You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.


  • ePAPER

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and interactive features. Starting at just 99c for 8 weeks.


Welcome to

Your source for Clark and Champaign counties’ hometown news. All readers have free access to a limited number of stories every month.

If you are a News-Sun subscriber, please take a moment to login for unlimited access.

Township dismisses fire chief

Clark County chief says process was unfair.

The fire chief here was fired late Monday night in a unanimous decision after trustees found him guilty of failing to follow several of their directives and a portion of the Ohio Administrative Code.

Their decision during a public hearing requested by Mad River Twp.-Enon Fire and EMS Department Chief David Leist was in connection with gross neglect of duty and other allegations.

Leist, who already has a lawsuit pending against trustees for a previous suspension that they later reversed, said the process was unfair.

On Monday night, trustees found him guilty of four of six charges, including, per trustee directive: failing to remove from the schedule those personnel who’d not been given proper training and orientation; failing to provide training and access to current policies and place in each personnel’s folder written documentation of the training; and failing to take at least four or more paid on-call shifts per month.

He was also found guilty of not following state code when he failed to file changes in personnel with Ohio Board of Pharmacy within a specified time frame.

Trustees acted as the judge in the administrative hearing. Clark County Assistant Prosecutor Andrew Pickering prosecuted the case, and Leist’s attorney, Mark J. Bamberger, acted as the defender.

Last fall, Leist was the subject of an informal investigation by another township’s fire chief that resulted in Leist’s administrative leave and suspension. He was later reinstated with back pay without a hearing because no specific charges had been filed as required by the Ohio Revised Code.

Leist has a pending defamation lawsuit in court in connection with that first investigation. That suit demands monetary compensation and individually names as defendants Mad River Twp. trustees Joe Catanzaro, Kathy Estep and Robert McClure Jr. plus the township and the fire department.

In the most recent investigation and the one that led to his firing, specific charges were levied against Leist by Cincinnati-based attorney and labor consultant Kelly Babcock, a shareholder and account manager with the same firm the township contracted with to review and update its police manuals.

It was a process that was unfair and unjust, Leist said.

“I’m upset, but I’m more hurt due to the inconsistencies of the board’s investigative procedures,” Leist said. “When you face your prosecutor, your judge, your jury, the ones that brought the charges up against you, I don’t see where you’d have due process.”

Leist and Bamberger said they would discuss an appeal but had made no decision on the matter. “As far as I’m concerned, we just gained additional evidence that we’re going to use in our civil case,” Bamberger said.

Bamberger formally objected to the proceeding before the hearing.

“We believe it is an overt and inherent conflict of interest that the board of trustees here have a judgmental and decision-making role, given the fact that they are currently named as defendants of a civil action … It is, to put it lightly, impossible for these trustees to judge objectively the evidence that they are about to hear,” he said.

He requested they recuse themselves, but

trustees chose to proceed.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Community News

President Trump’s Hollywood star vandalized again
President Trump’s Hollywood star vandalized again

For the second time in less than six months, President Donald Trump’s Hollywood Walk of Fame star has been vandalized, the New York Daily News reported. In October, a 52-year-old man destroyed the star with a pickax and sledgehammer. This time, the Hollywood star was defaced with a black marker and an obscene phrase, according to a photograph...
Highs in the mid-70s today, showers coming Thursday
Highs in the mid-70s today, showers coming Thursday

Tuesday will be another nice day today with more sunshine and warmer temperatures. Warming trend continues through Wednesday Showers, maybe storms Thursday Wet weekend ahead RELATED: County-by-County Forecasts  TODAY: Highs will be in the middle 70s. A few more clouds on Tuesday compared to Monday, but overall it should be pleasant....
Ludacris’ rap of ‘Llama Llama Red Pajama’ is classic
Ludacris’ rap of ‘Llama Llama Red Pajama’ is classic

It’s a bedtime story full of fun llama drama, thanks to hip-hop artist Ludacris. >> Read more trending news The singer took the Anna Dewdney’s classic “Llama Llama Red Pajama” to a new level when he rapped the book’s text on Power 106’s “The Cruz Show,” the Huffington Post reported...
Penelope Cruz gets Julia Roberts to lip-sync iconic song
Penelope Cruz gets Julia Roberts to lip-sync iconic song

Julia Roberts relived a scene from her iconic 1997 movie “My Best Friend’s Wedding” thanks to some prodding by actress Penelope Cruz, ETonline reported.  >> Read more trending news At Wednesday’s Lancome's Stars & Wonders gala in Monaco, California, one of the bands covered Dionne Warwick’s 1967 song ...
Florida man steals woman’s panties, leaves them on porch with note
Florida man steals woman’s panties, leaves them on porch with note

A Florida man allegedly stole woman’s underwear from her bedroom and left her other pairs on her property along with handwritten notes, deputies said.  >> Read more trending news Isitro Lee Sanches, 58, of Panama City, was identified as the alleged panty thief after the woman’s boyfriend caught Sanches inside their home, the...
More Stories