OSHA investigating fatal Middletown silo accident


Two recent deaths because of engulfments in silos — one of them on an unregulated family-owned farm — has the Occupational Safety and Health Administration reinforcing safety practices.

Tim Taylor, of New Carlisle, died Tuesday night after he became buried in more than 8,000 pounds of fly ash, a substance used to make cement, inside a silo at Central Ready Mix, 4714 Oxford State Road.

Taylor, 39, who had worked at the company for 15 years, died from asphyxia and his death was ruled accidental, according to the Butler County Coroner’s Office.

Charles Groh, of Fairfield, was killed Monday in a similar incident on a Fairfield farm.

Groh, 72, also died from asphyxia and his death was accidental, according to the autopsy from the coroner’s office. OSHA has no jurisdiction to further investigate the incident because it occurred on a farm with less than 10 employees, according to Bill Wilkerson, area director of OSHA’s Cincinnati office.

In only takes seconds for silos filled with grains or other materials to become death traps when the contents cascade in a rush, asphyxiating or crushing the victims.

Because the product is being removed from the bottom, Wilkerson said “bridging” can occur, where false surfaces are created and workers can be pulled downward.

When that happens, he said, it’s like being caught in quicksand.

“They can be very dangerous,” he said.

Serious injuries and fatalities on farms have fallen, but the number of workers dying by entrapment in silos has remained stubbornly steady, reaching a record high in 2010, according to a Purdue University report.

“OSHA is working hard to change the ‘it won’t happen to me’ mindset,” said Nick Walters, OSHA Regional Administrator for six Midwestern states. “Grain handling injuries and deaths can be prevented if employers follow proper safety procedures.”

OSHA has worked with the Ohio State University to develop a grain safety training session as part of the 2012 OSU/OSHA Safety Day on Grain Safety and plans to do a presentation for the Grain Elevator and Processing Society later this year.

Recommended precautions are outlined in grain-handling standards issued by OSHA. Every time someone goes into a grain bin, machinery that helps move grain should be turned off. The person should wear a body harness so they can be pulled to safety. An observer should stand outside the bin ready to help if needed.

OSHA was last at the Middletown company in 2000 for an accident when it was called Moraine Materials, according to Wilkerson. The business was sold and changed names in 2011, he said.

On Tuesday night, representatives from the Butler County Technical Response Team were called in to assist Middletown firefighters in the rescue of Taylor. Randy Hanifen, manager of the group, said rescuing someone trapped inside a solo is difficult because with every move, there is a potential for them to fall further down.

Once it became apparent Taylor was dead, Hanifen said the goal was to protect the response team and make sure no one else got injured.

“We go from ‘risk a lot to save a lot’ to trying to recover the body,” he said.

Representatives from Central Ready Mix were unavailable for comment Wednesday, though several messages were left.

Wilkerson said it may take four to eight weeks before his agency reveals its final findings. Before they’re publicity announced, the company can appeal the findings, he said.



Next Up in Community News

For sale: ‘Scariest’ lodging in America, iconic Clown Motel
For sale: ‘Scariest’ lodging in America, iconic Clown Motel

The lobby is stuffed with clowns of all sorts. Like a scene from a circus, they are seemingly everywhere, even above the beds in each clown-themed room. After all, it is “The Clown Motel.” The iconic, albeit frightening to coulrophobes, lodging is up for sale, after 22 years owning it, Bob Perchetti is ready to sing a sad clown song and...
Bielski brother partisan celebrates 90th birthday
Bielski brother partisan celebrates 90th birthday

In his early years, Aron Bell of Palm Beach helped his brothers save more than 1,200 Jews escaping Nazis during World War II. Now, he gathers with friends and family to celebrate his 90th birthday. The story of the Bielski brothers has been translated into books, documentaries and a Hollywood film, “Defiance.” For three years, Aron...
Fisherman hooks great white from California pier
Fisherman hooks great white from California pier

A fisherman in California did not need a bigger rod and reel when he hooked a nearly 12-foot great white shark from a pier Sunday. Once he identified it as a white shark, which is protected, the fisherman cut it loose, according to KEYT. Video showed spectators and other fishermen congregate as the shark thrashed nearby, according to KEYT...
Bush’s recalls beans over defective cans
Bush’s recalls beans over defective cans

Bush Brothers and Company is voluntarily recalling certain varieties of beans because of defective cans that can leak or allow harmful bacteria to grow. Bush’s Brown Sugar Hickory Baked Beans, Country Style Baked Beans and Original Baked Beans in 28-ounce cans were recalled after an internal quality control check uncovered the issue. “We...
Chained dog dies trying to reach shade
Chained dog dies trying to reach shade

A 23-year-old South Carolina man has been arrested on animal cruelty charges after a chained dog wearing a belt as a collar choked to death trying to crawl to shade in his yard. Keon Torrence Gladden, of Great Falls, has been charged with one count of ill treatment of animals. A concerned neighbor called police to Gladden’s Walnut Street home...
More Stories