You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.


  • ePAPER

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and interactive features. Starting at just 99c for 8 weeks.


Welcome to

Your source for Clark and Champaign counties’ hometown news. All readers have free access to a limited number of stories every month.

If you are a News-Sun subscriber, please take a moment to login for unlimited access.

Zimmerman verdict brings mixed reactions, race discussion

The not guilty verdict in the George Zimmerman hit home for one law professor because the case reminded her of her son being stopped by police as he walked home from the University of Dayton in the early 1990s.

“One son was stopped so many times that I ultimately had to go in and talk to the chief of police and said this has got to stop,” said Vernellia Randall, professor of law emeritus at UD. “Walking home at night is not suspicious. The only thing that makes it suspicious is that he was black and in Oakwood… . I began to be fearful that him being 19, he would get angry one of these times.”

The reaction of experts and residents to the verdict was mixed, mostly along racial lines.

Randall and UD Law Professor Tom Hagel both thought prosecutors overreached in going for a second-degree murder charge in the Feb. 26, 2012, death of Trayvon Martin instead of concentrating on manslaughter, which was included in the jury’s instructions as an alternative.

“I wasn’t shocked but I was a little surprised just due to the dynamics of this case,” Hagel said. “I thought there was a strong chance they’d find (Zimmerman) guilty of manslaughter, but I was not shocked because both sides had a pretty good argument for their positions.”

Not long after the verdict was announced, Dayton’s Monica Hockett said: “I think it’s some bull. He should have been found guilty because he killed that little boy for no reason, basically.”

Beavercreek’s Ryan Bevins said: “I feel like it never should have gone to trial. I just don’t think they had enough to go with, that’s kind of my initial reaction,” he said. “I think it could have a lot of different ways. To get a not guilty (verdict) doesn’t really shock or surprise me whatsoever. I think a lot of people were going on emotion but the law is what it is.”

Hagel said Zimmeramn’s actions — following Martin under the guise of being a neighborhood crime-watch volunteer — must be kept separate from when Martin allegedly had Zimmerman pinned and slammed his head on the pavement.

“My guess is (Zimmerman) was acting wrongfully at the beginning, but at the time of the killing, did Zimmerman have a right to use deadly force from what he perceived to be the imminent threat of seriously bodily harm or death?” Hagel said. ‘(Martin) was beating him. I salute the jury. I think they really thought this thing through.”

Kennith Inskeep of Indianapolis, in Dayton visiting family, said the verdict wasn’t fair. “I feel justice wasn’t served,” he said “An unarmed kid, a teenager, slain, another life lost. I think that was kind of foul. Not even a manslaughter, no conviction. It’s cut and dried. He wasn’t armed.”

Randall said the racial aspect of the situation couldn’t be ignored and she said Judge Debra Nelson erred by not allowing more discussion about the reasonableness of Zimmerman following Martin, contrary to neighborhood watch instructions. She said common law used to allow for deadly force in self-defense but asked people to escape if possible.

“Stand your ground turns on its head everything we have known about self-defense,” Randall said. “Why would they allow people to be the aggressor and then be able to use deadly force after he was losing a fight he started?

“What the Florida law does is authorize people to act on their biases and prejudices and stereotypes because they can say they were fearful of what this person was going to be doing.”

Hagel said a majority of states allow deadly force even if escape is an option, though he’s not sure if Zimmerman could have escaped while pinned to the pavement. “You can stand your ground and use deadly force even though you could have got away,” Hagel said. “That’s where the big controversy comes in.”

Randall’s son, Tshaka, who was stopped by police while walking home from UD to his Oakwood home in the early 1990s, is now an assistant professor of law at Florida A&M University.

“He wonders to what extent did George Zimmerman having a gun made him more brave than he would have been had he not have a gun,” Vernellia Randall said. “Would he have even confronted that kid if he didn’t have that gun?”

Randall said she’s always been against guns, but feels maybe she should advise her sons to be armed: “If everybody’s going to pack a gun and pull it out and shoot, pull yours out and shoot, too.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in News

Winter to take a break?
Winter to take a break?

You have to admit, it seemed winter was going to get off to a brutal start when we received 3 to 6 inches of snow about 10 days before Christmas. Since then, we’ve had a couple of one to two inch snowfalls but nothing major. Over the weekend, we had to deal with some ice. But it seems this January has been known to cause a little “weather...
Nicole Kidman clarifies call for nation to unite behind Donald Trump
Nicole Kidman clarifies call for nation to unite behind Donald Trump

Actress Nicole Kidman clarified her comments on President-elect Donald Trump and the 2016 election results after coming under fire for suggesting that the nation should unify behind the incoming president. “I just say, [Trump's] now elected, and we as a country need to support whoever’s the president because that’s what...
Trump slams 'Saturday Night Live' after press conference sketch
Trump slams 'Saturday Night Live' after press conference sketch

It's not the first time Trump has criticized "SNL." Last month, he called the show "unwatchable" and "biased," slamming Baldwin's portrayal of him. He also previously called the show "boring and unfunny" and "totally one-sided."
Scattered showers ahead tonight
Scattered showers ahead tonight

Patchy fog developed in spots overnight with drizzle possible during the early morning. Drivers may see a few slick spots, especially in the far northern Miami Valley where temperatures have been at or below freezing much of the night. Patchy fog and drizzle early Monday morning Rain chances increase Monday through Tuesday ...
Superbug resistant to all U.S. antibiotics kills Nevada woman
Superbug resistant to all U.S. antibiotics kills Nevada woman

The victim, who is unnamed, was in her 70s. She was initially hospitalized in August 2016 after returning from a trip to India. There, she had sought treatment for a broken hip several times in recent years, most recently in June 2016. Her most recent hospitalization, according to a postmortem CDC report, was in June 2016. The victim died of septic...
More Stories