You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to SpringfieldNewsSun.com

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.

GREAT REASONS TO SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

  • IN-DEPTH REPORTING
  • INTERACTIVE STORYTELLING
  • NEW TOPICS & COVERAGE
  • ePAPER
X

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and interactive features. Starting at just 99c for 8 weeks.

X

Welcome to SpringfieldNewsSun.com

Your source for Clark and Champaign counties’ hometown news. All readers have free access to a limited number of stories every month.

If you are a News-Sun subscriber, please take a moment to login for unlimited access.

Petraeus aide: WWII the exception, not the rule

D-Day program Thursday at Heritage Center


Retired U.S. Army Col. Peter R. Mansoor will be fresh off a tour of World War II sites and brimming with information when he presents “A Remembrance of D-Day” at 7 p.m. Thursday at the Clark County Heritage Center.

But Mansoor, the Raymond E. Mason Chair in Military History at the Mershon Center for Strategic Studies, says that after celebrating on the anniversary of the invasion, those who want to be prepared to think about current American strategic interest would be better off retreating from the Normandy coast.

“People look back on (World War II), perhaps, too fondly,” said Mansoor, an Ohio State University professor.

“As messy as the ending was — it lead to the Cold War,” he said, World War II “was a clear-cut victory, and most wars don’t end that way.”

Nor, he said, do they often end with the sense of the moral certainty that emerged after Allied forces discovered the Nazi death camps.

A 26-year Army veteran, Mansoor has the experience to back up his opinions.

The Yale Library of Military History soon will release his book “Surge: My Journey with General David Petraeus and the Remaking of the Iraq War.”

He also is the author of “Baghdad at Sunrise: A Brigade Commander’s War in Iraq” and organized a conference titled “Hybrid Warfare: The Struggle of Military Forces to Adapt to Complex Opponents.”

While serving in Iraq, he said, “One thing I saw was the difficulty of these endeavors.”

“You realize how strong foreign cultures are,” he said, and that making headway is “very difficult unless you find viable partners.”

Mansoor said he considers circumstances in Afghanistan such an obstacle that the prospects of accomplishing any lasting good there is “a bridge too far.”

“In that war, I just think we’re fueling the corruption which is part of the huge problem that prevents resolution to the conflict.”

He is wary of U.S. involvement in Syria for the same reasons.

“Is there a good opposition that is secular and democratic and will work with the United States?” he asked. “I haven’t seen any indication of that.”

With the inevitability in all foreign wars that American forces will be leaving, he said, “to change the local politics and the local attitudes through the barrel of a gun or (even) good works” is very difficult.

“We’ve had a tendency since 9/11 to overuse the military instruments of our national power, and in the process we’ve lost a little of our moral authority,” one of the other important instruments, Mansoor said. “My theory is that war should always be a last resort.”

One reason is obvious.

“It’s an endeavor in which both sides have input,” he said. “And you can plan to fight a short, sharp technologically based conflict and end up in a 10-year counterinsurgency effort.”

In invading Iraq on spurious strategic grounds, he said, “we lost 5,000 soldiers and lots of treasure for very little if any gain.”

That doesn’t take into account “north of 100,000” Iraqi civilians.

Although a certain segment of Iraq saw its conditions improve, Mansoor said, the war “plunged the country into a generation of bloodshed that continues today.”

Mansoor said there’s a lot of history to be unpacked regarding President George W. Bush’s administration and its justification for its aggressive policies. But he’s also critical of those who opposed the surge, and of President Barak Obama for his withdrawal strategy.

“Though the war was started for dubious strategic reasons and was terribly executed for the first three years, that doesn’t mean you just give up,” Mansoor said.

“I think (the surge) put Iraq on a path to a political solution to the conflict,” he said, but Obama “blew it by not supporting the winner of the election in 2010.”

Mansoor said that that even if they don’t seem as dramatic to the public, the nation’s “soft power or moral authority,” combined with “the diplomatic levers of power and the economic levers at our disposal” are the more standard and effective tools of foreign policy.

“Certainly force plays a part in diplomacy,” he said. “If you don’t have force to back up your commitments, they’re pretty idle.”

“When you get beyond that, the military is very good and can be used to strengthen other nations’ militaries” by providing advice and training, he said. “It helps other nations. It strengthens other nations and lets them fight their own conflicts. It does them very cheaply and at very little cost and risk to U.S. forces as well.”

Mansoor also says that military willingness to carry out any mission that arises should be taken with a grain of salt by policy makers considering options.

The military “has the attitude that given a mission, they’re going to do their best to accomplish it,” he said. “But there’s a sense that the military can do more than it can.”

And that may be a sense that’s strengthened by America’s nostalgia for World War II.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Community News

Dad learns to walk again for his daughters' sake after doctors said he was paralyzed
Dad learns to walk again for his daughters' sake after doctors said he was paralyzed

Seven months after doctors told him he’d never be able to use his legs again, a man stood up and walked out of a rehabilitation center with his two young daughters at his side. Cole Thomas, of Rochelle, Illinois, told “Today” that he shattered a vertebra in a September 2016 car crash. “I realized I was hurt very badly,&rdquo...
Poor Will’s Clark County Almanack: Hummingbirds arrive!
Poor Will’s Clark County Almanack: Hummingbirds arrive!

Stay together, Learn the flowers, Go light. — Gary Snyder, from “For the Children” The Almanack Horoscope Moon Time: Mock Orange Moon waxes throughout the period, entering its second quarter at 9:42 p.m. on May 2. Rising in the morning and setting in the evening, this moon passes overhead in the afternoon. Sun Time: Late Spring is...
Disney workers ask company to fight for 500 Haitian refugees
Disney workers ask company to fight for 500 Haitian refugees

Union representatives speaking on behalf of 500 Haitian refugees working as Disney cast members in Central Florida are asking CEO Bob Iger to fight for them to stay in the U.S. The group is part of 50,000 refugees from the island nation who are living in the U.S. following the earthquake that ravaged the country in 2010. President Barack Obama gave...
Facebook Live video leads to suspect in woman's death
Facebook Live video leads to suspect in woman's death

A Facebook Live video led police to a suspect in the December 2016 death of a woman in a Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, neighborhood.  Isaiah Booker, 23, of Homestead, was charged Tuesday with criminal homicide, criminal attempted homicide, aggravated assault and persons not to possess a firearm.  The charges stem from the shooting death of 25-year-old...
Opinion: The ESPN we used to enjoy is dead and never coming back
Opinion: The ESPN we used to enjoy is dead and never coming back

The worst thing that ever happened to ESPN was the success of PTI. Shortly after Pardon The Interruption debuted in October 2001, the network set about trying to replicate it on every other show on the network. That has proven to be a disaster because nobody in Bristol gets the debate isn’t what makes that show great, it’s the debaters...
More Stories