Ask Hal: Hitting coach not to blame for Reds’ struggles

Hall-of-fame baseball writer Hal McCoy knows a thing or two about America’s pastime. If you’d like to tap into that knowledge, send a question to

Q: Basketball and football have prospered by changing some rules, like the 3-point line in basketball and passing rules in football, so what must baseball do to save the sport? — DAVE, MIAMISBURG/CENTERVILLE/BEAVERCREEK

A: Baseball is not in the same category as the whales and manatees. It doesn’t need saving. It is prospering like it never prospered before. And it has changed, more drastically than any sport, with the DH and interleague play. Personally, the game probably would be better off without the DH and interleague play, but Bud Selig didn’t ask me.

Q: Who as a hitter, young or old, has improved under hitting coach Brook Jacoby? — BRIAN, NORTHRIDGE

A: Jay Bruce has improved every year. Joey Votto never had the success in the minors he is having in the majors. But giving Jacoby credit for all of that is giving too much credit, just as blaming him for others’ lack of success is giving him too much blame. Professional players are supposed to know how to hit, how to approach an at-bat, when they make the majors. Jacoby watches video and batting practice and corrects flaws and hitches. It is up to the players to carry it out to the batter’s box. Jacoby isn’t allowed to hold their hands.

Q: It seems the farther west the Cincinnati Reds go the less success they have. Is that why they have never won a game in Honolulu? — DAVID, SPRINGFIELD

A: They lost one very big game in Honolulu in the winter of 1977 when the winter meetings were held in the Sheraton-Waikiki. They traded minor-league first baseman Dave Revering for All-Star pitcher Vida Blue and $1 million. Commissioner Bowie Kuhn stepped in and said, “No, no, no, not good for baseball,” and negated the deal. What most fans don’t remember, though, is that two months later the Reds still traded Revering to Oakland — for relief pitcher Doug Bair, who became an efficient closer.

Q: Can a trade be made to bring in somebody with Scott Rolen’s leadership and clubhouse credentials to reverse this trend of lackadaisical play? — DAVID, LEXINGTON, KY.

A: No, no, a thousand times no. You can’t bring in an outsider and say “lead us to the promised land.” Leadership and respect have to be earned over time in a clubhouse and a new face can’t do it. And a team only looks lackadaisical when it isn’t hitting and winning. You can’t look fired up when you are getting shut out.

Q: How long can the Reds continue to give manager Dusty Baker a pass in his handling of this team? — LARRY, DOUGLASVILLE, GA.

A: He doesn’t need a pass. All the security people recognize him and he walks right into the stadium. I’m not sure what it means for a manager to “handle” a team. He plays the players given to him, replaces injured players with the best alternatives, puts players in spots best suited to their situations and turns them loose. How they play is up to them. If fans want a handler, the Reds should hire a lion tamer.

Q: With the Reds’ record against winning teams under .400, don’t you think it is time for a change on the 25-man roster? — DAVE, DAYTON

A: Change for the sake of change seldom works. Isn’t it too early to start cleaning out the clubhouse? It’s not like the Reds are the Los Angeles Dodgers or Toronto Blue Jays, tremendously underachieving teams. And they aren’t the Cubs or the Brewers. They’ve held it together pretty well through some adversity that might have buried other teams. Patience, patience, patience.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Sports

Stephenson, Scooter lift Reds to 11-8 win over Braves
Stephenson, Scooter lift Reds to 11-8 win over Braves

Julio Teheran still considers himself to be Atlanta’s ace, even if his numbers suggest otherwise. “Yeah, that’s the spot I want to be in hopefully for my whole career,” he said. “That doesn’t mean I won’t have ups and downs. We’re all human. We all make mistakes.” Scooter Gennett hit a grand slam...
HS Results 8/19: Springboro opens season with shutout win

The Springboro girls soccer team started the season on a winning note with a 1-0 win over Bearden (TN) at the Bearden High School Invitational on Saturday. Liv Page tallied the game-winner off an Alex Garver assist with 28 minutes to play in the second half. Keeper Kristy Catrine posted the shutout with five saves. Boro continues play in the tournament...
H.S. football: New coach, new conference for Greenon

After he was hired to coach the Greenon High School football team in February, one of the first things Josh Wooten did was find his “yes” men. Well, in a manner of speaking. Wooten presented potential coaching hires with four questions: Can I trust you? Do you love Greenon? Do you love our community? Do you love our kids? “If your...
Chiefs QBs light up Bengals defense in 30-12 rout
Chiefs QBs light up Bengals defense in 30-12 rout

The Cincinnati Bengals lost starting safety Shawn Williams to a right elbow injury in addition to losing track of numerous Kansas City wide receivers Saturday night as three Chiefs quarterbacks steered a rout at Paul Brown Stadium. Kansas City scored on its first five possessions, the last four of which resulted in touchdowns as the Chiefs whipped...
Tom Archdeacon: Reminiscing with the NFL’s first black quarterback
Tom Archdeacon: Reminiscing with the NFL’s first black quarterback

He opened the old leather bag in front of him and with his left hand — where the ring finger was adorned with a bulky, gold College Football Hall of Fame ring — he began rummaging through the packed contents. “I’ll show you how Jim Crow it was back then,” George Taliaferro said quietly as he began his search, pulling out...
More Stories