Ohio pension reforms would trim benefits costs

Public employees would have to work longer, contribute more.


COLUMBUS — A sweeping overhaul of public employee pensions in Ohio was proposed Tuesday and would require state workers, police, firefighters, teachers and others to work longer before retiring, contribute more to their pensions and accept less generous benefits.

Senate leaders from both parties said they’re ready to fast-track pension reform legislation. The move comes nearly three years after Ohio’s public employee retirement funds pitched reform plans to legislators.

Ohio’s five public retirement systems cover 1.7 million workers, retirees and beneficiaries and have $165 billion in combined investments. The systems also offer health care to retirees. The five systems are: Public Employees Retirement System, State Teachers Retirement System, Schools Employees Retirement System (nonteachers), Ohio Police and Fire Pension Fund and the Highway Patrol Retirement System.

Senate President Tom Niehaus, R-New Richmond, and Senate Minority Leader Eric Kearney, D-Cincinnati, are jointly sponsoring four pension reform bills — one for each of the four largest systems. Hearings began Tuesday and Niehaus said floor votes could come as soon as next week.

“It’s long overdue. Our pension plans are losing close to $2 million a day in savings while they wait for the General Assembly to act,” Kearney said.

“I’m not going to offer any excuses for inaction over the past three years. But what I am saying is that it is time to take action now,” Niehaus said.

In Ohio, state law prescribes most pension benefits for public employees. Pension fund boards have been pushing for less generous benefits as a way to shore up their finances. The Senate bills reflect the changes that pension boards requested.

Ohio Public Employees Retirement System Executive Director Karen Carraher said there are four factors driving the need for reforms: Baby Boomers retiring, people living longer in retirement, huge investment losses during the 2008 market downturn, and perks built into the systems over time that allow for abuses.

The OPERS reform bill takes aim at curbing abuses such as allowing elected officials to buy service credit at a discounted rate, giving full-time service credit for people working part-time and earning as little as $3,000 a year, and permitting workers to spike their pension benefits by landing big raises in the twilight years of their careers.

Often, it’s elected officials who are exploiting these perks in pension law to their own advantage. Some peaks and valleys in earnings are to be expected during a long career, but OPERS identified 770 “egregious spikers” whose beginning pension checks are at least six times more than their accumulated contributions into the system, Carraher said.

Pension benefits are calculated on the average of a worker’s three highest paid years. (The systems want to change it to the highest five years.)

Let’s say a township trustee earned $3,000 a year for many years and then moved to the General Assembly and earned $65,000 a year for four years before retiring. That trustee’s pension check would be based on $65,000 a year even though most of his contributions to the retirement system were based on $3,000 a year.

Niehaus said he supports the anti-spiking measure in OPERS’ plan.

A bill outlining reforms for the Ohio Highway Patrol Retirement System, the smallest of the five funds, is still in the works, he said.

While the Senate leaders are ready to move, it’s unclear what might happen in the Ohio House. State Rep. J. Kirk Schuring, R-Canton, urged his colleagues to delay pension reform until a consultant’s report is delivered this summer.

The consultant was hired to review proposals that the systems are pushing.

Union officials reached Tuesday said reforms are needed.

“We don’t bargain the retirement benefit.

“However, we think it’s wise for the legislature to adopt the OPERS’ board recommendations,” said Sally Meckling, communications director for OCSEA/AFSCME Local 11. “We recognize the difficult choices that must be made to ensure the retirement fund is solvent and that a health care benefit is retained.”

Jay McDonald, president of Fraternal Order of Police Ohio agreed.

“We recognize the pension systems need to make some changes and we are supportive of those changes,” McDonald said.

Contact this reporter at lbischoff @daytondailynews.com.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Community News

Black Friday deals: Here’s what we found today
Black Friday deals: Here’s what we found today

Shoppers are already out finding the best deals at big box retailers on Black Friday. Retailers like Target and Walmart opened last night on Thanksgiving, offering major deals for shoppers. Cabela’s opened again at 6 a.m. today, and gave away prizes to the first 600 customers in line. These are the best deals we’ve found so far:
Ohio lawmaker wants to limit child marriage
Ohio lawmaker wants to limit child marriage

Efforts to reform Ohio’s child marriage laws, which currently allow children of any age to marry if they obtain parental and judicial consent, could get tangled up in politics over gay marriage, lawmakers say. A Dayton Daily News investigation detailed more than 4,400 girls under 18 married in Ohio over the past 15 years, including 59 girls who...
Colin Kaepernick surprise guest at 'Unthanksgiving Day' on Alcatraz
Colin Kaepernick surprise guest at 'Unthanksgiving Day' on Alcatraz

Former San Francisco 49ers quarterback Colin Kaepernick made a surprise appearance at the Alcatraz Indigenous People's Sunrise Gathering on Thursday, The San Francisco Chronicle reported. A tradition in California since 1975, the annual dawn festivities, also known as Unthanksgiving Day, commemorate the occupation of Alcatraz by American...
Love sweets? 4 local candy shops to check out
Love sweets? 4 local candy shops to check out

Have a sweet tooth? So do we. Luckily for all of us, there are a slew of candy shops in the Miami Valley to check out. Here are some favorites.  (Pro Tip: Candy makes a great stocking stuffer.) They’re known for their gourmet cotton candy, but they’ve got several sweet treats to try, including Sweet Tart Chews, rock candy, gummies...
What Ohio wine pairs best with Wolverine meat? We have the answer!
What Ohio wine pairs best with Wolverine meat? We have the answer!

The Ohio State-Michigan football rivalry has been a wee bit lopsided in recent years — thank you, Urban Meyer, and thank YOU as well, Jim Harbaugh — so since this Buckeye fan and OSU alum has a keen interest in food and wine as well as football, that leads us to one and only one question as the two teams prepare to battle on Saturday: What...
More Stories