Redistricting reform stalling in Ohio House


Despite calls for urgency from fellow Republicans, the Ohio House and its leader are pumping the breaks on the latest round of legislation that would overhaul how Ohio draws its election maps.

Senate President Keith Faber, R-Celina, said passing a plan that would require both Republicans and Democrats to sign off on congressional and state legislative districts is a top priority. The Ohio Senate approved that plan 32-1 in December. Senators reintroduced a bipartisan new version in the new legislative session that began this year.

“I’d expect the senate to act soon,” Faber said.

But the Ohio House, led by Speaker William Batchelder, R-Medina, is taking a more deliberate approach.

Rather than address the Senate plan directly in the legislature, Batchelder has decided that redistricting reform should be first taken up by the Constitutional Modernization Commission, a 32-member advisory body that is scheduled to meet 12 times this year. The commission has 10 years to recommend changes to Ohio’s constitution. Any changes would ultimately require the approval of the legislature.

Ohio Secretary of State Jon Husted, a Republican longtime advocate for redistricting reform, said it’s urgent that the legislature approve something by the end of this year or next. The closer it gets to 2021, when lines will be re-drawn again, the less likely it is that Republicans and Democrats in the General Assembly will cooperate to pass a reform measure, he said.

“The longer we wait, the harder it is to do this,” Husted said.

Despite Husted’s calls for haste, Batchelder’s decision to refer the issue to the commission will certainly slow it down. Batchelder said he has no timetable to act on the issue.

“Well, we’ve got to finish it in less than ten years. Other than that, no,” Batchelder said.

Batchelder said the commission will take a less partisan approach to redistricting reform than what the legislature can offer.

“I think the system succeeds now. But if there are people who feel differently, we can look at that,” he said.

State Rep. Mike Curtin, D-Columbus said by referring redistricting to the Constitutional Modernization Commission, Batchelder is making a “calculated chess move.” The issue has been so thoroughly studied that further review is unnecessary, he said.

“That to me looks like a recipe for putting the issue it in the deep freeze,” Curtin said.

Husted said if legislators try to stall redistricting reform, the public will end up going over their heads.

“People are tired of the way that government is dysfunctional, and they know that (redistricting reform) is one of the solutions of reclaiming a functioning government that gets things done and cares about the concerns of average people,” Husted said.

The latest round of partisan gridlock in Washington, D.C., illustrates the importance of drawing up more competitive districts, Husted said. The current winner-takes-all system leads to uncompetitive districts, where politicians are elected by partisan primary voters instead of more moderate general election voters.

It’s also led to a congressional map, drawn by Republicans in 2010, that despite Ohio’s status as a swing state, sent 12 Republicans and just four Democrats to Washington, Husted said.

A Democrat and union-backed coalition last year posed redistricting reform to voters via a ballot issue that was soundly rejected. But Husted said he thinks future efforts will be viewed as more bipartisan.

“Any politician who wants to stand in the way of commonsense reform will be seen as obstructionists, and those who are advocating for change will not be afraid to push ahead,” Husted said.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Ohio

Cool and sunny today, rain/snow mix possible Tuesday evening
Cool and sunny today, rain/snow mix possible Tuesday evening

Darke County remains under a flood warning until 8:45 a.m. today. Frigid morning Few showers Tuesday with rain/snow mix possible Quiet for Thanksgiving Today: It will be a bitter cold morning with temperatures in the 20s, said Storm Center 7 Meteorologist Kirstie Zontini. Skies will be clear with plenty of sunshine through the afternoon....
Lena Dunham backtracks defense of 'Girls' producer accused of raping teen
Lena Dunham backtracks defense of 'Girls' producer accused of raping teen

Lena Dunham did a major backtrack following backlash from her decision to defend a “Girls” producer who was recently accused of raping a teenage girl. Actress Aurora Perrineau filed a police report against producer Murray Miller, saying that he raped her in 2012 when she was 17 and he was 35 years old, according to The Wrap...
Charles Manson death: Notable reactions on social media
Charles Manson death: Notable reactions on social media

Charles Manson, the cult leader who led followers to kill actress Sharon Tate and six others, is dead at age 83, the California Department of Corrections said late Sunday. >> Read more trending news Here’s what public figures, celebrities, and other notable people and organizations were saying about his death:
Charles Manson dead at 83
Charles Manson dead at 83

Charles Manson, the notorious cult leader who led followers to murder several people in the 1960s, is dead, the California Department of Corrections said late Sunday. The 83-year-old died of “natural causes,” according to a CDCR news release. TMZ reported Wednesday that Manson’s health had been deteriorating steadily. He was...
These children’s Christmas wish lists include blankets, food 
These children’s Christmas wish lists include blankets, food 

Not all wishes are for the season’s hottest toy.  Some boys and girls are seeking more practical gifts: hygiene items, warm blankets and food. The charity group Things of My Very Own is hoping to help them.  The organization created tags, and children filled them out with specific items they would like.  “I want school snacks...
More Stories