"You even see a little bit of, like, Pablo Picasso going on here," Fletcher told the jug's owner, Alvin Barr, who reportedly bought the piece for $300 at an estate sale in Eugene, Oregon.
According to the Bend Bulletin, the piece was actually made as a high school art project in 1973 or 1974 by Betsy Soule, now a horse trainer in Bend, Oregon.
"The whole story has had me laughing out loud for over a month now," said Soule, now 60, who learned of the mix-up when a friend recognized the jug on the show. "It's just the most fun thing ever."
Fletcher has since revised the appraisal, The Washington Post reports.
>> Click here to watch the segment
About the Author