AP enrages copy editors with 'more than = over' style change


Warning: nerd alert! The world of journalism has been shaken to its core — or at least the world of copy editors — after the Associated Press Stylebook received a controversial update.

The American Copy Editor's Society is holding its National Conference in Las Vegas this weekend, and as part of the festivities, the AP editors talked about some of the upcoming changes to the Stylebook — including the canonization of selfie and the hyphenation of Wal-Mart.

But the editors really dropped a bombshell when they announced that "over" is now interchangeable with "more than" when referring to numbers. So you could say @APStylebook has "over" 167,000 Twitter followers, or "more than" 167,000 Twitter followers, and you'd be right either way.

>> Read more trending stories

The rule used to favor "more than" rather than "over," but the editors said "overwhelming usage" of both terms prompted the change. 

Those attending the conference didn't take the news well. A reporter from The Poynter Institute noted the announcement "elicited a gasp" from the assembled copy editors.

And reactions on Twitter bordered on hysteria, to say the least. While a few people defended the new rule, most of the amusing commentary about the decision was a mixture of anguish, rage, and despair. (Via Twitter / @yelvington@DOBIEST@JonZlock)

A couple of nerds even started replacing song lyrics to mock the new ambiguity. "More than the river and through the woods" — doesn't really have the same ring to it, does it? (Via Twitter / @Marley_Jay,@emfred)

The Atlantic explains the hubbub: "The insistence that over is not synonymous with more than is drilled into the eager skulls of first-year journalism students everywhere. ... [It] was stylistic conservatism that could be lorded over the uninitiated."

But for all the fury about the rule change, we have to ask: why is this even a thing?

Grammar Girl notes the preference for "more than" started with the style quirks of an 1877 newspaper editor and spread from there. "The majority of style pros attribute the objection to tradition and not actual grammar rules."

And the Columbia Journalism Review notes "over" has been used in dictionaries to refer to numerical quantities since the 14th century. "All those centuries of precedent would seem to make 'over' unexceptionable. Better still, natural."

Oh, and in case you were wondering, "under" and "less than" are now synonymous as well. As for us, we're more than over this controversy.

See more at newsy.com.  



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Nation World

Stabbing victim flown to hospital; Springfield crews search for suspect
Stabbing victim flown to hospital; Springfield crews search for suspect

Springfield police are searching for a suspect after a man was stabbed in the chest, according to Springfield Sgt. Michael Curtis. Crews were dispatched to the 1100 block of Water Street around 11:40 p.m. Friday on a report of a stabbing.  Officers arrived to find the victim coherent and unable to recall the events leading up to the stabbing,...
Pennsylvania man accused of urinating on toys on store shelf
Pennsylvania man accused of urinating on toys on store shelf

A Pennsylvania man is accused of urinating on toys and other items in a store.  Police said David Pacoe, 74, was captured on surveillance video urinating on a shelf inside Playthings, Etc. in Butler on Nov. 2.  “It's not very nice at all and it's a toy store. You shouldn't have to worry about having security and guards or...
Ohio woman burned by coffee in break room spat
Ohio woman burned by coffee in break room spat

An Ohio woman suffered “significant burns” when another woman threw a cup of hot coffee on her in a break room at the YWCA, according to a Dayton Police report.  Officers and a medic were dispatched to the YWCA in Dayton at 5:25 p.m. Thursday on a report of an aggravated assault.  The two women involved in the altercation...
Louisiana veteran entertains motorists with saxophone
Louisiana veteran entertains motorists with saxophone

A Vietnam War veteran has become a fixture for music lovers in his Louisiana town. Donald Givens plays saxophone for several hours daily in his gazebo at his Monroe residence. His yard is located near the corner of two overpasses and commuters can listen to his daily jam sessions, the News-Star reported. Strangers pull up to his home and ask Givens...
Stolen Van Halen guitar returned to Hard Rock Cafe in Texas
Stolen Van Halen guitar returned to Hard Rock Cafe in Texas

A guitar owned by rock ’n’ roll legend Eddie Van Halen worth more than $100,000 was recovered Friday, hours after it was stolen from a Hard Rock Cafe in San Antonio, Texas, KSAT reported. The guitar, nicknamed “Frankenstrat,” had been reported stolen around 1 a.m. Friday. It was returned later in the day, but it is unclear how...
More Stories