You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to SpringfieldNewsSun.com

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.

GREAT REASONS TO SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

  • IN-DEPTH REPORTING
  • INTERACTIVE STORYTELLING
  • NEW TOPICS & COVERAGE
  • ePAPER
X

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and interactive features. Starting at just 99c for 8 weeks.

X

Welcome to SpringfieldNewsSun.com

Your source for Clark and Champaign counties’ hometown news. All readers have free access to a limited number of stories every month.

If you are a News-Sun subscriber, please take a moment to login for unlimited access.

Tax reform key to economic growth

House will introduce tax reform legislation soon, though it will be ‘politicized.’


Tax reform may be the new puppy of politics: Everyone likes it in theory, but when it’s gnawing on your shoes, howling all night and having accidents on your carpet, things get a little dicey.

Conceptually, Democrats and Republicans agree that the current tax code is a cumbersome mess; weighing in at whopping 73,954 pages, it’s so difficult to navigate that 90 percent of Americans use either software or a hired professional to do their taxes.

Both sides also agree it’s also not fair, full of loopholes that allow some companies to pay virtually no taxes while others pay more than 40 percent.

And it’s powerful, capable of helping or hindering the economy, encouraging behavior such as buying houses, donating to charities, or locating new factories in the United States or abroad.

It’s those factors that have spurred lawmakers to sit down and take a close look at the tax code in the hopes for the first major reform since 1986. Some are hopeful — bullish, even — that that the new year will bring a new focus on simplifying and overhauling a tax code that they say has done little to help the economy recover.

House Budget Committee Chair Paul Ryan, R-Wis., who is vying to take over the helm of the powerful House Ways and Means Committee in 2015, expressed hope earlier this month that the committee would introduce something early next year. And Rep. Pat Tiberi, R-Genoa Township, a member of the committee, predicts the House will introduce tax reform legislation soon after Jan. 1.

Different reform goals

Republicans see lowering the corporate tax rate, expanding the base and eliminating loopholes as key to reducing the deficit and boosting the slowly-recovering economy.

Democrats agree that the corporate tax rate is too high. They also want to generate new revenue, primarily by taxing wealthier Americans. Doing so, they say, could do more to stimulate the economy, which would also decrease the deficit.

“What Democrats really want is greater fairness in the tax code. What Republicans really want, I think, is they want a more robust, more rapidly growing economy and greater prosperity, which they think will trickle down to everyone,” said Richard Vedder, an economics professor at Ohio University. “There ought to be places to make deals.”

There’s a lot on the line, said Pete Sepp of the National Taxpayers Union, a taxpayer watchdog. “The tax structure doesn’t just go to questions of who pays what,” he said. “It goes to question of how our economy will evolve in the future.”

The committees working on tax reform have already done a considerable amount of work. Tiberi said the House Ways and Means Committee has worked on the issue since 2011, including convening the committee, its subcommittees and more than a dozen working groups.

In early 2013, House Ways and Means Chair Dave Camp, R-Mich., and Senate Finance Chair Max Baucus, D-Montana, did a “road show” where they traveled the country together talking about the need for tax reform. The two are amicable, said Tiberi, but that may not matter in the end: President Obama earlier this month signaled his intent to nominate Baucus as the ambassador the China, which means that if he’s confirmed, there will be a new chairman of the Senate Finance Committee.

But Tiberi worries that politics will quickly eclipse any progress. He said despite years of work, the bill runs the risk of becoming the House Republican bill as soon as Camp introduces it, meaning it will be immediately politicized. It’ll take far more than the two congressional committees, he said, to get a bill passed.

“If we don’t get the administration engaged…it’s just not going to happen,” Tiberi said.

A congressional dilemma

But Sen. Rob Portman, R-Ohio, a member of the Senate Finance Committee, said Congress can’t afford not to move forward.

“It doesn’t make any sense for us to sit back, wring our hands and say, ‘it’s just too hard,’” he said. “We have to do it if we want to help American workers get better jobs with better pay and better benefits, because right now we have a situation where American companies are competing with one hand tied behind their back.”

He said that should Baucus be confirmed as ambassador, his likely replacement would be Sen. Ron Wyden, D-Ore. “He is also a strong advocate for tax reform, Portman said. “He assured me he’s going to push hard for tax reform.”

But Matt Yuskewich, a Columbus-based CPA with the Winterset Group, said he’s not optimistic. He said there’s been so much focus on the new health care law, which is administered by the Internal Revenue Service, that it’d be hard to shift to tax reform. “I don’t see it happening,” he said.

Too bad, he says, because the tax code is a mess. He can count at least five deductions aimed to help people pay for education and at least five for retirements. It’s confusing, and needs to be simplified, he said.

“If tax reform is done and simplification is one of the major themes, I think that helps everyone,” he said. “I just personally don’t hold out any great hope it’s going to happen.”

The agreements, like the concept, are broad. Both Democrats and Republicans agree that the corporate tax rate, at 35 percent, is too high; it’s the highest in the world. Both agree that eliminating loopholes and broadening the base would simplify the code.

Even that isn’t a clean fix, said Tiberi.

Can loopholes be eliminated?

He said that many businesses don’t pay the corporate tax rate, but instead operate as “pass-throughs” paying taxes on business income at the marginal level. The new health care law has put their tax rate at more than 40 percent, he said, which makes the debate a little less tidy.

And beyond that, there enough deductions and credits that some companies end up paying far less while others pay far more.

“You can’t have a small business paying almost 45 percent and a Fortune 500 company that’s competing around the world paying 25 percent,” he said. “Politically, that doesn’t work.”

The other area of consensus might be on eliminating loopholes, Vedder said.

“The tax code has become riddled with all sorts of special provisions over time and there’s virtue in simplicity,” he said. ‘Simplicity means getting rid of a lot of those things and having fewer exemptions.”

The rub there: Which loopholes do you eliminate? And which do you keep?

It’s hard to eliminate loopholes, said Sen. Sherrod Brown, D-Ohio, who is also a member of the Senate Finance Committee and who argues special interests will fight hard to keep their exemptions. “Because they were there for a reason.”

But Roberton Williams of the Tax Policy Center, a nonpartisan think tank devoted to tax policy, said a larger hangup may ultimately kill the prospects for tax reform: Disagreement over how much revenue the federal government should bring in.

While both sides appear to agree that corporate tax reform should be revenue-neutral, meaning any changes to the corporate tax code should be paid for by other changes, Republicans and Democrats disagree over whether to make changes to the individual tax code revenue-neutral as well. Republicans would like it to be; Democrats are more inclined to use reforms as revenue to help pay for federal programs.

“The issue comes down to how do you balance your budget in the first place,” Williams said. “Republicans say it all has to be on the spending side. Democrats say it can’t all be spending.”

Williams believes corporate tax reform could happen. He’s less bullish on individual tax reform.

Part of that comes down to public outcry. Because 90 percent of the public relies on a computer or professional to do their taxes, it’s become “a black box to us,” he said.

“If we had to do our own tax returns by hand, a lot more people would be saying ‘this is a mess,’” he said. “And we need to fix it.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in News

Mother abandoned 4-year-old boy found naked in dollar store, police say
Mother abandoned 4-year-old boy found naked in dollar store, police say

A Chicopee, Massachusetts, mother is accused of abandoning her 4-year-old son after he was found wandering without clothes Saturday afternoon. According to police, the boy was found alone in a Family Dollar store without clothes on. Police told WGGB-TV that the boy “may be autistic.”  The names of the boy and the mother were...
Rocking Horse to fill gap, serve Clark County kids with no dental care
Rocking Horse to fill gap, serve Clark County kids with no dental care

A local medical provider that serves low-income families in Springfield and Clark County will expand into dentistry soon. Rocking Horse Community Health Center intends to open a wing at its South Limestone Street center in September to offer dental care predominately to local children. The need is large in Clark County, Human Resources Director Marianne...
Nanny allegedly beats toddler with special needs in shocking video
Nanny allegedly beats toddler with special needs in shocking video

A nanny in Southern California is out of a job and facing charges after a video surfaced that allegedly shows her beating a toddler with special needs in her care. According to KCBS, the mother of the child, Dyanna Ko, installed a “nanny cam” app and caught the entire incident on video. She said she and her husband were at their other son&rsquo...
Shocking Facebook Live video shows aftermath of apparent drug overdose
Shocking Facebook Live video shows aftermath of apparent drug overdose

A frightening Facebook Live video from Massachusetts shows the life-and-death struggle that follows an apparent drug overdose. Posted just before 5:30 p.m. Wednesday in the Dorchester area of Boston, a man confronts a couple in a car about using drugs in his neighborhood. A needle is visible, lying in the woman’s lap. The woman wakes up...
Ohio Politics Today: State’s newest congressman looks back at first year, JobsOhio blunder as big as the moon
Ohio Politics Today: State’s newest congressman looks back at first year, JobsOhio blunder as big as the moon

Ohio Politics Today runs down the latest and best political stories around the state and recommended reads from around the web.  JobsOhio, the economic development program aimed at helping private businesses in the state, took out a page-sized ad in the widely read The Economist magazine, but left a noticeable mistake. In either a brilliant...
More Stories