comments

Next Up in Nation World

Bond set at $20,000 in Springfield gun case
Bond set at $20,000 in Springfield gun case

A Springfield man is accused of running from police and illegally having a loaded gun in his car. Emmanuel Crossley, 28, is charged in Clark County Municipal Court with having a weapon while under disability, carrying concealed weapons and improperly handling firearms in a motor vehicle. Crossley pleaded not guilty and his bond was set at $20,000....
19-year-old drunken driver charged in crash that killed young Texas mother, injured 2
19-year-old drunken driver charged in crash that killed young Texas mother, injured 2

A Texas 19-year-old has been charged with killing a young mother in a violent crash Sunday night as she drove with her toddler son and her mother.  Erick Raphael Hernandez, of Pearland, was charged Monday with intoxication manslaughter in the death of 23-year-old Taylor Phillips, court records show. As of Tuesday morning, he had been released...
Mueller investigation: Michael Flynn sentencing delayed
Mueller investigation: Michael Flynn sentencing delayed

A federal judge agreed to delay sentencing for President Donald Trump’s former National Security Adviser Michael Flynn on Tuesday after he pleaded guilty last year to lying to the FBI. Flynn resigned from his post in the Trump administration in February 2017 after serving just 24 days in office. He pleaded guilty in December 2017 to lying to...
Actress, director Penny Marshall dead at 75
Actress, director Penny Marshall dead at 75

Penny Marshall, the actress and director best known for “Laverne and Shirley,” “A League of Their Own” and “Big,” has died, her publicist confirmed to the New York Daily News. She was 75. “Yes she did (die) … peacefully at her Hollywood Hills home,” publicist Michelle Bega said. “She passed...
Who is Mathew Golsteyn and why is Trump tweeting about him?
Who is Mathew Golsteyn and why is Trump tweeting about him?

President Donald Trump tweeted Sunday that he would be looking into the case of a former Green Beret officer who is facing a murder charge in the death of suspected bomb maker in Afghanistan in 2010. >> Read more trending news Trump said he would review the case of Army Maj. Mathew L. Golsteyn who, during his service in Afghanistan, was awarded...
More Stories