Hartman: Ohio State Buckeyes should be in the College Football Playoff


When it comes to Ohio State making the College Football Playoff despite not even playing for a Big Ten championship, I’ve been trying take the most conservative stance possible.

Perhaps that was a mistake.

RELATED: Buckeyes’ playoff fate in hands of the committee now

A fresh look at the cases of every team that seems to be realistically in the running has changed my mind.

Now it looks like Ohio State’s case is so much better than anyone from the Pac 12 or Big 12 that the Buckeyes’ being left out would be a huge upset.

Anything is possible, but the numbers are pretty stark.

Ohio State has already beaten more bowl-eligible teams (eight) than Washington (four) or Colorado (three) will have even after one of them beats the other this weekend.

The same is true of Ohio State vs. Oklahoma (four) and Oklahoma State (four). (Plus the Buckeyes beat the Sooners, of course.)

Beyond that, while none of those teams have a top 10 win, Ohio State has two.

So no matter what happens this weekend, the Buckeyes will still have a clearly better resume than the champion of at least two major conferences.

That means even if Penn State wins the Big Ten, there should still be a spot available for the Buckeyes.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Sports

H.S. football: New coach, new conference for Greenon

After he was hired to coach the Greenon High School football team in February, one of the first things Josh Wooten did was find his “yes” men. Well, in a manner of speaking. Wooten presented potential coaching hires with four questions: Can I trust you? Do you love Greenon? Do you love our community? Do you love our kids? “If your...
KC QBs light up Bengals defense in 30-12 rout
KC QBs light up Bengals defense in 30-12 rout

The Cincinnati Bengals lost starting safety Shawn Williams to a right elbow injury in addition to losing track of numerous Kansas City wide receivers Saturday night as the three Chiefs quarterbacks steered a rout at Paul Brown Stadium. Kansas City scored on its first five possessions, the last four of which resulted in touchdowns as the Chiefs whipped...
Tom Archdeacon: Reminiscing with the NFL’s first black quarterback
Tom Archdeacon: Reminiscing with the NFL’s first black quarterback

He opened the old leather bag in front of him and with his left hand — where the ring finger was adorned with a bulky, gold College Football Hall of Fame ring — he began rummaging through the packed contents. “I’ll show you how Jim Crow it was back then,” George Taliaferro said quietly as he began his search, pulling out...
H.S. football: Experience a plus for win-starved Cedarville

The Cedarville Indians football roster is down about three players from last season. For most schools that’s inconsequential. For schools like Cedarville it’s an obstacle. The Indians have 19 players. Coach Jason Christian is hopeful those numbers will rebound to the mid-20s next season with a larger eighth-grade class coming up. &ldquo...
What to know to kick off high school football season
What to know to kick off high school football season

The high school football season begins with three area games Thursday, the bulk of the Week 1 games on Friday and a few others on Saturday and next Sunday. Here’s a rundown of teams to watch and things to know. Changes: Most important, this season marks the debut of the Ohio High School Athletic Association competitive balance initiative. The...
More Stories