No deal expected from pension panel before deadline

Sherrod Brown says a bipartisan solution is still attainable.


The leaders of the bipartisan House-Senate committee tasked with solving a pension crisis that threatens the retirement security of 1.3 million Americans said Thursday they won’t be able to finalize an agreement to send to Congress before Nov. 30 — the self-imposed Friday deadline they set when they established the committee.

Sens. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, and Sherrod Brown, D-Ohio, said in a joint statement that “we believe a bipartisan solution is attainable, and we will continue working to reach that solution.”

Brown and Hatch, co-chairs the Joint Select Committee on the Solvency of Multiemployer Pension Plans, reported making “meaningful progress,” but said the problems “are multifaceted and over the years have proven to be incredibly difficult to address.”

RELATED: Businesses warn Congress pension plans are running out of money

What’s unclear is whether that means the committee aims to have an agreement by the end of the year, whether it will continue in the next Congress, or whether it will disband altogether and let the new Congress sort out a solution.

Sen. Rob Portman, R-Ohio, who is also a member of the joint committee, said in a statement that letting the multiemployer pension system collapse is “an unacceptable outcome.”

The joint committee, which Brown fought for as part of a budget deal reached last February, operated under the premise that it would have until Nov. 30 to create a deal that could be sent to Congress for an up-or-down vote without amendment.

That deal would aim to shore up the nation’s at-risk multiemployer pension plans — pension plans that allow employers to pool their resources to provide retirement for their workers. According to the Pension Rights Center, some 150 to 200 plans out of about 1,400 nationwide, are at risk of running out of money within the next 10 years.

RELATED: Sherrod Brown pitches bill to protect pensions

Among the at-risk plans: Central States, which includes 48,000 Ohio members of the Teamsters union. Brown’s office says some 60,000 Ohioans are in at-risk plans and nationally 1.3 Americans could be affected.

Brown has pushed a bill that would create a low-interest, 30-year loan program to troubled pension systems with no cuts to benefits. That bill, called the Butch Lewis Act, is named after a West Chester retiree who died in 2015 while fighting to save his pension.

Republicans have been resistant to the bill, however, arguing it could be perceived as a bailout paid for by taxpayers. Pensioners in the at-risk plans argue that they paid into those funds over the course of their careers and are only getting what they are owed.

RELATED: Portman calls on pension panel to shed partisanship

Mike Walden, president of the National United Committee to Protect Pensions and a retired Roadway Express Teamster from Akron, said he is not surprised that the committee did not reach an agreement by its self-imposed deadline.

“I think most of us, after seeing who was picked by the different sides, knew right away there’d either be deadlock or nothing done at all,” he said. “And here we are.”

He’s hopeful for an agreement next year but added: “It’s going to cost everyone more money if we let it go another year.”



Reader Comments


Next Up in Politics

Ohio lawmakers vote to ban late-term abortion procedure
Ohio lawmakers vote to ban late-term abortion procedure

The Ohio House on Thursday voted 62-27 to outlaw abortions performed by dilation and evacuation, a procedure commonly used to terminate pregnancies between 13 and 24 weeks gestation. In 2017, 3,441 D&E abortions were performed in Ohio, according to state records. It marked the second abortion restriction bill approved by lawmakers in two days. RELATED...
Ohio Gov.-Elect Mike DeWine meets with President Donald Trump
Ohio Gov.-Elect Mike DeWine meets with President Donald Trump

Joining 12 other newly elected governors at the White House Thursday, Gov.-elect Mike DeWine said President Donald Trump “listened very carefully and was very engaging” as they talked about constructing new roads and bridges, combating drugs, and keeping Lake Erie clean. “There wasn’t much contention in there,” DeWine...
Ohio lawmakers vote to give themselves a pay raise
Ohio lawmakers vote to give themselves a pay raise

Ohio lawmakers, the governor and other elected leaders would be in line for a pay raise under a bill approved by the Ohio House on Thursday. The bill still needs to clear the Senate and be signed by Gov. John Kasich but the governor expressed distaste for the pay raises, especially since they are coming during the lame duck session. On Thursday, the...
President Donald Trump issues challenge to John Kasich to run in 2020
President Donald Trump issues challenge to John Kasich to run in 2020

When asked if other Republicans such as Ohio Gov. John Kasich should challenge him in a primary in 2020, President Donald Trump on Thursday said, “I hope so.” During a Fox News interview with Harris Faulkner, the president was asked about a challenge from Kasich or retiring Arizona Sen. Jeff Flake. Kasich strategist John Weaver sent a short...
Ohio may set up database for violent offenders
Ohio may set up database for violent offenders

Ohio lawmakers have approved the creation of a statewide database of violent offenders under legislation named for a college student who disappeared while bicycling and was abducted and slain. The bill named for Sierah Joughin and known as “Sierah’s Law” was approved recently and will take effect if it is signed by Republican Gov...
More Stories