Right-to-work divides GOP

Top GOP leaders come out against plan by members of own party.

Ohio Senate President Keith Faber struck a blow to members of his own party Wednesday, saying there is not enough GOP support behind legislation to make Ohio the 25th “right-to-work” state.

>> Which states have right-to-work laws?

After meeting with fellow Republicans Gov. John Kasich and House Speaker Bill Batchelder, Faber said pending GOP-led legislation that would end mandatory union membership or dues payments does not have the support of the General Assembly.

“We have an ambitious agenda focused on job creation and economic recovery, and right-to-work legislation is not on that list,” Faber said in statement. “The only purpose this discussion serves right now is to generate a bunch of breathless fundraising appeals from the Ohio Democratic Party.”

Faber’s strong comments came hours after Republican representatives Ron Maag of Lebanon and Kristina Roegner of Hudson introduced three bills that would end requirements that employees pay dues or fees to unions as a condition of employment.

Democrats and union leaders already began ramping up for a repeat of the Senate Bill 5 showdown of 2011, holding a small rally outside the Statehouse and a press conference that felt more like a pep rally, with dozens of union supporters standing behind a dozen House Democrats.

“Folks are ready to fight this fight again if we have to but we’d rather be able to work on a positive agenda, be able to talk about what we need to do to create jobs in Ohio, create a level playing field, create the chance for our kids to have great opportunities and stay in the state of Ohio,” said Rep. Debbie Phillips, D-Albany.

Senate Bill 5 would have put curbs on the collective bargaining rights of public employees.

House GOP spokesman Mike Dittoe told the Dayton Daily News the issue was not one put forward by Batchelder, R-Medina, or the Republican caucus.

But at least 16 GOP representatives signed onto the bill including two in leadership positions — Reps. Jim Buchy of Greenville and John Adams of Sidney. A citizen-led constitutional amendment also is still in the works.

Current state and federal laws allow employees to opt out of union dues, but they must pay a “fair share” fee to cover the costs of collective bargaining, representing employees in grievance cases and other activity directly related to employee benefits. Each of the bills introduced Wednesday would end the requirement to pay fair share fees, which do not go toward political contributions.

Maag said right-to-work would make Ohio more competitive with other states, including neighboring Michigan and Indiana, which enacted right-to-work laws last year. He admitted Ohio currently leads those states in many economic indicators, but he said that doesn’t mean that will always be the case.

“From my perspective, this is not anti-union,” Maag said. “I support unions, I support the individual’s rights. The difference is the individual now has the right whether they want to belong to any organization.”

James Winship, executive director of the Miami Valley AFL-CIO, said right-to-work legislation would produce a similar outcome as Senate Bill 5, which was overwhelmingly rejected by voters in 2011.

Ohio voters also rejected a right-to-work ballot issue in 1958.

“The labor unions are just going to have to stick together,” Winship said. “It’s not so much about unions. It’s about the middle class, let’s be honest.”

Citing union data, Winship argued that the “poorest” states and the states with the highest worker fatality rates are ones that have adopted right-to-work laws.

Winship, who also heads the Dayton-based International Union of Electronic Workers-Communication Workers of America Local 775, said union elections are overseen by the National Labor Relations Board. If workers don’t want union involvement, he said, they’re free to vote against it.

He summed up the goal of right-to-work legislation as “rich people who don’t want regular people to have a voice.”

John Heitmann, a University of Dayton history professor recognized as an authority on the U.S. auto industry, said new auto assembly sites in recent years have been put in Southern states with right-to-work laws long in place.

In January, Nissan said it would move assembly work from Japan to Canton, Miss. Mercedes-Benz said in March it will build a $70 million automotive parts staging facility at an existing plant in Vance, Ala. The plant will have 500 workers. Last month, Toyota said it will build the Lexus ES 350 at its Georgetown, Ky. plant, investing $360 million and creating 750 jobs starting in 2015.

Honda has thrived in Ohio since the late 1970s with more than 13,000 workers, but its workforce is not unionized.

“All you have to do is look at where the new car factories are being set up,” Heitmann said.

He added, however, that while right-to-work laws — or other factors — may open doors to new jobs, those jobs may not offer living wages. “Will they be jobs that pay the kinds of wages that historically we’ve come to expect from manufacturing?” he said.

Kasich, who is up for re-election next year, has said that right-to-work is not a priority of his. But as word of the legislation surfaced this week, Democrats quickly attempted to tie it to Kasich, an indication that another SB 5-like battle could occur if right-to-work became law.

After SB 5 was defeated, Kasich’s approval ratings plummeted.

Right-to-work states (Back to top)

Alabama, 1953

Arizona, 1946

Arkansas, 1944

Florida, 1943

Georgia, 1947

Idaho, 1985

Indiana, 2012

Iowa, 1947

Kansas, 1958

Louisiana, 1976

Michigan, 2012

Mississippi, 1954

Nebraska, 1947

Nevada, 1951

North Carolina, 1947

North Dakota, 1947

Oklahoma, 2001

South Carolina, 1954

South Dakota, 1946

Tennessee, 1947

Texas, 1993

Utah, 1955

Virginia, 1947

Wyoming, 1963

Source: National Conference of State Legislatures (Back to top)

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Politics

Clark County to spend $140K for consultant for combined 9-1-1 center
Clark County to spend $140K for consultant for combined 9-1-1 center

Clark County will spend $140,000 to hire a consultant to oversee the process of creating a unified countywide 9-1-1 dispatch center. Clark County commissioners voted unanimously this week to hire Fairfax, Va.-based Federal Engineering Inc. to help it transition from its current location at the Clark County Jail to the Springview Government Center....
Should Springfield ban smoking in cars with kids?
Should Springfield ban smoking in cars with kids?

A smoking ban in cars with children in Springfield could be problematic because it would only be in effect in the city limits, local leaders said, but they’re willing to talk about it. The city of Honolulu sparked a national debate on Oct. 18 when the city’s council voted unanimously to enact a ban on smoking and use of electronic cigarettes...
Springfield replaces 14,000-pound water valve from the 1920s
Springfield replaces 14,000-pound water valve from the 1920s

City workers removed a 14,000-pound water valve that was nearing 100 years old this week and replaced it with a new one. The valve on Lexington Avenue may have been part of the original water line, Springfield City Director Chris Moore said. Workers were able to get the valve out and replaced in one day. READ: Springfield medical marijuana ban ends...
O’Neill’s boast of sexual liaisons brings calls for his resignation
O’Neill’s boast of sexual liaisons brings calls for his resignation

A Facebook post touting his sexual exploits with “50 very attractive females” Friday had colleagues expressing shock and political opponents calling for Ohio Supreme Court Justice Bill O’Neill to resign.   “I condemn in no uncertain terms Justice O’Neill’s Facebook post. No words can convey my shock,&rdquo...
Hatch to Sherrod Brown: ‘Don’t spew this stuff at me’
Hatch to Sherrod Brown: ‘Don’t spew this stuff at me’

Sen. Sherrod Brown and Senate Finance Committee Chairman Orrin Hatch are garnering attention today for a yelling match they had last night at a hearing over the tax reform bill working its way through the Senate. Hatch, a Utah Republican, took umbrage at comments by Brown saying the tax bill will help the rich at the expense of the poor. &ldquo...
More Stories