breaking news

Police, state troopers investigating accident on U.S. 40, east of Springfield

Bill to ban red-light, speed cameras advances


A bill that would shut off red light and speed cameras throughout Ohio took a step forward Tuesday.

The Ohio House Transportation, Public Safety and Homeland Security Committee voted 9-4 to refer to the full Ohio House a bipartisan bill that would largely ban automated traffic cameras, which currently operate in 14 Ohio communities.

Co-sponsor state Rep. Ron Maag, R-Lebanon, said he thinks the bill has the votes to clear the Ohio House Wednesday. It would still need approval from the Ohio Senate and a signature from Ohio Gov. John Kasich before it would become law.

Maag and co-sponsor Rep. Dale Mallory, D-Cincinnati, said the bill was inspired by the case of Elmwood Place, a Hamilton County village of roughly 2,200 people that issued $1.5 million worth of automated speeding tickets during a period of six months until a Hamilton County judge shut them down last March.

The committee approved a late amendment that would allow speed cameras to be set up and operated in school zones during school hours, as long as a police officer is physically present to monitor the device and make sure it’s working properly. Otherwise, House Bill 69 would completely shut off the cameras statewide as they exist today.

Those in favor of the ban say the cameras circumvent due process and are just a way for communities to make money.

Maag said allowing some communities to treat speeding or red-light running as a civil offense, as the cameras do, while allowing others to treat the same actions as a crime, is unfair.

“The citizens of Ohio are not being treated equally, and that is the most important thing,” Maag said.

But police officers and public safety officials from Dayton, Springfield, Trotwood, West Carrollton and Columbus, which all have automated traffic cameras, testified against the ban, saying the cameras reduce crashes, free up police resources for more serious crimes and raise revenue for cities that run them.

Police representatives also said that legislators shouldn’t shut the whole system down just because of concerns with one small community.

George Speaks, deputy public safety director for Columbus, said legislators should instead impose a set of regulations that would require all municipalities with automated camera systems to follow the same set of rules.

A ban, Speaks said, “would undoubtedly increase deaths, increase property damage and increase crashes throughout the state of Ohio.”

State Rep. Ross McGregor, R-Springfield, who voted against the ban, said he favors a regulatory approach rather than an outright ban.

“We have technology, we will continue to develop technology and law enforcement should certainly be able to continue to utilize technology to help protect our citizens,” McGregor said.

Red-light and speed cameras in Trotwood pay for the salaries of two and a half officers there, said police Capt. John Porter. If a ban goes through, the city might either have to lay them off or ask voters to pass a levy, he said.

Porter said crashes in Trotwood have dropped 35 percent since the cameras were installed in 2005.

“I’m not satisfied with the direction this is going,” Porter said following the vote. “If this were to go all the way through, it’s going to have a drastic effect not only on the city of Trotwood, but on all the municipalities.”

The ban would cost the communities that operate them, ranging from the thousands to the millions.

Dayton collected about $2.4 million from camera citations in 2012. Dayton keeps about $55 of the $85 civil citation and sends the rest to Phoenix-based RedFlex Traffic Systems. RedFlex also operates cameras in Hamilton, Middletown, Springfield, Trotwood and West Carrollton.

Springfield issued 6,638 citations in 2012 and generated $287,784 from paid tickets. Hamilton uses speed cameras mounted on an SUV and 20,782 citations were issued between March 31, 2010 and Jan. 31, 2013, generating $958,636. In the small Butler County community of New Miami, police have given more than 9,700 violations since installing two mobile speed cameras in the village Oct. 1 and collected more than $210,000.

Middletown’s 14 red-light cameras — located at eight “high accident” intersections in the city — generated $186,580 for the city’s general fund in 2012.

Staff Writer Jackie Borchardt contributed to this report



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

Springfield mayor speaks out about Charlottesville violence
Springfield mayor speaks out about Charlottesville violence

Springfield Mayor Warren Copeland spoke out about the violence in Charlottesville, Va., last weekend and also said the city will enforce its anti-discrimination ordinance if similar actions were to occur here. A Unite the Right rally was held Saturday morning in the Virginia city where a statue of Confederate Gen. Robert E. Lee has long been a point...
New Carlisle: Income tax ballot issue may lead to ‘humongous’ cuts
New Carlisle: Income tax ballot issue may lead to ‘humongous’ cuts

An initiative petition filed with the Clark County Board of Elections could potentially devastate New Carlisle’s finances, city leaders say, but the woman behind it says residents shouldn’t have to pay income taxes twice. Residents can be taxed both by the city where they work and, if it’s a different, where they live. Many cities...
Ohio country band booted from Lee Brice concert, rib fest after Charlottesville Facebook post
Ohio country band booted from Lee Brice concert, rib fest after Charlottesville Facebook post

Rodney Parker and Liberty Beach, a country band from Sylvania, was booted from Northwest Ohio Rib Off and an opening slot for Nashville star Lee Brice after complaints over a Facebook post. Singer Rodney Parker, on his personal Facebook page, posted Tuesday about the Charlottesville, Va., protests. The Toledo Blade, which sponsors the Rib Off...
Park Layne park called unsafe, township trustees say complaints rare
Park Layne park called unsafe, township trustees say complaints rare

A Park Layne mom said she won’t bring her kids to Raynor Park because she believes its unsafe but Bethel Twp. trustees said they rarely get complaints about it. Raynor Park off Fyffe Drive is a popular spot, said Bethel Twp. Trustee Nancy Brown, especially during the fall for sports such as soccer and football. “It’s clean, it&rsquo...
Flight blocked from landing in Indy due to VP visit sent to Dayton
Flight blocked from landing in Indy due to VP visit sent to Dayton

A plane low on fuel traveling from Chicago to Indianapolis Friday was forced to land in Dayton since Vice President Mike Pence’s plane was on the runway there. According to RTV6 in Indianapolis, the flight was in Indianapolis air space and was denied permission to land at Indianapolis International Airport. Air traffic controllers said United...
More Stories