Springfield considers charter review

Some say mandatory reviews can produce bad results.


The city could create a review committee to examine possible changes to the Springfield charter.

The review committee, proposed by Commissioner Dan Martin, would recommend possible changes to the city’s charter, providing guidance on items that could be good to address, Martin said. Any changes would have to be approved by a three-fourths vote of the city commission to be put on the ballot for voters.

“It’s not mandatory that you accept these changes, but it gives you ideas, it gives you some things to think about,” Martin said. “I just think since it’s something we haven’t done in awhile, I think it makes sense to either do it or put some sort authority out there where we have a process for doing it.”

The charter is like the city’s constitution, Martin said, and “every so often it makes sense to have some citizen input” on possible changes that are outdated.

Martin made the proposal at last month’s annual retreat, and it was established by commission as a goal for this year.

The preliminary proposal by Martin would allow the review committee to meet every seven years. The committee would be composed of 11 members with each commissioner making two recommendations and the final member being selected by city staff. The committee would make a final report no later than nine months after the committee is established.

“It’s basically a consulting board that looks at things, gives some feedback and develops some potential amendments,” Martin said. “There’s probably some small things that need to be fixed, that seem dated. There might be some out-of-the-box ideas that people have, too.”

Other cities in Ohio, Martin said, have a provision review their charter over time. Newark, for example, reviews its charter every five years.

“There’s usually some effort to include a periodic charter review and have a committee to recommend changes to the commission on possible charter changes,” Martin said.

Martin, who was re-elected for his fifth term last year, said he’s unsure if the city had “systematically reviewed” the city’s charter.

“It’s something we haven’t done in recent memory,” Martin said.

Mayor Warren Copeland said the city has suggested specific changes to the charter but hasn’t performed a full review.

City Commissioner Kevin O’Neill supported the idea.

“It’s good for checks and balances,” O’Neill said. “The citizens need to have somewhere to go.”

O’Neill said the charter has withstood the test of time, but likes the idea of having somebody from the outside take a look at it.

The review committee process can lead to citizens believing they need to do something, said Law Director Jerry Strozdas. He believes “institutionalizing” charter review can lead to consequences commissioners “may not intend.” Strozdas was previously the law director for New Carlisle, which has a review committee at least every eight years.

“(The committee) feels they need to put together recommendations and whether it’s broken or not, they want to give you fixes,” Strozdas said.

City Manager Jim Bodenmiller believes it’s a good idea to review the charter, but said he’s spoken with other city managers who say the review committee can create fighting amongst citizens every five to 10 years.

The city’s charter was originally adopted by citizens in 1913 and went into effect in 1914. Changes were approved by citizens in 1965, according to the charter. The most recent changes were adopted by citizens in 2002, which included the direct election of the mayor.

New Carlisle performed its most recent charter review last year. The committee is composed of five citizens and reviews the charter, then brings back recommendations for the city council. The review produced several recommended changes that were approved by the council, including making the charter viewable online and changing requirements for the position of city manager, among others.

The changes, however, were rejected by voters last November.

“It gives you fresh eyes, people who don’t maybe work in the government day-to-day,” said New Carlisle city manager Kim Jones. “You can bring in outside opinions and thoughts.”


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Community News

Sunshine today, warmer this weekend
Sunshine today, warmer this weekend

Warmer temperatures expected this weekend Chance for rain returns Sunday into Monday Snow possible Tuesday Today: More sunshine is expected today as temperatures climb above freezing, said Storm Center 7 Meteorologist Brett Collar. It will be a nice day, although still cool, with temperatures topping out in the mid to upper 30s this afternoon...
Texas' 'Tourniquet Killer' executed via lethal injection
Texas' 'Tourniquet Killer' executed via lethal injection

Houston’s “Tourniquet Killer” became the nation’s first prisoner executed in 2018, KTRK reported Thursday. Anthony Allen Shores, 55, who admitted to killing a woman and three girls in the 1980s and ‘90s, was executed by lethal injection, the Texas Department of Criminal Justice said. Shores received his nickname because...
'Brace': Passengers have rough, scary landing at Dallas airport
'Brace': Passengers have rough, scary landing at Dallas airport

Flight attendants routinely instruct passengers on emergency procedures before a plane takes off, and it is a necessary but tedious monologue. However, passengers on an American Airlines flight from Phoenix to Dallas were paying close attention Wednesday, when they were told to brace for impact as their plane made an emergency landing because of mechanical...
Drone saves 2 swimmers at Australian beach
Drone saves 2 swimmers at Australian beach

The Little Ripper turned out to be a lifesaver for two Australian swimmers caught in churning surf. Australian lifeguards were testing a new drone during a practice session at a beach in New South Wales when they received a call about two swimmers caught in 10-foot swells, according to Surf Life Saving New South Wales and The New York Times...
Rapper Kodak Black arrested in South Florida
Rapper Kodak Black arrested in South Florida

Rapper Kodak Black was arrested Thursday in South Florida, accused of grand theft of a firearm, possession of marijuana and child neglect, the Broward County Sheriff’s Office said. Black, 20, whose legal name is Dieuson Octave, also faces two counts of possession of a weapon by a felon and two counts of probation violation, the Sheriff&rsquo...
More Stories