Bills targeting Internet cafes advance

Business owners say prize limits will shut them down.


State lawmakers moved closer Tuesday to shutting down hundreds of Internet sweepstakes cafes operating in Ohio.

Two bills are headed to floor votes as early as today: One would essentially ban the storefront gaming centers and one would extend the moratorium on new cafes and strengthen reporting requirements.

Both bills have already passed one chamber and were assured speedy approval when Senate President Keith Faber, R-Celina, pledged in April the Senate would pass both by June.

In a 7-4 vote, the Senate State Government Oversight and Reform Committee approved House Bill 7, which would limit prize payouts to less than $10 and require cafes to register with the Ohio Attorney General’s office. Cafe owners said the prize limit would force them to close their doors. The bill passed the House in March in a bipartisan vote, 66-29.

Committee chairman Sen. Dave Burke, R-Marysville, said he expects the bill to clear the Senate. Burke said he had visited a cafe and did not have a negative experience there, but that doesn’t mean cafes are legal.

“This thing’s an onion and we’ve crafted what we believe to be the best solution,” Burke said after the vote. “Is it the best solution? The judicial process will tell us.”

Lawmakers did not change the bill, despite requests from proponents to add an emergency clause. Emergency legislation takes effect immediately, without the 90-day grace period, and is not subject to referendum. Adding an emergency clause requires two-thirds of the vote in each chamber.

Without an emergency clause, the well-funded industry could back a referendum for the November 2014 ballot. Ohioans gave the green light to four casinos in a 2009 ballot initiative.

Internet cafes sell phone cards or other products that can be used to win prizes by playing slots-like games on computer terminals. Cafe owners say they offer entertainment for a largely elderly clientele and boost the economy by paying sales tax on their products. Law enforcement officials say the cafes are rife with criminal activity including money laundering.

Cafe owners and employees filled the Senate hearing room Tuesday evening to plea with lawmakers one more time not to close down the industry and eliminate what they estimate to be as many as 8,000 jobs.

“These customers rely on us on a daily basis for companionship and we’ve created that atmosphere in all of our establishments,” said Jody Spurrier, who manages a cafe in Alliance. Spurrier and a half dozen others told lawmakers the actions of a few bad apples do not speak for the whole industry.

Hours before the Senate committee vote, a House panel approved Senate Bill 115, sending it to a floor vote. The bill would extend the current moratorium on new cafes set to expire June 30 one more year, requires more reporting data and establishes daily fines for non-compliance.

Florida banned the cafes last month, after a group claiming to operate cafes to benefit veterans’ causes was found to have pocketed most of the revenues. Law enforcement there arrested 57 people in connection to what was described as “illegal casinos.”


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

Hundreds flock to Springfield vigil to stand against hate, racism
Hundreds flock to Springfield vigil to stand against hate, racism

More than 250 people attended a vigil in downtown Springfield in light of recent events in Charlottesville, Virginia, that saw three people die amid violent protests. RELATED: Springfield mayor speaks out about Charlottesville violence Several local leaders from different backgrounds spoke out about the hatred seen during the protest — and stressed...
Springfield mayor speaks out about Charlottesville violence
Springfield mayor speaks out about Charlottesville violence

Springfield Mayor Warren Copeland spoke out about the violence in Charlottesville, Va., last weekend and also said the city will enforce its anti-discrimination ordinance if similar actions were to occur here. A Unite the Right rally was held Saturday morning in the Virginia city where a statue of Confederate Gen. Robert E. Lee has long been a point...
New Carlisle: Income tax ballot issue may lead to ‘humongous’ cuts
New Carlisle: Income tax ballot issue may lead to ‘humongous’ cuts

An initiative petition filed with the Clark County Board of Elections could potentially devastate New Carlisle’s finances, city leaders say, but the woman behind it says residents shouldn’t have to pay income taxes twice. Residents can be taxed both by the city where they work and, if it’s a different, where they live. Many cities...
Ohio country band booted from Lee Brice concert, rib fest after Charlottesville Facebook post
Ohio country band booted from Lee Brice concert, rib fest after Charlottesville Facebook post

Rodney Parker and Liberty Beach, a country band from Sylvania, was booted from Northwest Ohio Rib Off and an opening slot for Nashville star Lee Brice after complaints over a Facebook post. Singer Rodney Parker, on his personal Facebook page, posted Tuesday about the Charlottesville, Va., protests. The Toledo Blade, which sponsors the Rib Off...
Park Layne park called unsafe, township trustees say complaints rare
Park Layne park called unsafe, township trustees say complaints rare

A Park Layne mom said she won’t bring her kids to Raynor Park because she believes its unsafe but Bethel Twp. trustees said they rarely get complaints about it. Raynor Park off Fyffe Drive is a popular spot, said Bethel Twp. Trustee Nancy Brown, especially during the fall for sports such as soccer and football. “It’s clean, it&rsquo...
More Stories