Hartman: Ohio State saved more than face by blasting Michigan State

Ohio State restored order in the Big Ten East on Saturday afternoon. 

Unfortunately for the 11th-ranked Buckeyes, their 48-3 evisceration of No. 13 Michigan State will probably be too little, too late when it comes to the 2017 national championship. 

I guess they’ll have to settle for saving the program. 

Is that being overdramatic? 


But as we said two weeks ago when the Buckeyes miraculously rallied to beat Penn State — was it only two weeks ago? — narratives are a big part of college football

PHOTOS: Ohio State trounces Michigan State

Ohio State overcame myriad errors to take out the Nittany Lions, leading us to praise their mental fortitude and will to win. 

The sky again was the limit for the Buckeyes, who atoned for their early-season loss to Oklahoma and restored their path to the playoff. 

Then they made some of those same errors and many more in an inexplicable 55-24 loss at Iowa seven days later. 

Just the score of that game was shocking, but if you watched the game, you probably came away thinking it wasn’t even that close. 

The Hawkeyes made the Buckeyes look like a high school team as much as one ranked in the top 10 of college football. 

RELATED: Old problems resurface in stunning loss

That game also put the errors against Penn State in a new light. 

Which one is the real Ohio State team, anyway? 

Coach Urban Meyer faced tougher questions the Monday after the Iowa loss

Of course there were queries about discipline, maturity and the game plan on both sides of the ball. 

But there were also some existential questions. 

He deflected one about the direction of the program but acknowledged there’s at least some chance his team is, um, too talented. 

Wait, what? Isn’t recruiting great players the name of the game in college football? 

Yes, but with that inevitably comes outside pressures — like NFL draft status. 

And when more and more players start spending less than four years in Columbus — whether it’s because they go pro early or transfer out when they get recruited over — what does that do to the soul of a team? 

“I think that's part of life in the big city,” Meyer said Monday. “That when you recruit good players and develop them and they play well there's chances — great chances — that it creates all kinds of issues.” 

Ohio State fans of a certain age are probably more sensitive to this kind of thinking than others. Those who saw John Cooper’s Buckeyes annually romp through September and October in the 1990s only to lose to an inferior team — too often Michigan — and miss a chance at a Big Ten title or greater couldn’t help but endure some uncomfortable flashbacks. 

RELATED: Some perspective on the Penn State win

Cooper, like Meyer, recruited many NFL-quality players and pulled them from high schools across the country. 

In between, Jim Tressel constructed teams that dominated both Michigan and the Big Ten while also tending to have a more significant Ohio flavor. 

No less a college football authority than Kirk Herbstreit (the Centerville native, son of a Buckeye captain and Cooper’s first recruit at Ohio State) broached the topic on ESPN Saturday morning, wondering if there were enough guys on the roster who cared about the Big Ten championship to buy the importance of every game. 

However valid those concerns might have been, the Buckeyes did all they could to alleviate them against Michigan State, a team that has been a thorn in Meyer’s side since he returned to Columbus. 

The Spartans are heading back to East Lansing smarting from their worst loss in series history, and Ohio State could clinch a berth in the Big Ten championship game next week with a win over Illinois and a Michigan loss at Wisconsin. 

Meyer has done a great job recruiting and developing players at Ohio State. No one disputes that. 

But there’s also no doubt winning is hard, and winning programs are fragile. 

READ MORE: 7 things to know about the start of college basketball season

He’s lost control of a major program before (at Florida), and the end of the Coooer era was pretty close to the same thing at Ohio State before Tressel came to the rescue. 

Some concern was reasonable. 

How much? That’s hard to say, but Meyer didn’t deny this was an important win for his team psychologically. 

“I think you know the answer: Of course you needed it,” Meyer said. “And college football, 18- to 22-year-olds, even more than I imagine the NFL, but it's a game of momentum. 

“The browbeatings that take place and all these things, you need these kinds of things. You need a great performance. 

“And they had a great performance.”

So those big-picture worries can be put away… at least for another week or two. 

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Sports

OSU’s Holtmann first coach in 95 years to win first 7 Big Ten games
OSU’s Holtmann first coach in 95 years to win first 7 Big Ten games

Chris Holtmann became the first coach in 95 years to win his first seven Big Ten games as No. 22 Ohio State defeated Northwestern 71-65 on Wednesday night. C.J. Jackson had 12 points, eight assists and three steals, Micah Potter scored 13 points off the bench, Jae’Sean Tate added 12 and Keita Bates-Diop had 10 points and eight rebounds for the...
HS Results 1/17: Centerville drops Lebanon, Waynesville beats Oakwood

Boys Basketball Cedarville 63, West Jefferson 53: Colby Cross poured in 29 points, including five three-point baskets, to carry Cedarville in the win. Girls Basketball Centerville 66, Lebanon 62: Emma Stanley scored 18 points, leading four players in double-digit scoring for Centerville. Alexis Straw led Lebanon with 21. Beavercreek 60, Miamisburg...
HS Scores 1/17: Cross leads Cedarville, Hamilton edges Middies

Boys Basketball Tuesday’s Results Belmont 68, Franklyn 51: Hunt (B) 20; Kinder (F) 16. Butler 55, Tecumseh 32: Justice (B) 22. Chaminade Julienne 61, Thurgood Marshall 59 Clark Montessori 67, Cin. Christian 50: Ealy (CM) 24; Reutener (CC) 12. Clinton Massie 59, Valley View 55: Chowning (CM) 20. Dayton Christian 48, Emmanuel Christian 29: Welker...
Unbeaten Wittenberg rolls over Ohio Wesleyan
Unbeaten Wittenberg rolls over Ohio Wesleyan

The beard lives on in Springfield. Wittenberg men’s basketball coach Matt Croci says he won’t shave until his team loses this season and the Tigers made sure the growth will continue with a 93-72 win over Ohio Wesleyan on Wednesday night. The Tigers (16-0, 9-0) climbed to No. 5 in the D3hoops.com poll this week and promptly proved they...
Stanford remains a contender in Pac-12 with win over Arizona State; 3 things we learned
Stanford remains a contender in Pac-12 with win over Arizona State; 3 things we learned

The Stanford Cardinal remain tied atop the Pac-12 standings with Arizona following Wednesday night’s 86-77 upset win over No. 16 Arizona State. Dorian Pickens led Stanford with 19 points, while Romello White also scored 19 for the Sun Devils. Stanford is now 11-8 overall and 5-1 in Pac-12 play, while Arizona State dropped to 14-4...
More Stories