Sports Today: Yep, Alabama making the College Football Playoff still smells funny


The Bengals-Steelers game wasn’t the only sporting event last night. It just seemed like it. Here’s a rundown of some of the other stuff that happened:  

Kirk Herbstreit told Dan Patrick he would have picked Alabama over Ohio State, too. 

I’m ready to move on from the College Football Playoff debate because what’s done is done, but I still found these comments interesting. 

The Centerville legend has been knocked for trying too hard not to be an Ohio State homer before, but I think he was genuine here. 

He basically concluded Alabama is better because the Buckeyes didn’t have an easier time putting away Wisconsin. 

That’s not unreasonable, but it’s not really fair, either. 

First of all, the Badgers were at a talent deficit, but they are still a tough out. That’s how they get to 12-0 and why they have such a good record overall in recent years. 

Second of all, Alabama might have struggled with Georgia if it had actually been playing. 

I said up front I didn’t believe Ohio State got a raw deal because the Buckeyes put themselves in position to be passed up… but man is the pick of Alabama ever more distasteful the more I think about it. 

The Crimson Tide getting in by default just rubs me the wrong way.

Even if Alabama proves to be one of the four best teams, it stinks in general because there is no reliable way to determine that at this point and Nick Saban’s team accomplished almost literally nothing on the field in 2016. 

Alabama didn’t beat either of the teams that won divisions in the SEC, and that league was nothing to brag about this season. It has become like the ACC used to be — full of talented players but light on good teams because of a coaching drain. 

The ACC is the best conference now thanks to better leadership, but we’ll see how that evolves with some change in both leagues... 

Chris Holtmann’s Ohio State basketball tenure got a boost when his Buckeyes stormed back to beat Michigan at the Value City Mausoleum

Ohio State trailed by 20 late in the first half but dominated the second to improve to an improbable 2-0 in the Big Ten. 

The inconsistent Buckeyes showed good poise late in the second half as the game remained close, and they ended up committing only 10 turnovers. 

It remains to be seen how good the Wolverines or Wisconsin (whom the Buckeyes blew out Saturday night) will be, but I suspect there are going to be a lot of toss-up games in the Big Ten this year… 

Meanwhile, Anthony Grant and his Dayton Flyers were back home in Dayton following a tough loss at Mississippi State. 

We talked to Grant, Jalen Crutcher and Josh Cunningham for a few minutes before practice (full recap here) and the takeaway was not surprising: This season is going to be a long process of getting to know each other. 

Jalen Crutcher taking ownership of the team could mean more growing pains but also an accelerated learning curve for the Flyers, who could be pretty formidable if they can take care of the ball and stay out of foul trouble. 

READ MORE: Here’s what we learned during Dayton’s media availability Monday

Unfortunately, it seems like there is no magic formula for making either of those things happen. 

Grant said there is no common thread with the consistent foul trouble, and he pointed out a large percentage of the turnovers came outside of the offense… 

If you missed my reaction to the Bengals game, you can find that here. 

Before the game, Boomer Esiason shared some interesting thoughts with local reporters on Marvin Lewis and Andy Dalton. 

The former Bengals quarterback seems to be seeing a lot of the same things those of us around Ohio have been: A situation that has gotten stale. 

“You’d love to see a new-found energy around this team because that’s what it’s going to end up taking.” 

The lefty expressed a belief Dalton is good enough to be a winner in the NFL but mentioned something else that I’ve wondered about before. 

“I think Andy gets down on himself, that’s just me watching from afar. I just want to shake him and say, ‘You’re better than this. You’re a good player. You should be the leader of this team. This should be your team, there should be no questions about that. You have to assume that mantle.” 

I have to wonder: If that didn’t happen this year, when will it? 


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Sports

Future Buckeye Justin Ahrens shows off bigger body, expanded game at Flyin’ at the Hoop 
Future Buckeye Justin Ahrens shows off bigger body, expanded game at Flyin’ at the Hoop 

There was more to see of Justin Ahrens at the 2018 Flyin’ to the Hoop than last year’s version — in more ways than one.  The Versailles senior, who signed with Ohio State in November, said he is an inch taller and about 10 pounds heavier than he was last season.  The reigning Midwest Athletics Conference Player of the Year...
Dayton Dragons announce 2018 coaching staff
Dayton Dragons announce 2018 coaching staff

Luis Bolivar will return as Dayton Dragons manager after guiding the team to the postseason in his first season at the helm.  The Cincinnati Reds low Single-A affiliate made that announcement and unveiled its 2018 coaching staff Tuesday.  Seth Etherton will serve as pitching coach while Daryle Ward returns as hitting coach and Kevin Mahar...
Sports Today: Does Jags postseason success mean Bengals have a fighting chance?
Sports Today: Does Jags postseason success mean Bengals have a fighting chance?

After a three-day weekend there’s one obvious question to ask this morning: Was the NFL divisional round good or bad for the Cincinnati Bengals?  Well, it probably won’t affect the team.  They are going to be the same either way. That’s kind of their thing.  Even when there are changes, I have succumbed to the feeling...
Dayton at St. Joe’s: Everything you need to know about Wednesday’s game
Dayton at St. Joe’s: Everything you need to know about Wednesday’s game

Who: Dayton (9-8, 3-2) at St. Joseph’s (7-9, 2-3) When: 6:30 p.m., Wednesday Where: Hagan Arena, Philadelphia TV/Radio: CBS Sports Network; AM 1290, News 95.7 WHIO Darrell Davis, 6-5, Sr., G, 17.6 Josh Cunningham, 6-7, R-Jr., F, 15.6 Trey Landers, 6-5, So., G, 9.0 Jordan Davis, 6-2, Fr., G, 7.8 Jalen Crutcher, 6-1, Fr., G, 6.5 Shavar...
With returning cast, Clemson enters 2018 with championship expectations
With returning cast, Clemson enters 2018 with championship expectations

College football teams can’t win a national championship in the middle of January (the bowl season hasn’t been pushed that far back yet), but Clemson took a giant step towards another title on Monday. Defensive tackle Christian Wilkins sent shock waves throughout the college football world with his decision Monday...
More Stories